There are several sys out there big and small. Most of the big ones are too pricey for me. I want to go to the next level in my turning but not neccessarly
to the biggest sys there is. Whats a good decent medium size hollowing sys
out there at a decent price. I have used the hand held systems and they are
too rough for me as i have some shoulder problems. Byron
I'd recommend Monster Lathe Tools' Articulated Hollowing System or Don Derry's system. Both will run $300 to $475, the higher price being the Monster system for a full size lathe. Both are good systems, a nice fit and finish, and are very popular. Don's are available through him at derrytools.com and Monster's site is monster-lathe-tools.com
On all laser systems the laser needs to be moved around the cutter when vessels walls are cutting deferent angle to the tip of the cutter.
On this system you adjust the laser once to the center of the cutter. Then you turn a screw to set the wall thickness. With the cutter in the vessel you twist the laser it will form an arc you stop turning at the low point. As you work around the curve of the vessel you just find the new low point in the arc.
This laser allows you to readjust the laser without pulling tool from the vessel.
I have no connection to this company nor do I own any of their tools, but this seems to be in your price range. http://www.harrisonspecialties.com/simple-hollowing-system-with-or-without-carbide-tipped-turning-tool/
The Harrison rig looks OK for very small hollow forms like ornaments and such, but really under-built for anything larger than 4" or so...
I have a setup that's surely a knock-off of Lyle Jamieson's original, made by a friend of my dad. After hurting my right elbow using hand-held hollowers the wrong way, I accepted his offer to make me one. If I were starting afresh, I'd just get the real thing. (I've also learned how to use hand-held blind hollowing tools, too!)
Since Lyle's starter set is pretty close to $300, why not start with that? You can make a simple back-rest out of wood, and either replace it later, or stick with it.
As an added bonus, you get loads of free advice from Lyle right here at WoodCentral already, so it's a value added product
The more information you give us the better! You are really going to be restricted to smaller depth and size pieces with that price. I suggest you find someone with a welder, another guy with a metal lathe, go to Lyle Jamieson's site with the make your own instructions, and buy critical parts from him or Packard.
I went to Lyle Jamiesons web-site, used his instructions for making a copy of his system (thank you Lyle!) Cost for materials was around $80-$90. Friend had a torch, metal bandsaw and welding equipment. Took us about 5 hours to fabricate.
I do mostly hollow forms and this set up works well. Added a 1" boring bar so I can go about 15" deep.
what lathe are you wanting to use a hollowing system on?
what's the deepest you want to hollow?
what's the max diameter of a piece you might want to hollow?
how much clearance do you have behind you lathe?
how much room do you have behind the headstock?
have you figured out where you're going to store the device
AND accessories
do you want a range of diameters for the shanks
(3/8", 1/2" 3/4") ?
carbide, hss or what for the cutters?
laser?
Here's a link to a compendium of hollowing systems that were available several years ago. I'm usre more have come along since I put that stuff together.
Why not just hollow like many of us, with simple tools that your hands control?? It can and is done, daily, by those of us who take pride in our own skills. Yes, controlled systems work, and perhaps they are easier to us, but they take up space and cost money. Some famous turners, Trent Bosch for one, only uses a hand controlled system.
I built a copy of Lyles rig using 3/4" steel rod and connected them with short lengths of square tubing all held together with all thread and nuts. I used a short 3/4" I'd sleeve I got at lowes to hold the boring bars and held that on with 1/8" roll pins. No welding at all. Made the secondary tool rest out of wood. It worked so well I still use it but s did eventually weld it together.
Byron already stated that he is trying to avoid shoulder problems. I completely understand his approach after having become frustrated with hand hand tools of various designs. Like many of the others have already stated, Lyle Jamieson has very generously provided plans to build a simple system that works very well. I built one years ago for way less than $50 and it has served me well. I used a four foot length of one inch square steel tubing cut into sections and welded together. Support is two pieces of 1/2" cold rolled steel mounted on a wooden base that can be adjusted easily for different lathe heights. A 3/4" bar slides right into the square tubing and a nut brazed to the tubing and a bolt secures the bar. I purchased Lyle's tool holder at a workshop ten years ago and added the Hunter adaptation to it a couple of years ago.
Thanks for all the feedback and support from the captured system folks...even SteveA :-) kinda. I sent a direct note to Byron offering my help. There are lots of folks still using hand held hollowing boring bars. Even when you get good at it, they are still hard work and working blind in there is no fun. My system is still hand controlled. All the excitement, design, and creativity is on the outside of the hollow form. The inside---is just get the wood out of there without beating up my body.
Before you select a hollowing system, you need to really decide what you want to hollow. Different systems have different size ranges. I have many hollowing tools that enable me to hollow ornaments to vessels up to about 15". Some of these are individual tools. Some are sets. Most require a handle of some sort. For captured systems, I have the Derry system and Lyle's system.
I've had the Derry system for about 10 years. It is excellent for vessels in the 5" to around 11" size. The system is designed to be used in either reverse or forward rotation. I use it in reverse so that the handle is close to me instead of reaching across the lathe. This does place the laser dot on the back side of the vessel. I use a simple bathroom mirror to watch the laser dot on the back side when it goes over the far side of the vessel. The laser has two screws to adjust the orientation of the laser dot in relation to the cutting tip.
For larger vessels up to maybe 15", I use Lyle's system or an Exocet cutting tool (I do not think you can get these anymore). I don't make large vessels that often, so I don't use either that much. My negative comment about Lyle's system is more about my lathe set-up than his tool system. I have a Stubby lathe in a rather confined space. For me in my shop, it is rather difficult to set up the capture system in my limited space so I tend to shy away from using it.
Before you buy any system, I HIGHLY recommend that you try them out. Visit a friend or borrow a tool. Even at your budget, the "low" cost of $300, a hollowing tool system is a big investment and you can end up not liking the tool. Being the tool junkie that I am, I have a lot of hollowing tools - probably dozens. I do wish that I had some of that cash back.
My hollowing goes as follows:
2"-3": Packard mini hollowers. Jordan's mini tools. Maybe start to use the small (not mini) McNaughton set.
3"-6": McNaughton small hollowing set (1/2") and Jordan 1/2" set.
5" to 11": Derry system almost exclusively.
8" to 15": Exocet, Jordan 3/4" in the Stewart/Scorpion armbrace (I have parts from both), or Jordan in Jamieson system.
Hope this helps. BTW, I live in San Diego if you need to try some tools for yourself. The weather doesn't suck here in the winter :-)
Lyle, perfectly said. The artistic value is the outside form. Inside, you are just pulling out chips.
As to Philip's comment about the pros, he is correct. However, when I have talked to most about why they use what they use, most found a system that worked for them and then never experimented. They are in "production" mode and don't have time to fiddle with new gadgets. If you talk to Lyle or Don, they will tell you that they switched to captured systems in no small part to the physical toll that hand-held tools were taking on their bodies and shoulders.