Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

Posts

Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#1

Steven Antonucci

Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

steven antonucci

It's not terribly gory, but if you dare, follow this link to see why you never wear long sleeves at a lathe.

Skip ahead to the 3:00 minute mark if you are impatient. Realize that the lathe he is turning on is a metal lathe, and turning very slowly. A wood lathe will not have the same torque, but will be spinning much faster...

Steve


Little bit of horror, but not bloody.

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#2

Ouch!


Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#3

Re: Video of a lathe accident

Dale Gillaspy

I'm going out on a limb to say that it wasn't the long sleeves, but the looseness of the sleeves at the wrist. Add to that his stance and the way he was working, and the multiple other safety issues in the video, including not being able to turn the lathe off for 40 seconds (and 3 people) after the incident. (Notice I did not say accident.) It wasn't an accident, it was carelessness.

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#4

Re: Video of a lathe accident

Bill Howatt

I agree. However the task he was performing looked pretty mundane and did not have any of the obvious warning signals like sharp cutter, rotating corners, etc.

Bill

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#5

Steven Antonucci

at what point is a sleeve too loose?

steven antonucci

I think that in general, the best way to lower the risk of accidents at the lathe is to weigh the risk/reward of decisions and choose the lesser of two evils.

I see no particular advantage to wearing long sleeves at the lathe, other than warmth? If you shop is cold, long sleeves may make sense if they are tight fitting. I always push them up away from my wrists if I am turning in long sleeves.

98 times out of 100, I will take off the long sleeves to remove that risk entirely. I've had a glove get pulled into a mandrel while winding wire into a coil. Power button at my knee if I need to kick it off hands free. On a Nova lathe, the motor will free spool. On a Oneway, you have a couple of seconds of pain coming your way.

S

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#6

I had already planned...

GaryG in MD

...to use "wrap it up" as my December Safety Tip for MCW -- for obvious reasons -- but you've given me a very instructive additional bonus. Thanks, GG

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#7

Re: Video of a lathe accident

walta

Total carelessness.

5 of the 6 workers have on long sleeves and only one has them rolled up.

I feel all gloves are just as dangerous.

Walta

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#8

Re: Video of a lathe accident

Geoff Whaling

Lucky man! Though he seems to have facial & other injuries.

Its a well known hazard - safety alert from 1995

http://www.labour.gov.on.ca/english/hs/pubs/alerts/i07.php

& just keeps popping up

http://www.commerce.wa.gov.au/worksafe/PDF/Safety_alerts/2012/08-2012_Emery_cloth_tape_metal_working_lathes.pdf

There are a number of hazards in that clip that have potentially high to catastrophic risk that any half decent shop foreman or safety inspector should issue a stop work order on. Very poor housekeeping - stock material on the floor (trip hazard); thoroughfare to tools cabinet - distractions, bumping/falling into lathe moving parts; even the way the machinist is manually holding & using the sand paper on the bar stock. First rescuer puts himself in danger too! Then to top it off no one isolates the lathes power supply during the rescue (turned off but not isolated) to prevent an accidental startup during the rescue.

There was a death not that long back from an unsupported bar fed thru the headstock (outboard) flailing about and striking the machinist. This could easily have ended in a similar manner on the inboard side.

There are numerous instances of de-gloved hands, broken arms, amputated body parts & deaths - but machinists still hand hold long lengths of emery cloth.

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#9

Re: Video of a lathe accident

Geoff Whaling

have a look at http://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/eis2.pdf

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#10

Incidents or accidente happen

Sergio

Incidents or accidents they do happen. Prevention (clothings etc) is certain important but a stop bar like the one the Vicmarc lathe has is for me essential and one of the reasons why I bought one.

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#11

OK, So Why...

Don Orr

...do turning suppliers sell mostly long sleeve turning smocks???

I use a windbreaker from a thrift store that my wife sewed the sleeves down the length to tighten them. Slippery so chips don't stick and other things don't grab either. That's not to say it COULDN'T happen, but I think the risk is significantly reduced.

I don't think this video is from the USA. But I did not dig to find out.

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#12

Steven Antonucci

great question... no idea...

steven antonucci

presumably, the inconvenience of having wood shaving hit your arm outweighs the risk of having your arm pulled into a chuck? Go figure...

I know I am nowhere near as sharp as I used to be. Last thing I want to do is introduce another way to get hurt into the shop environment. I cannot think of a single reason to wear long sleeves at a lathe except warmth?

S

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#13

Re: great question... no idea...

robo hippy

Well, it might be for those who are sensitive to some woods and need to keep exposure to a minimum. I am in short sleeves and shorts all year long. One of those hot people.

robo hippy

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#14

Keeping warm is highly desirable.....

JamieDonaldson

...in my shop during much of my turning seasons! I don't have any overt concern about long sleeves being a safety hazard in my turning processes. ;)

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#15

Re: great question... no idea...

Don Evans

Way in the back of my mind (which is a scary place) I think I remember some type of lotion or cream you can put on for contact dermititis.

Don't have a clue to a name for it. If it works, that would allow turning with no sleeves.

On the video did anyone notice what he was standing on? Some loose boards just laying there which gave way under his feet, the poor sap didn't have a chance.

Also the video was from Turkey I read in the comments below it.

The place was an accident waiting to happen and I also wonder WHY there happened to be a video camera there to capture it?

Don

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#16

Re: Keeping warm is highly desirable.....

Don Evans

I'm really spoiled with 1.5 ton of heat pump with 15kw of backup coils. It's 550 square feet.

I spent many cold hours in the garage shop some years ago though.

Don

Re: Video of a lathe accident *LINK*

#17

Being cold can be a hazard too.

Geoff Whaling

Being cold can be a hazard too. Judgement is affected in cold conditions. Every thing we do at the lathe presents a hazard/s and carries a level of risk so we learn about hazards to make informed judgements to balance the risk.

Does the hazard of being cold outweigh the hazard of entanglement? I would say yes. The potential entanglement hazard from long sleves can be minimised significantly by ensuring the sleves are close fitting and that there is no dangling threads or damage etc & by using recommended methods to "work safely".

In the video that started this discussion off there were a number of hazards present. Unfortunately for the worker those hazards combined to create an environment that resulted in his entanglement injury. One that easily could have been life threatening. Most likely if the worker had continued to use the emery paper in the recommended manner & had not been distracted the entanglement hazard may have been avoided alltogether.

The real lesson here is how small seemingly low risk tasks can combine to create what can be a life threatening hazard within an instant.