Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

Posts

how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

#1

how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

Dick McNeill

I've not had success sanding out imperfections or tear out on the end grain of ash. My skill level is not up to turning out the tear out even with a sharpened bowl gouge. I began sanding with 60 grit discs to no avail. How would you recommend that I go about sanding the end grain on a stationary lathe with a power tool. I've attempted this but I always end up gouging the bowl. Any Info greatly appreciated.

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

#2

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

Barry Irby

Welcome to Wood Central. I am in a bit of a hurry, so pardon the brief answer.

I use a regular corded drill with a two or three inch Velcro sanding pad. I lock the spindle and sand the two spots where I have trouble with tear out. I sand them as little as I can to get rid of the tear out and then turn the lathe on very slow and sand progressively through the grits. This tends to blend the harshly sanded areas. This is on bowls.

There are techniques you should try to reduce tear out. Very sharp tools is a good start. Learning to shear scrap is a good idea. Wetting the bowl works for some people. Observe where the tear out is prominent and you might have luck soaking those areas with lacquer. Or dish detergent. Think through what you will use for finish and don't "contaminate" the bowl.

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

#3

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

John lucas

Good suggestions above. I find newer turners tend to force the cut. After you sharpen make a concerted effort to slow down the forward push. Try to feel the wood being cut.

When I have serious tearout I use a cabinet scraper with the lath off to sort of carve out the tearout. I use a curves scraper. It ha the advantage of being a le to fake out the sides of the divot created by carving out the tearout. It also doesn't leave the lumps created by sanding the hard and soft grain changes

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

Brad Vietje

Big thumbs, small keyboard, John ;)

Dick: I like the suggestions so far, but would also suggest working with a finer grained wood than Ash. Ring porous woods such as Ash and Oak can be tougher to get a good smooth cut off the tool. If you use Sugar Maple or Black Cherry (or a dozen or so other woods), you might get less tear-out and chatter.

If you look up "power sanding" you should find good information. I do this with the lathe running slowly in one direction, and the abrasive running fast in the opposite direction. Usually the abrasive is a hook & loop variety mounted on a 2" or 3" foam-backed pad. If the lathe rotation can be reversed, it's good idea to either sand with each grit in both directions, or switch from forward to reverse with each grit size.

You'll find that with a little practice, the sort of tear-out you experience now will be a thing of the past. Tiny adjustments in tool presentation, bowl profiles, and a gentle touch go a long way, and a little very gentle shear scraping can get rid of a lot of tearout. Chances are the bevel is coming off the wood just enough to initiate a coarse scraping cut, or perhaps the cut direction is the issue. With a side-grain bowl, the smoothest cut will be from the rim to the center on the inside, and the foot up to the rim on the outside.

Good luck, and hang in there -- it will get better.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

#5

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

John Lucas

Dick I've been playing a lot with ways to get rid of tearout in the last few years. Some woods tearout a little even with the sharpest tools because we are forced to turn up hill against the grain.

What I've found is that it is much faster to get rid of a tearout area with the lathe off. Concentrate on just that area and then blend the divot created by excessive sanding by gradually expanding the circle of where you sand.

What I think is happening when you sand with the lathe running is the sandpaper bounces over that area. You can sand till your blue in the face and it will still be there so you step down to lower grits trying to get it out. Then you have to sand away all those scratch marks.

When I sand in one area I can usually use a smaller grit size than if I power sand and it seems to get rid of it faster.

For bad tearout on something like punky wood I still prefer to use the rounded cabinet scraper . Concentrate on the torn area working in several directions. Once it's about gone gradually increase the size of the area you are working on. Normally I can start sanding at 180 grit once these areas are repaired and can usually go back to sanding with the bowl rotating if I turn the rpm's down. I think it's faster than power sanding with course grits and doesn't produce the ripple of hard and soft grain areas like sandpaper does.

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

#6

No Tearout, No Problem.....

Wally Dickerman

There are two things that will guarantee tearout. A dull tool..always. Cutting against the grain..always. Cut WITH the grain with sharp tools.

Using 60 grit will give you an out of round bowl in no time. It takes a lot of sanding to get rid of 60 grit scratches.

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

#7

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

ron bauer

In addition to all the great advice given above I have very good luck with a air operated random orbit sander while the lathe is stopped. The 2" pad seems to work best. You can start at 120 or 150 grit, make fast progress and get minimum swirl marks. Don't pause long in one spot and follow Johns advice on feathering out. The small disc works well inside and out.

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

#8

Re: how do u sand a turning on a stationary lathe

robo hippy

Reducing sanding is what all cutting technique is about. No one likes to sand. Some woods will tear no matter what you do, and the idea is to reduce it to manageable levels. Especially with dry woods, tear out can be reduced by wetting the wood and taking light cuts with a high shear angle. Water or oil can be used. wet the wood, let it soak for maybe a minute, and turn off the wet wood.

Of course, if your tools are dull, it doesn't make any difference what you do with them as they will not cut clean.

After I am done with the gouge, I use a shear scraper. This means a freshly sharpened scraper with a good burr on it. Never flat on the tool rest, but up on its side at a 45 or higher angle. Very light pull cuts. This usually gets tear out down to manageable levels.

If you are having to resort to 60 grit to get rid of tear out, this most likely means you need a mentoring session. Some times I have to go down to 80 grit, but usually that means I needed to spend more time with the shear scraper. Often, it takes more time to sand out the 80 grit scratches than it does to cut out the tool marks. I have found out that with good technique, you can reduce a lot of your sanding time.

I have some turning clips up on You Tube if you type in robo hippy. John has some good turning clips up as well. Not as good as a hands on session, but they do help.

robo hippy