Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Anybody build prototypes

Posts

Anybody build prototypes

#1

Anybody build prototypes

John Lucas

I don't do it very often but have started doing it for some things to help get the concept down better or to have a better idea of how things work or how much wood to leave for carving. I often do for furniture that I can't visualize very well or need to work on the dimensions. Not so much for turning although Barbara's latest piece shows what either turning multiples in a series or possibly making test pieces which really aren't that far off doing a prototype.

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#2

Steven Antonucci

On things with multiple parts or multiples

steven antonucci

If I have a plan to make something that requires assembly, I might prototype it to make sure I know how things will be put together. Everything works on paper, not so much in reality.

The other place I might prototype is in a process. If I was going to make one of something, it probably doesn't make a lot of sense to prototype it. However, when you want to make multiples, it might from two perspectives. The first perspective is time, and being able to do things efficiently. The second perspective is repeatability, and not having 10 things that sort of look like the same thing...but sort of don't when you put them together.

I have a project in my head where I have failed at V1.0 to produce the thing that I need. It requires being able to produce 100's of the same thing, with two variations. Variation one is simple, Variation #2 is more complex. If I think about it, I may only need variation #2? When you are making hundreds of something, it pays to validate your assumptions.

Steve

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#3

On somethings I do....

Greg Haugen

...things like "kitless" pens I will. Acetal rod is a little over a dollar a foot compared to ebonite or italian lucite at $1 to $2 an inch. I'll mock up a couple of options,get the measurements that I like, and make one or two out of the acetal rod and then make the final components out of the requested material.

Most things out of wood, I may use a sketch but not prototypes usually. Especially one-offs, if I don't like it it will go on the s'mores wood pile. For works that are in a series though, the first one (if it's intended or not) usually becomes "prototype" status and it never leaves. #2 on up go out into the world for new owners.

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#4

Alan Sweet

Re: On somethings I do....

Alan Sweet

I frequently will experiment with a wood working idea before actually applying it. Usually the idea has merit but needs to be fleshed out or modified. I will build betas or protos to test an ideas validity. Most of the time I can work on an idea out of the scrap pile and not have to invest anything except my time. But, that is considered almost fun in my case. :)

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re:I do.....

Jesper, Denmark

My main interest in turning is shape, so having an idea of a good shape, a sketch does not show it as well as a three dimensional prototype - which often gets to be many - before I think I have the right one.

............and then they seem to keep changing :)

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Anybody build prototypes

Keith Tompkins

Hey John, I frequently build maquettes, or models of a piece I'm contemplating turning. Sometimes I make a handful of models just to visualize, then use the best ideas in the final piece.

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#7

Do Virtual 3D Prototypes Count

charlie belden

Since I like to do Wild Hare Idea pieces that often require parts too fit inside, under or on, other parts - and often move, it's a lot easier to do prototypes in Google's free SketchUp 3D modeling program. With it I can create To Scale virtual 3D models of the components and find potential problems, make adjustments and correct or work around them - and when I'm done I have all the dimensions on print outs of different views. I also have images of what the part or turned piece SHOULD look like as a reference while turning the actual piece. Helps to see where you want to go and compare it with where you are. It's also easier to erase what you don't want - than cutting all the wood you don't want off.

Doing multiple axes / multi axis pieces can be a hit or miss thing, even if you understand the fundamental concepts - parallel, intersecting and crossing axes. For parallel axes turniing you can work out where the centers are to be and what each profile should look like in 2D. But when you want to do intersecting or crossing axes (the latter putting a twist in the piece), 2D is totally inadequate. For intersecting axes and crossing axes, SketchUp can do pretty well, You can create the profile for each axis, generate a "turned" 3D model of each - with centers and axes - overlap them and remove all of each profile that is not in the overlapped volume. With the free SketchUp this process is semi=tedious, but there apparently is a "plugin" that lets you do Boolean operations on 3D objects - the one I'm trying to get does the AND operation - isolating the part of each profile that is within the overlapped volume created when two turned objects are overlapped. Without this plugin it takes about 15 to 20 minutes to erase everything that isn't "common to both". With the plugin it's 5 seconds.

I've been creating viritual 3D models of several of Barbara Dill's MA pieces. Once created, I can view the piece from any angle and any distance, color surfaces done on each axis to see them more clearly and have the relative locaions of the centers on each end of the blank and thus the axes - at 1:1 scale, or any scale I chose. I can also create virtual 3D models of each major step in the turning process, make prints, and see what I'm supposed to have for each step of the turninig process - to scale.

I've got about 10 hours into what will be a 20 minute video on fundamental concepts of MA turning and the process of designing MA pieces using the free version of SketchUp. All the animation is being done in SketchUp, video screen captured at 1080p and imported in to iMovie where the video editing is then done. I'm using the idea Peter Rand used to create a piece he entitled "Femme Noir" as an example of what can be done with MA turning - and how to DESIGN it and do variations of it. Will post a link to the YouTube video when I get this one done.

Having a virtual 3D model of a worked out idea is very useful. An ACTUAL 3D model would be even better. The price of 3D printers keeps dropping and their capabilities keep getting better and better - much like computers, only at a faster rate.

It's fun to just chuck up a chunk of wood and start turning with only a vague idea of where I want to go and wing it from there. But some ideas take a bit of planning , and because I turn mainly dry wood, take a fair amount of time to turn and finish. If the plan is to do the Real Piece in a precious piece of wood, a prototype in an easy wood to get is usually the way I'll go.

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#8

Re: Anybody build prototypes

Peter Rand

I almost always do prototypes. Even after experience with several possibilities and complexities of multiaxis turning I still need a prototype to unfold what might happen if I attempt something new. And now with slicing such pieces it is even more necessary since moving/rotating the slices adds to the unpredictability. Sketching doesn’t help me at all – perhaps the 3D method Charlie is developing will help but that is quite an investment. Besides I find prototypes are fun – quick and fun, little investment, zero 'tension' :-)

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#9

Re: Anybody build prototypes

John lucas

I'd have to prototype the prototype if I tried your work

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#10

Re: Anybody build prototypes

Peter Rand

......maybe that's what I'm doing!!!

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#11

SketchUp's Free - working on flattening the learni

charlie belden

Peter (and anyone else into or getting into MultiAxis Turning (MAT))

The 3D modeling software, SketchUp, is free and available for Windows, Mac OSX and Linux.

Like any tool that's made as a Solution Looking For Problems To Solve (an old HP ad campaign for their programmable pocket "caculators"), it has a lot of Whistles & Bellls and you'd have to climb a very steep learning curve to be able to use them all - for everything. Like eating a pie, if you try and eat it ALL, it's upsetting. But - IF - you start with a small piece of the pie - it's satisfyng. And you can always go back for Seconds if you're still hungry.

For turners - of ROUND - creating a profile and then "turning" that profile into a Virtual 3D object is pretty easy. There are plenty of YouTube videos on how to do that and in half an hour you could learn to do that - create profile - "turn" it. And once you've got a virtual 3D model of the idea, you can copy it and tweek it - "stretch it" - just vertically, just horizontally or any combination you want.

Once you can create a profile and "turn" it, you can create a profile for each axis you want to turn on, "turn" each one into a 3D model and start overlapping them - which is what you do when working in MAT (Multi Axis Turning) - and SEE the "outcome" from any vantage point you choose.

Here is an example of how to use SketchUp for creating Virtual Prototypes.



1. For this example I'm going with a "bead" profile for each axis

2. Offset one of the bead profiles a half bead diameter up or down

3. Take HALF of each profile and offset the axis that it will be turned on. You'll see why in the next step

4. Overlap the two profiles so that the "common volume" includes HALF of your two bead profiles

5. Copying each of the profiles from Step 3, "turn" each one to create Virtual 3D models of the turned form.

6. Copy the "overlapped" 2D version from Step 5 and move the centerlines of your 3D models so that its axis lines up with its 2D axis

7. "Intersect" the two 3D overlapped models to get the their "common volumes" - which will be the "outcome" that would be turned on the two axes.

If the two axes parallel each other the "outcome" shown in 7a will be the result.

If you slant the axes in opposite directions - in the same plane - they will INTERSECT - and you'll get a tapered version of 7a - roundest where the axes are closest together, more lens shaped as they get farther apart.

If you slant the axes in opposite directions - but in two separate planes - you get a tapered result like 7b - BIT - with a twist in it.

Now to a Top View



On the left (5) we've got the two 3D models of our two profiles.

6a shows how they'll overlap - and - the lens shape cross section of the "common volume" IF the two axes are PARALLEL TO EACH OTHER

7a shows the resulting "outcome"

Now here's what prototyping with Virstual 3D models can do for you - quck and relatively easy VARIATIONS

(think word processor or PhotoShop)

6b uses copies of our orignal Virtual 3 D turned profiles.

By "tilting" the axis of each in opposite directions relative to each other and THEN overlapping them, we get a TAPERED version of the PARALLEL AXES piece - fattest and most round where the axes are closest together, narrower and more lens shaped as the axes get farther apart.

Here's where it gets interesting - and something you CAN'T do in just 2D - TWIST.

Copy the "slanting" overlapped models of 6b

6c. Now offset one of the axes "planes" away from the other.

The axes "tilt" gives us a Taper AND a TWIST shown in 7c - which happens to be a Counter ClockWise Twist. Had the Blue Axis been offset in the opposite direction ,the result would be a ClockWise Twist

OK, now let's look at things from a diffent vantage pont - something SketchUp and other 3D modeling apps let you do that you can't do with simple 2D CAD.


Look at 7a, 7b and 7c.

Notice how 7b and 7c differ from 7a - they taper and 7a doesn't. 7b and 7c are fatter at the bottom and thinner at the top.

Also notice that the "lens" shape cross section starts getting flatter (not fatter but fLatter) when you tilt the two axesin opposite directions.

Finally, though it's tricky to see, that 7c has a TWIST to it. You can go from almost no twist to almost a 180 degree, or half twist" by changing the distance between the two "axes planes" Farther apart, MORE TWIST, closer together LESS TWIST.

Once you've got the profiles worked out and the resulting Virtual 3D "turning" done

, you can do variations in 15 minutes or so - and not be ankle deep in chips and shavings - and not used ANY wood - yet.

In addition to letting you SEE the "outcome" of an idea, this method lets you work out where the centers of each axis should be on you blank, shows you what the "outcome" should look like so you'll recognize it while turning to get it AND - what you did is Self Documenting - assuming you saved the file of the SketchUp Model(s) - and can find the file later (use descriptive file names - in this case I went with "Dill_MoonRising..."

Questions, comments, suggestions all welcomed.

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#12

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Anybody build prototypes

#13

Re: Fig 3 that didn't upload in previous post

RCH

I see a picture of two syringes -- not quite what you intended?

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#14

Re: Fig 3 that didn't upload attempt 2

charlie belden

Not the first time this has happened. I upload an image, preview my message - everything looks good - I hit post - and ASSUME that what I saw in the preview actually got posted. In the future I'll check and make SURE that's the case.


Re: Anybody build prototypes

#15

Re: Anybody build prototypes

Barbara

I make many small prototypes of various possibilities of multi axis spindles. Charlie and I have talked for years about using sketch up as a way to visualize MA turning. I have spent some time playing with sketch up and have decided that I'm better at playing on the lathe than on the computer. I am in awe of Charlie's persistence with mapping complex ideas in 3D. It is difficult to share ideas an clearly communicate about MA work and Charlie is onto something!!

Re: Anybody build prototypes

#16

Re: Anybody build prototypes

John Lucas

I agree Barbara It's far easier for me to just go out and build something. I can learn to "see" what is happening when I can put it on the lathe. On multi axis work I may make a sketch to better see the angles that I need to mount the work but until I make shavings I don't always understand how the 2 angles work together.