Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Glue block process

Posts

Glue block process

#1

Lyle Jamieson

Glue block process

Lyle Jamieson

There has been many good suggestions that work and many reports of failures. There are a lot of ways to hold wood on the lathe but I use glue blocks and faceplates and never use chucks. The reason I use CA glue, thick CA glue, is for strength and speed. The sheer strength of a properly executed glue block is enormous. I believe Betty is correct that this process is safer then a chuck. Yet it is brittle so it transfers the power without vibration. Hot melt glue will work for relatively small turnings but will result in vibration limitations with larger work of when you might want to pour the coal to it and turn faster. The other glues have a longer waiting period. I have used this process for decades and never have failures, even with very large, natural edge bowls with voids. http://youtu.be/y8b35iq4LTA http://youtu.be/rbZXEBIHVOU

Re: Glue block process

#2

Thanks! (and a ??)

mjonesrdg

I think that most of us, over a period of years, will accumulate a box of tenons...the result of parting off from various work pieces. I go to my box from time to time and pick one for use as a glue block to be held by a chuck. My several face plates have not come out of the drawer for a very long time.

I remain curious, from an earlier post, your aversion to using plywood for glue blocks. The few times that I have used a faceplate/glueblock combination, the only negative that I could see was the tendency of plywood to splinter a bit when rounding it up.

what am I missing? (Nice video! Thanks!)

Re: Glue block process

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Thanks! (and a ??)

Lyle Jamieson

I have had glue blocks that have been on the same dedicated faceplate for many years. I use them over and over again. I would never use plywood. I don't trust the glue lines. There can and will be air pockets and glue voids in there. When you clean up the glue after use for the next bowl you get splintering. Using the concave mating surface, it cuts through from layer to layer and splinters. All this can cause vibration at best and the possibility of something flying off the lathe. You cant get 5/4 or 6/4 plywood so that would mean gluing multiple pieces of plywood. Yuck, more room for error.

I use a hard tight grain wood like hard maple when I can. It transfers the power with more stability and strength and will last for dozens of bowls.

Re: Glue block process

#4

Re: Glue block process

Steve Kniffen

Lyle, can you elaborate on why you never use chucks? I've been turning for less than 5 years now so I'm still new. One of the first things i heard from everyone was that I needed an assortment of chucks and jaws. I'd like to hear more about why you prefer faceplates and glue blocks. Steve

Re: Glue block process

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Glue block process

Lyle Jamieson

Here is another Youtube clip to help define some elements. http://youtu.be/VlZ81aDfcxc I have 40 of then on Youtube. The whole picture is in my Bowl Basics DVD.

The short answer is the chucks have limitations. I want to open up possibilities not limit them. Anything that limits my access, scale, design or creativity drives me crazy. A chuck does not fail but it is grabbing a sponge and the compressed fibers will lead to vibration --at best-- and danger of pulling the wood off the chuck. I use a faceplate with lots of screws for ALL hollow forms and large bowls, and use a faceplate with my CA glue up process for most bowls. You could buy a new lathe for what many people have paid for multiple chucks and a steady rest...that I seldom use either. The only time I use a chuck (I did not buy it, it came with a lathe I purchased) is to put a waste block in for reverse chucking with friction drive. At that point I'm done with turning and just cleaning up the bottom that sits on the table.

Re: Glue block process

#6

Re: Glue block process

Ed Larson

Lyle, in your video you mention the 40% rule for chucks for the tenon size. Do you have a rule of thumb for glue blocks?? What size glue block would you use for a 16 inch bowl??

Re: Glue block process

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Glue block process

Lyle Jamieson

The size of the glue block and faceplate would be the same 40 percent rule. I would use a 5 or 6 inch faceplate with a 6 inch glue block for a 16 inch bowl.

One of the criticisms of using glue blocks was the glue line fails after a period of time. This is correct. As the turned piece shrinks or warps from drying it will weaken or break the glue line. This will happen no matter what holding method you use. As wood dries it shrinks and there will be problems if you leave the roughed piece on the lathe too long. I always try to have time to go from start to finish in one setting. If I have to walk away from a piece half done I put a plastic bag on it to help stop the moisture loss and save the glue line. Then get back to finish turn it real soon. If you are double turning I always remove it from the lathe to dry off the glue block or faceplate. I always start the roughed out piece after it dries and shrinks, between centers, to orient the piece on the axis that will get me back in balance. It will be oval and distorted, so putting it back on the same axis as it started might not work, depending on the shrink rate of the wood variety.

Re: Glue block process

#8

Very sound advice

Geoff Whaling

If only more turners would listen to turners like Lyle. Vibration, harmonics & movement are major issues when turning.

Chucks can create more problems than they solve when not used appropriately either contributing to movement & vibration or initiating the shear of wood in tennons. The use of inappropriately sized & often poorly made tennons which are limited by jaw sizes available to the turner cause failures through overtightening - just to be sure..

The things I like most with glue blocks is the flexibility and safety they offer. Start off with a massive glueblock while rough turning then turn away the glueblock to reduce its size as the piece becomes more delicate.

Very few pieces will genuinely fail at a well made glue joint - the timber usually fails either side of the glue joint. The problems attributed to the use of glue blocks are more related to inappropriate material choice, like cheap plywoods. I learned a valuable lesson years ago after a 6" bowl parted company from the lathe & shattered. That very nice pink silky oak makes for a nice trim colour but is to soft, open grained and useless as a tennon.

Re: Glue block process

#9

Re: Thanks! (and a ??)

steve worcester

A lot of glue block failures are related to the block type (dry hardwoods are better than no grain MDF) and the glue.

Yellow glue will fail with ripping the grain out ( a wood failure) and the glue. In the instance of a glue block, it will fail the same. CA gets brittle over time, so turning after a day of curing will yield different results than after a month or a year, and the type of CA.

Flexible CA while it may not hold as fast, will allow better results than "stock" CA. I turn a lot of pieces with a CA attachment of the wood to a Poplar (my wood of choice because it is cheaper) and have discovered that stock CA is good for a month or so but flexible CA will allow more vibration and catches than stock CA.

But also, CA has a diminishing lifetime in this situation. CA has only about a 12 month shelf life. Disregard whatever you have read about storage in the fridge, etc. It isn't archival in any means I have found, even more so in finished turnings. Dont use it to fill a gap your children might use.

Just my $.02

Re: Glue block process

#10

Lyle Jamieson

A different view

Lyle Jamieson

Steve, my experience is a bit different. Correct, failures can be due to the wood used for a glue block. No plywood, no MDF, no pine 2x4's. Always use dry wood for the glue block. Always use side grain orientation not end grain. We need the stability of dry wood to start with for the glue block.

CA is brittle from the start. That is a good thing because it will not contribute to vibration. That is a good thing because all you need to do to get the piece off the glue block is break the glue joint with a chisel. It is unbelievable how much strength it has to hold the wood but how easy it comes off with a blow from the chisel. I never use a parting tool to separate them. Its not the CA that fails over time it is the turned wood is drying and moving and the glue block is not moving.

I use stock CA but never leave it on the block for more then a few hours. 24 hours is all it takes to have the wet wood dry and move enough to weaken or break the glue line. If you leave a wet piece on the glue block for a few days it might be on the floor when you get back to the lathe. The joint will fail completely. All this assumes you are starting with wet wood. A dry glue block on a dry turning blank will hold and last a long long time.