Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

How Far Do You Stray From The Familiar?

Posts

How Far Do You Stray From The Familiar?

#1

How Far Do You Stray From The Familiar?

charlie belden

We tend to stick with the familiar, doing things we know how to do. Conversely, we tend to shy away from the unfamiliar and resist trying things that seems to have a steep learning curve.

Small steps in the direction towards where you think you want to go may get you there. And you may end up there eventually. You'll also know more about the path you've taken probably better than anyone else on the planet. Incremental refinements to an idea can result in finer and finer pieces. That's definiitely a good thing. "Practice makes perfect" is true - unless - you're practicing the wrong thing, bad proportions, bad techniques, bad finishing methods, . . .

But when you step away from the familiar and start trying things you dont know how to do - yet - things can get quite interesting. You may find that the Steep Learning Curve you thought was there, may not be all that steep. or not steep at all.

Jack Of All Trades, Master Of None - or - Master Of One - or - somewhere between the two. Where do you fall on that continuim and how do you see your turning journey?

I tend to lean towards the Jack of All Trades --but that could just be a matter of a short attention span and a curiosity that gets me going in a lot of different directions - sometimes at the same time.

Re: How Far Do You Stray From The Familiar?

#2

Ellis Walentine

***Looks like an Ides question to me!***

Ellis Walentine

This is about our personal approach to creativity and would make a fine survey question for our "News & Views" column in Woodworker West magazine. So, let's do it. I'll post it on the other boards, too.

Personally, I think of everything I make as a solution to a design problem. I usually start with a framework for solving the problem at hand, along with my peculiar set of skills and tastes. When turning, I have fewer functional design constraints, so I tend to gravitate to shapes that I subjectively see in the wood, which tend to be pretty consistent. But, if the design problem I set for myself requires a decorative or functional aspect, I do whatever it takes. Figuring stuff out is very satisfying to me.

Ellis

Re: How Far Do You Stray From The Familiar?

#3

Re: How Far Do You Stray From The Familiar?

Dale Gillaspy

I tend to lean towards the master of none side of the spectrum. Although I would hope I fall somewhere in between, because there are a few things I think I do well. I tend to replicate small lidded boxes, bird houses, and hollow forms, because they are good sellers, but I get very bored if I do production runs of things, so I am always looking for the next thing to spark my imagination and incorporate something new into my work.

Re: How Far Do You Stray From The Familiar?

#4

Alan Zenreich

Re: How Far Do You Stray From The Familiar?

Alan Zenreich

I like being competent on a wide variety of topics and skills. Mastering any one of them, not likely.

Re: How Far Do You Stray From The Familiar?

#5

Steven Antonucci

ADHD and , oooh,, shiny!

steven antonucci

I will typically get very good at one thing at a time by devoting all of my free time towards it. In some cases, you cannot overcome your own limitations no matter how much time you spend... and you simply cannot get better. In other cases, you might get more runway or be able to move the ball in different directions.

When I played basketball, it didn't matter how much time I spent. I simply would never be able to dunk. Small hands and short shins meant I had to jump higher than I would ever be able to jump, so it would just never happen. In woodturning, some folks may never get to be Michael Jordan, and they will be happy playing 3 on 3 pick-up games on Saturday morning against whoever shows up.

Personally, the more things I can do at a competent level, the easier it becomes to do things I don't yet know how to do. I went from basketball to competitive cycling for a couple of years, because the leap (pun intended) was small. I went from cycling to photography... and the leap was enormous. Chemistry, composition, equipment... none relied on leg strength or conditioning.

In my making career, turning has taught me to be competent with tools, metalworking, and problems solving. I bounce between things and often find that I know how to do things that I cannot do...but knowing how to do things and being able to do them are not the same thing! Dunking a basketball is simple... jump high, and throw the ball through the hoop. It is the doing that excites me.

Steve