Doesn't matter which dot you use as long as you use the same one each time. The only laser pointers I've seen that had different symbols or dots Han interchangeable tips. Perhaps the tip has simply come unscrewed a little and is refocusing the spot
If the front lens is getting loose, it could be giving you a goofy image with a primary spot and an off-axis reflection (?) Maybe you can see if the front element will snug up, or is the tiny lens is now held in there at an odd angle. Pretty understandable given the vibration that these things deal with.
If you remove the cutting tip from the vessel, and adjust the light using a white card, you should still be fine, as Bill suggests -- just be sure to remember which arrow or dot you are using.
I use one of the quarter size rare earth magnets painted white with a line and makings for wall thickness. Then I just attach the magnet to the tool tip and adjust the angle to be perpendicular to the side where I'm cutting. Then I adjust the laser
If the laser (like mine) has a tip, take it off. The tip is interchangeable with different symbols on them. Just take it off, it is usually only cosmetic.
two arrows sounds like there is a lens on the laser. A lot of laser pointer type lasers will come with different lenses. Like Lyle says, see if it is removable to it's dot.