Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

Posts

Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

steven antonucci

I didn't want to hijack Matt's thread below, but I think it's a pretty recurring thread that we are an older group, and people pass on every year. I know that many of us leave behind equipment and supplies that our spouses will be forced to deal with the disposal. I can tell you with 100% certainty that my wife wouldn't know what to do or where to begin.

Which brings me to my question? How many of you have an "estate plan" for your shop? Does anyone? Are there things that you'd care more about than others? In my own shop, I would probably only care about my lathe and tools, and my workbench because I built it. The lunchbox planer, Sears tablesaw, etc. all can land wherever they land, but I would probably want "a better life" for my lathe... because it is MY lathe and not just A lathe.

I probably also have a few boards that fit this category, and maybe a hand tool or two...

Thoughts?

Steve

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#2

Dan Jechura

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your sh

Dan Jechura

My wife knows that the wood working tools go to my adult kids to fight over. My son hardly ever used them but my daughter has. She still wants to learn the lathe. My wife also knows to have a really big fire with the truck loads of bowl blanks stored in the shop. Or give them away to anyone that asks.

Dan J.

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#3

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your sh

Bill Howatt

You raise a good question and I'm sure over the years there have been a lot of "I wish Osgood had told me how to deal with his shop tools before he left us".

If you have heirs that want the tools and materials and can take them then the problem is pretty well solved.

The thing is that people who aren't into the shop stuff haven't a clue about what it is worth or even what it cost new. If the person is a member of a WW/Turning club then it certainly helps.

My first thought is that a document should be prepared (right now) listing the "valuable" items which may not necessarily be large tools, e.g., a Oneway Stronghold with jaw sets, listing price new, how old, and some assessment of condition. This would give the survivor at least a basic idea of the contents value. A picture of the item may serve well to identify them - might be obvious to you but is it obvious to your survivor?

The survivor should also be told that while some of the items cost a significant amount of money they may not have a market and not to feel bad about accepting a low amount or even giving them away.

Bill

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#4

CC this Doc. to your Insurance Co. Too!


Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#5

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your sh

John Lucas

Since it's almost impossible to put a value on something and assume you'll get it I am just telling my son to put everything in an auction. He's not interested in any of the equipment. It will be his to do what he wishes.

It does bother me that someone may buy some equipment and not know what some of the auxilliary stuff is that goes with it. But then I'll be gone and doubt that I'll really care. Although I may come back and haunt someone who doesn't properly appreciate some of the tools that I really value. :)

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#6

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your sh

Curt Stivison

Everytime I buy a new tool I tell the loml that when she has the estate sale she will be happy I have so much stuff.

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#7

Codicil

Ralph Lindberg

If your state has Codicil's, you can easily have a document that supplements your Will for "disposal" of items like your Lathe, Chucks, etc

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#8

Re: Codicil

Bernie Rose

My biggest concern is the question of how long will I live, now that I hardly ever use most of my tools. The problem is that there are occasions when one of my unused tools comes in handy and is the right thing for the present "emergency".

I managed to sell my SeaDoo when I got so old that I feared that I would not be able to climb back aboard if I got thrown, and I sold my South Bend lathe for a super bargain. But I fear that if I sold one of my three bandsaws it would be just the thing I needed for a small job. Or why do I need two Delta table saws just because I hated changing blades.

These thing cause me some concern, but the big problem is that how will the estate sale man know what to do with the drawers full of left over supplies, like Hut wax bars , partial pen kits, exotic 2 in. squares, or the 60 year collection of grinding wheels or the big stack of steel saw blades. When I retired I didn't expect to live beyond 71, but now 20 years later I sit on a 65 year collection of solutions to non-encountered problems. For the first time in my life I wished I lived on a main road with lots of highway frontage where I could have a long running yard sale.

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#9

Ric Taylor

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your sh

Ric Taylor

I've thought about this issue and I have it boiled down as simply as I can. My son gets his pick of anything and everything in my shop. My brother-in-law can have whatever is left. If there is still anything left after that, I have a trusted wood-turning friend who will sell whatever remains and split the money with my son.

Ric

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#10

This subject hits close to home with .......

JamieDonaldson

...the recent passing of my father. I come from hoarders on both sides of the family, and have been gone from home in Ohio since leaving for college in 1962, and blame my tendancy to "collect" on my DNA. After relatives had removed all cherished items from the house, an auction was the best solution. Dad was an engineer and labeled most everything in sight, but how do you explain a jar full of umbrella tips? I wondered if they could have sold on ebay in England?

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#11

Steven Antonucci

Some great stories and ideas

steven antonucci

For me, I feel a little bit about my lathe the way some people feel about their dogs. It's not going to the kennel if I die, but to a home of my choice. I want someone that wants to be great to get it. I don't really care how much they pay for it (I'm dead, I can't use the money).

There are things in my shop that I do not have any emotional attachment to at all. Oddly, I want them to sell at market value to whoever comes up with the cash. I am a hoarder, but not in such a way that I would describe it as a sickness. I have an eclectic pile of "stuff" and I know that I won't use it all, but I'm not throwing it away. It would take me a week to move just my shop, and a month to move the rest of the house. I'd leave every bit of wood right where it sits, with the exception of the few bits in my shop.

I know that most of my woodturning friends make me look like a pauper. We are dealing with our friend who died over the summer and his woodcutting hobby. As a sawyer, we're guessing that he's got 30-40,000' board foot of flatsawn stock in the various barns and piles around his property. None of us know what to do. I've resisted hoarding any of it. So far.

I have baseball cards, coins, and a bunch of other things that all will have a price and hopefully a value, but I feel like my Nova is an old friend.

S

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#12

This is not an original idea, but...

Chuck Jones West TN

...I'm taking mine with me.

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#13

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your sh

Terry Scott

Steve

In my will ive taking care to state my wishes with my workshop gear

I deal in secound hand woodworking gear on the side so have a fare idea what it is worth

I have an extensive carpentry/ building equipment list as I used to employ 20 plus staff.I was also a boat builder in a past life so have that as well

My woodturning gear is what some say more than what a retailer has in stock

So we are talking some real coin

My wishes are that (i have three daughters)my woodturning club takes it all to auction and all the proceeds go to the club to be used for training woodturning

advancement.

We already have a curriculum that we teach by so that I am in the process of setting up a trust for this purpose

I have got allot out of turning and the fellow ship that goes with it.

So my wife is happy with my decision

This is maybe an extreme but I think it is very important to at least write down what we wont done with our gear especially if the family dont show any interest in it

Ive been involved in quite a few estates were the pour widow has asked for help as shes in a right mess

Cheers

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your sh

Mike Stafford

I recently created a new will just to make sure my wife would not have to deal with all the items in my shop. I labeled every turning tool and accessory and have it listed on an inventory that is notarized and identified in my will. I keep the boxes in which my chuck jaws are bought so they are identified in that way with the exception of the 10 jaw sets for my Axminsters. It may be easier to sell all my saws, jointers, planers etc. as there is a ready market for that stuff The inventory also includes pictures. The whole mess is on a DVD which is with the will. I also identified friends to whom bequeaths were to be made. Perhaps the hardest thing to get rid of will be my "wood pile". Between my turning stock and my flat stock I don't think my survivors will have any idea of its value and it is unlikely that selling it a yard sale will realize even half of its value. I have enjoyed accumulating and using my wood and I hope someone else will do the same.

I used to think that the best way to leave this world was by writing a check to pay for ones final expenses that would bounce after you were put in the ground. Not so sure that they wouldn't dig you up these days to extract the last pound of flesh.

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#15

Re: This is not an original idea, but...

Bill Howatt

I wish you success but you never see a U-Haul behind a hearse.

Bill

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#16

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your sh

Bernie Rose

Chuck Jones has it about right, if possible. Otherwise, trying to control human activity from beyond the grave is anti-social and can cause all sorts of miseries for those left to try to obey a corpses wishes.

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#17

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your sh

matt overton

Thanks to all for your input. I know that I will try to do as Mike has done with my shop as soon as I have completed the task in front of me. I think it only fair to my wife since she has been so supportive of my second love.

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#18

Alan Zenreich

Re: Some great stories and ideas

Alan Zenreich

Steve,

I have heard it said "My greatest fear is that when I die, my wife will sell my tools for the price I told her I paid for them".

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#19

Steven Antonucci

Not sure that I worry about what it's worth?

steven antonucci

I think (for some of us?) that the value of the tools we own goes deeper than the value that they might have on the secondary (or in some cases Nth-ary market)?

I have a set of 19th century carving tools that I bought years ago (thinking I needed them), and the honest truth is that I've never used them (and I can't really figure out why?) They just don't "mean" that much to me? When I bought them, they were a good buy, and filled a void in my shop... and I thought that it would be something along the lines of stewardship for me to be "the next person to own them and use them" for the next 40 years. It just never materialized.

When I walk through antique stores, I am always looking for a "rescue tool". To me, certain tools are "too good" to be hanging on the walls of a Cracker Barrel, or sitting in a box somewhere collecting rust and dust. I want to put them back into a "useful life."

In my own shop, I have a bunch of tools that I would wish this type of fate. I am more concerned about the next person to own them and what they will do with them than I am with how much they paid for them. I have a whole bunch of tools that can go out the door at fair market value, or to the kids if they need wrenches or stuff, but has anyone here ever gotten attached to a wrench or a screwdriver? You can get a whole set of them from the Black Friday flyers for $9.99...

Steve

P.S. I doubt Lauren buys your stories... ;)

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#20

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your sh

charlie belden

I put all the receipts for my woodworking addiction acquisitions in a drawer in the shop. That way, my sons will know where their inheritance went ; )

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#21

I've lost a few friends, and ask their heirs,

Keith Newton

If I could have something / anything, they choose to offer, which I could add to my collection. Not that I'm in need of anything in particular, but will be reminded of my friendship every time I pick that tool up, or even see it in a drawer.

I need to make sure to tell my heirs that I want them to honor that request, if any of my friends should ask.

Re: Sobering question: Estate planning for your shop?

#22

Club auction ?

Pete in Holland, MI

Had a friend on the east coast who was part of a large turning group. When one of the members passed, the family came to him for suggestions on what to do with all of the turning equipment.

They advertized in their club newsletter about a club auction. Being all the turners in the area were there, it worked out well with the focused audience.