Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

What happened to the Bedan???

Posts

What happened to the Bedan???

#1

Jesper, Denmark

What happened to the Bedan???

Jesper, Denmark

Years ago - and especially in European fora - the was some discussions about the Bean. Not anymore.

Is this the forgotten tool or does it really not have any uses in today's turning environment?

I don't have one, but it seems to be useful for sizing tenone/spigots and some were even equipped with an attachmenmt just for that.

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#2

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

John Lucas

Jean-Franso Escuelon (sp) is a huge supporter of the Bedan. He uses it like a skew and I it's incredible to watch him work with this tool. I'm guessing it's not popular here for the same reason the skew isn't that popular. It takes lots of practice. I have one. Seldom use it because I can't see it does anything I can't do with my normal skew. Of course I grew up with a normal skew so I haven't practiced as much with the bedan.

It is excellent for sizing tenons, and it's good for rolling beads because you cut them with the flat side so you don't have to move the handle as far to get a flat sided bead. However it can really be grabby and you get a lot of kickback if you don't really practice with the thing. For planing cuts it works about like the skew

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#3

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Have to agree with what John said about the Bedan.

Still I like using it to turn my flowers. Sharpening is easy with just my diamond file.

Photos at lumberjocks.com/projects/89405

Have trouble posting pictures even when have them at Photobucket, get a formt warning and given an e-mail to contact. One day will sort it out

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#4

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

Don Evans

Well I'm afraid I don't agree! The bedan is like any woodturning tool, it's a matter of knowing how to use it. I find it nothing like a skew as far as grabbing etc.

So what is the difference here between me and John? It's that I was shown how to use one by the master himself that John mentioned ( I am not sure how to spell his name either John) Escoulen?

Anyway, here is a quick lesson:

You must raise the tool rest higher than you normally do, to set it, lay the tool on the wood with the bevel UP, then hold the tool horizontally as level as you can and raise the tool rest up to the tool. This set up is most important to how the tool will work.

To make a planning cut that is as good or better than a skew twist the tool slightly ccw so the left corner is touching wood on top of wood angle to handle to the right slightly and move the tool left cutting with just the left corner. The right side of the front edge will only be raised off the wood maybe 1/64 to 1/32". To plane to the right just reverse above. You'll soon be doing beads same way by not moving left but just twisting the tool and not angling the handle to right (or left) depending on what side of bead you are doing.

This is a very easy tool to use when done properly.

One really important thing also is when cutting down the diameter of a rounded piece like making a tenon on the end for a chuck do NOT use the full width of the cutting end. Use only about 1/3 of the width of the tool.

Now I have no financial stake in this, but there is a big difference in the tool that Jean sells and the others on the market. It is forged similiar to a Japanese sword with folded metal over folded metal to make it. I have one from him and another from another popular tool company and there is no comparison. I reach for the Escoulen ever time.

As someone already said, DO NOT GRIND on this tool to sharpen it, just touch it up with a fine grit diamond file, I use a 1200 grit, I think, it is an EZE Lap with the red handle.

There is also an advantage to putting a very short bevel on the opposite side of the edge from the bevel but it is hard to put in words how it should be done. But it is about 1/16" long from front edge going back toward the handle and is only 1 or 2 degrees.

There is no advantage to a wide Bedan so if you can get the one that Escoulen sells that is 1/4" wide or slightly wider.

Don

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#5

Re: Addendum to the Bedan???

Don Evans

Made a couple of type goofs is above but thing you can figure them out.

Anyway, making beads is easy if done this way:

Move tool rest down to the middle of the wood (top to bottom) lay the bedan on it's side on the rest with the bevel to the right. Put point of tool pointing under the wood so that when you lower the handle the point comes up and contacts the wood in it's side and begins to scrape a groove, back out, turn the tool over so the opposite side is on the rest with the bevel pointing to the left, move over to the right and make the same cut again. What is in the middle is you bead that you then round over with the bedan left and right edges by setting up the rest to top again and twisting the bedan as stated in previous message.

Hope this helps some.

Don

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#6

J.F.Escoulen champions the "French"......

JamieDonaldson

...bedan as he describes it, and his is 1/2" wide and square in profile, as opposed to the "English" bedan which is 3/8" wide and tapered on one face. He is an absolute magician with that bedan, one if the most skilled turners I have encountered. :)

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#7

Re: J.F.Escoulen champions the "French"......

RCH

I've converted a 3/8" (square stock) 'parting tool', which was near useless in its original form, to a more bedan-like grind, and I have found it to be far more useful even for normal parting tool purposes. I've also begun experimenting with using it in other ways, inspired by Escoulen videos. That is still at a very early stage but seems very promising.

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#8

Re: J.F.Escoulen champions the "French"......

Don Evans

Interesting, the one that I purchased from him, in person, was brand named BORDET which he said was made per his spec's. It is 3/16" beveled side x 3/8' top to bottom.

This was a long time ago.

Don

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#9

Re: J.F.Escoulen champions the "French"......

RCH

I did NOT regrind any Escoulen tool -- it was a Woodcraft/WoodRiver tool, sold as 'WoodRiver 3/8" Beading and Parting Tool', and not very good for either purpose.

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#10

Have 2 and use them often

Jorge

One is "english" 3/8 "tapered and is good to make tenons. I made a 1/2" "french" out of a round scraper, they are good to make cylinders, I make tenons in bowls with them and use them often on work between centers.

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#11

Re: J.F.Escoulen champions the "French"......

Don Evans

RCH, just to be clear, I was responding to Jamie's message just above yours where he gave the size of his bedan.

I have another bedan that is a Hamlet which is not square but trapizod (I think) the bottom is wider than the top making the sides angled, think they called it a 3/8" which would be the measurement of the bottom width. No comparison to the cutting ability comparing it to the Bordet, the Bordet is like hot knife through soft butter and Hamlet I cannot seem to get as sharp. I've got a lot of Hamlet tools and like them all but this one.

Don

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#12

I have them and use them often.

Don Orr

One is a rectagular 5/16" wide commercial tool from Lee Valley I believe-Crown or Hamlet, don't remember. And the other I made from a piece of 1/4" HSS stock-square X section. I don't have the tapered type-I think JFE called them English style. Very useful tools in many applications, especially detail work.

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

Jesper, Denmark

Thanks for the comments. It seems like it does have a place.

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#14

Re: J.F.Escoulen champions the "French"......

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Tried loading these pictures back when asked about shear scraping, had one picture to show up could not get first picture to post. I turn most of the outside of my flowers with my bedan. I also use a skew, spindle gouge and parting tool turning flowers.

Thank you Ellis for setting me straight on posting pictures!


img

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#15

Re: J.F.Escoulen champions the "French"......

Don Evans

Need to correct my wording the Bordet I have is 3/16" wide on top and bottom. The sides are NOT beveled, the tool steel is rectangular.

Don

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

#16

Re: What happened to the Bedan???

Sergio

To see a couple of interesting video on the use of the bedan just type "bedan practice" on you tube.

Interestingly, in italian the bedan is called bedano which is the heavy chisel with a rectangular section used to cut deep mortises. It is exactly like the French bedan. A very old tool borrowed from the cabinet makers.