Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Freeze It - SEE It

Posts

Freeze It - SEE It

#1

Freeze It - SEE It

charlie belden

If you turn any or all of the following

- natural edge bowls

- winged vessels

- rectangular pieces

- multi axis pieces

What I saw at a club demonstration last night may be of interest to you.

When you turn any of those types of pieces - WHERE you're cutting is blurred - part "air wood" and part "real wood" - intermitent cuts. Though you can HEAR and FEEL when you're cutting and when you're not - you can't SEE where you're cutting and where you're not.

But -

IF you could "stop" the piece - as it continues to spin - at 700 to 1000 RPMS - you could SEE the "real wood" - and where your cutting edge is as you start a cut. (you could also see where you're getting tear out as well).

THAT is exactly what a STROBE LIGHT can do for you - FREEZE a moving object - so you can clearly see it.

I've tried using a strobe, dialing in a flash rate of one flash per revolution of my piece and could freeze the piece. However, the minute I began a cut, the RPMs of the piece would slow slightly - and put the strobe's flash slightly out of synch with the spinning piece. The result is something like what used to happen on old television sets sometimes - "screen crawl" (remember when TVs had Horizontal and Vertical adjustment knobs?).

Last night I watched a demonstration that solved this "screen crawl" effect - and makes a strobe light a new very useful tool for "air wood / real wood" turners. By placing a small rare earth magnet on the chuck, and a special type of sensor that can detect a magnetic field - acting as a switch to turn the strobe on or off, the strobe will ALWAYS flash just once per revolution - at the SAME PLACE every time. No more "screen crawl".

By moving the rare earth magnet's location, or the Hall Effect Sensor's location, you can set the strobe effect on your side of the lathe - and eliminate the blurred "air wood" and clearly SEE the "real wood" - as you're cutting it.

Here's the basics of the set up.


Mount the strobe on a tripod, set high and looking down over your right shoulder, but not in the way, magnet on your chuck and magnetically mounted Hall Effect sensor on your lathe' sheadstock end and you've got SEE IT - while you're turning. You mmay need to adjust your other lighting so it doesn't overpower the strobe's light. Replacing the power supply/transformer with an X-10 remotely controlled with a "key ring" battery powered remote could let you turn it on and off for when you need the strobe and when you don't need it.

I may put a system like this together and play with it a while. Will report back on what I find - if I actually do one - and use it.

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#2

Alan Zenreich

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

Alan Zenreich

Sounds like a fine plan... More shop toys!

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#3

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

Dwight Rutherford

I remember a previous discussion on another forum and one of the complaints with a strobe was headaches after a relatively short period of use. Was this an issue at your demonstration?

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#4

interesting idea


Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#5

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

charlie belden

Some people are very sensitive to strobing light and can have seizures or migrain headaches from it. The guy doing the demonstration did a PowerPoint presentation before getting to actually using the strobe. He pointed out that anyone with epilepsy or other types of seizure issues or suffered from migrains should probably not attend the rest of the demo.

Working continually in a strobe light could be a problem - though we humans are extremely adaptable critters and could probably get used to working in a strobe light. The guy who was doing the turning - of a multi axis piece did comment on the fact that this would take getting used to. I think either a foot pedal on/off switch or a little battery powered remove you could hold in your handle gripping hand could let you turn the strobe on when needed and off when not needed.

The interesting thing about the guy who put this set up together is that he's a product designer and product rep for several medical supply companies - AND - an avid woodturner. He also has a network of friends, co-workers and clients with a whole lot of knowledge about a lot of pretty technical stuff. So when he has an idea to make turning specific types of pieces easier or safer he'll access his technical friends and get their input and suggestions for changing or refining his idea - and help find the parts and provide guidance for putting together an integrated solution.

We certainly live in interesting times.

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#6

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

John Jordan

Michael Mode did a demo of this at the first AAW Symposium in 1987. He used a tachometer of some sort. There is a article around somewhere about it. Maybe his web site.

I prefer just using a disco ball on the ceiling..................

John

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#7

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

Dale Miner

I have used a similar system with a strobe that was triggered by a reflective tape on the rotating element. This type of system is/has been used for vibration analysis on machinery for quite a while.

There is a danger involved with using a strobe to 'stop' rotation. It is easy to forget that the item is not 'stopped' and reach out to touch or feel the piece.

Years ago dynamic balancing was performed using a strobe that was triggered by a velocity pickup. The heavy spot of the rotating element could be identified by noting where the shaft was stopped at in relation to the velocity pickup.

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#8

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

charlie belden

John:

I was aware that turners have played with strobes before. But it is only recently that the missing element has been incorporated - synching the strobe continually while turning. There's an RPM measurer that, when you put a piece of reflective tape on the chuck, sees the light bouncing back from it and displays the rpms. The dial an RPM strobe that has been being used required manual dialiing in when the speed changed on the piece being turned. Slow the rpms down even a little while making a cut and you start getting the equivalent of the old TV Screen Crawl defeating the "freeze" goal.

Now if there was a way . . . to dim other lights when the strobe is turned on and bring them back up when the strobe is turned off . . .

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#9

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

charlie belden

You didn't happen to work for HP?

They had a division devoted to vibration analysis - accelerometers to capture the amount and direction of the vibrations - and then display the data graphically - in virtual 3D. One of their clients was IBM. They had a problem with heads crashing on hard drives. Their test on individual components showed no significant problem. HP analyzed the whole hard drive in operation - and found that some vibrations would go into and ouf of phase with each other - canceling movement out, or accumulatng and going way out of desired vibration levels.

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#10

Leo Cuellar

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

Leo Cuellar

Very interesting, Charlie. Perhaps colored LEDs, red, to emphasize danger(?), to illuminate/strobe the spinning object might solve the problem of needing to dim the shop lights. It may also have less of an impact in regards to eye strain & headache issues.

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#11

Rob Wallace

A Few Significant Points About This System

Rob Wallace

My assumption is that the demonstration you saw was done by Lars Stole, who has written a great summary of the use of a synchronized strobe light in woodturning applications. You can see this write-up at the following link: www.larsstole.com/Lars_A_Stole/techniques_files/notes.pdf‎

I have gathered all of the components of this system and am assembling it when time permits (probably during Thanksgiving week when the University has a mid-semester break). I have done some quick 'breadbording' of these components just to test how it works before competing a final system build. In general the system works OK, but I have one circuit problem to overcome based on the kind of sensor I purchased (see below).

Some of the points needing clarification relevant to Charlie's post:

1. The power supply (low voltage 6-18+ volts) is not to power the strobe itself, but is to drive a synchronously pulsed voltage sent from the Hall Effect transistor to the trigger input of the strobe light. The strobe requires a separate 110 volt AC current from a 'normal' electrical outlet.

2. You need to purchase a "sourcing" type of Hall Effect transistor (get a PNP, and NOT an NPN type) that is capable of switching a sufficient amount of current to trigger the strobe light at a minimum threshold voltage. I am having problems with the industrial-rated sensor unit I got from eBay, in that it does not adequately trigger this particular strobe with enough current directly from the output of the H-E transistor; I will now need to add an external switching transistor pulsed from the Hall Effect transistor's output to have enough current to drive the strobe's trigger. Selection of what the specifications of the Hall Effect transistor are somewhat critical so you do not burn out the unit in use. You can't just buy any Hall Effect transistor and expect it to work in every application.

3. The "specs" referred to at the Chauvet web site are the most generic/basic specifications about the Techno Strobe 2000S unit mentioned (which actually is a pretty decent strobe for the price), however no information on required trigger voltages or currents is available from the web site. If this information WAS available, my system would already be working because the critical design parameters of what voltage and current are needed by the strobe are not available. I now have to do measurements and determine trigger sensitivity thresholds to put the appropriate switching transistor into the circuit. Not a major problem, but taking more time and a bit of electronic design additions to make the system function as desired.

4. To turn on the system intermittently, all that would be needed is to power the HE-transistor sensor's circuit to send synchronized trigger voltage pulses to the strobe. Any basic SPST switch (push button, toggle, foot switch, proximity sensor, etc.) could be used to send or stop low voltage current being supplied to the sensor. Mine will have a momentary-contact industrial-rated push button to turn-on the strobe to view the piece, and will turn it off when the switch is released.

5. The sensor must be mounted to the lathe in close proximity to the rotating part (spindle, chuck, handwheel, etc.) that holds the magnet, and the sensor must also be capable of being adjusted radially in position to phase the "image" in an appropriate position. Thus, some capacity of "radial" physical positioning adjustment of the sensor is required, while maintaining a close position of the revolving magnet to "close" the magnetic sensor and send a trigger voltage.

6. Caution must be taken to ensure that any wiring coming close to the rotating lathe spindle or other moving parts must be adequately protected from getting fouled in rotating parts and causing damage or injury to the operator. Long skinny wires and rotating lathe parts do not mix!

I hope these comments will help anyone attempting to put together a synchronized strobe system. I am looking forward to using mine!

Turn Safely!

Rob Wallace

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#12

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

Wally Dickerman

Hey John, I was there in 1987....A very interesting demo.

Do you do the "woodturners dance" with that disco ball?

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#13

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

Dale Miner

I worked in the maintenance technology section in a large integrated steelm mill. Steel mills have equipment that runs the gamut from the smallest to much larger than most folk can envision. We used strobes often to find the phase in and out issue you described fairly often. In one particular instance, we found that a handrail on a stairs several feet away needed a short brace welded in to cure a vibration problem that had plagued a large fan for years. Vibration is a strange animal.

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#14

Arduino

Tony - Memphis

This would be a good task for your Arduino. Seems like I recall you speaking about one anyway. I made a new controller for my dehumidifier with a tiny Arduino. Works great. Been looking at makeing a tach for the drill press and lathe. Just for fun - no practical purpose really.

Tony

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#15

Ellis Walentine

I sense an article here


Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#16

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

Barbara

Very interesting!! Thanks for the info.

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#17

Brad Vietje

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

Brad Vietje

Charlie,

I completely understand the philosophy of this, and once saw a demonstration of a variable frequency strobe that could be tuned to the RPM of the lathe rotor.

I am not convinced this would help me very much, but I haven't actually turned using such a system. I have done a lot with natural edge pieces and odd shapes, and I don't have difficulty seeing what's happening. I look at the "horizon" view with a dark background, and I can see pretty well what's happening as the cut develops.

However, that often involves getting my eyes dangerously close to the firing line, and live edges truly are a different level of danger, since the bark can separate from the sapwood with a minor screw up with bevel angle, or just come flying off unexpectedly. If the strobe effect allows better visualization while well out of the firing line, then I'd be inclined to try to build such a system.

We should also be sure to mention the enormous leap in danger that comes from using a strobe light -- after a while we can get tired or just so used to the visualization technique that we can forget that the wood really IS spinning! This sort of work should never be attempted when hurried, tired, or on a tight deadline -- screw-ups can be pretty bad, and can happen really fast -- with or without the strobe light.

I hope the experimenters here will report their findings back to the wider group. Thanks, Charlie, for bringing it up.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#18

I tried this strobe procedure years .....

JamieDonaldson

......ago as part of a neurology research study that my brother was conducting, and it gave me multiple migraines very quickly each time. :(

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#19

Re: Arduino

charlie belden

If I had more time and fewer items on my To Do list, that would be a fun project. In this instance, Off The Shelf stuff readily available (e-Bay, Radio Shack, etc.) are a more likely route to actually trying the idea first. If it turns out it doesn't work - for me - I'm just out some money rather than a fair amount of time. I have more money than time. I've got a cyclone dust collector and 6" ducting to work out and put up, an idea for a 3D printer that has a "shoulder", "upper arm", "elbow" and "fore arm" for XY positioning, the table lowering for the Z axis and a Light Tracker that does use an Arduino.

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#20

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

charlie belden

With ABBA or The Village People playing in the background, a wearing platform shoes - and wide bell bottoms?

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#21

Re: A Few Significant Points About This System

charlie belden

Once again proof that there's very little new under the sun.

The guy who did the strobe demo is named Bob IIRC, from either East Bay or West Bay Woodturners. He made no mention of Michael Mode's much earlier article, which, coincidently (?) uses the same parts and even the same strobe make and model.

Sounds like YOU are the perfect person to put together an article on how to make and use this strobe set up. You've got the electronics knowledge, can write well AND you're an active woodturner.

So when do we get to see the third, illustrated, draft of the article?

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#22

Re: I tried this strobe procedure years .....

charlie belden

The demonstrator pointed out that some people, especially those who have seizure or migrains should probably not use or be around a flashing strobe.

I'm going to try and pick my eye doctor's brain about the eyes and brain reaction to flashing light - and possible methods of reducing or eliminating negative effects. Yesterday's problems may have a solution today.

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#23

Re: I tried this strobe procedure years .....

Michael Mode

I first got into this idea when thinking about a timing light used on an auto engine. I actually tried that first, probably in 1986. My mechanic brought a distributor to my shop and we stuck it in the headstock spindle over the bed while I turned outboard. We connected a car battery for juice, hooked up the timing light to one of the spark plug wires on the distributor, and when we turned on the lathe and dimmed the lights, I was amazed to see a stationary image of a spinning block of wood. Sparks arcing onto the lathe bed from the other distributor wires made it seem like a frankenstein movie. Soon I discovered industrial strobes and bought the least expensive one I could find. This had no facility for synchronizing the strobe with a spinning object other than adjusting the flash rate with a dial. So I could match the flash rate with the lathe, but when making a cut the lathe slowed down and the image began to rotate, as described here in an earlier post. I believe it was this strobe I used in Philadelphia in 1988. Then I talked the strobe company into giving me a more sophisticated model with a photo electric eye and reflective pickup to put on the spindle. This solved the problem of image movement, and I'm still using this strobe to this day. I have a chuck on either side of my headstock, and the reflector is on a round piece of wood in the chuck opposite my work. The photo electric eye I attach to the tool rest and position it appropriately. That works.

I've not had any problems myself with headaches or dizziness or anything else. I do a lot of irregularly shaped turnings at this point, some of which would be extremely tedious and difficult to accomplish without a strobe. I see it as a technological doorway to an area of shapes that has not been that well explored. Another art turner named Ron Gerton did a demo of the strobe light in San Jose two years ago. He quoted my Fine Woodworking article which he discovered as he researched the strobe idea.(which he came up with on his own, by the way; he's a retired engineer)

I know that using the strobe makes a spectacular demo, but beyond that it's a very useful technique for me.

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#24

Re: I tried this strobe procedure years .....

John Lucas

When I turn my one piece mirrors there is a handle spinning so fast you can't see it. I "find it" with my bevel and then turn the handle. I am wondering if freezing it with the strobe would make it a safer operation because I would know exactly where the wood is. At least as long as I don't try to reach around it. :)

Re: Freeze It - SEE It

#25

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for weighing in, Mike

Ellis Walentine

Great story about the Frankenstein strobe arrangement. You always were pushing the envelope, even back in those salad days in the late 70s when we had that amazing guild together. Lotta water under the bridge since then. Thanks for joining the conversation.

Cheers,

Ellis