Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Emphysema

Posts

Emphysema

#1

Emphysema

Barbara Dill

Has there been much talk about shop dust and emphysema??? I, for one, have ben a bit careless about using my dust collection system. I use it when I'm sanding but I tell myself that green wood has no dust....until the sun ray catches the dust particles in the air. Oops. Mistake. I just had a chest CT recommended by my physician because I complained of coughing at night, really being afraid that my history of smoking for more than 25 years had caused cancer.... So I was told today that I do not have lung cancer, but I do have emphysema. So I bought a comfortable dust mask rated at 100% at my local Woodcraft. And I will follow up with my doc to see what else I can do to keep this from being worse. I am 68 y/o and wonder how the rest of the wood turning community is dealing with this potential hazard of our passion of turning.

Re: Emphysema

#2

Well, that's the good news and the bad news

GaryG in MD

Hi Barbara,

Sorry, you know I don't mean to joke about your emphysema, but I'm glad you don't have lung cancer!

I, too, have gotten concerned recently about breathing dust. As you know, I turn outside, and I have been a bit cavalier about dust, figuring the wind would keep me safe. But the wind isn't always blowing, and when it does, it can resuspend stuff that has already fallen to the ground. I've noticed the same visual effect of light scattering off the particles in the air when the sun is shining just right -- sometimes lots of dust in the air around me. Not good.

As a result, I've taken to wearing my dust mask and harping about it at recent MCW meetings. I'm afraid you're now on the docket for a November "told you so" edition.

I sincerely hope that you're doing OK and that the symptoms are minimal. It's certainly a wake-up call for you, and now, thanks to your reporting, to all of us. Wearing a good dust mask is not "sissy", it's just common sense if you want to protect your health.

...GG

Re: Emphysema

#3

Be sure to mention the 25 years of smoking...

Dick Coers

...at the meeting. Not criticizing, but just want that included in the anecdotal information. I continue to eat M&Ms and I know those are not doing me any favors either. We all have or have had some type of addiction. Take care Barbara.

Re: Emphysema

#4

Re: Emphysema

Jorge

Barb,

Like you I used to not always use the respirator, and my nose gets congested, so now I have the dust collection on all the time I am at he lathe, not only when sanding, and let it running a while after I am done. I use a respirator too when using chemicals with noxious fumes. I wish for a helmet with an air supply from out of the shop, some day soon hopefully.

Get well soon young lady...

Re: Emphysema

#5

Re: Emphysema

Ralph Lindberg

Barb, I'm guilty of not wearing my breathing gear all the time. The DW has her own and does wear it consistantly.

consistently.

She remarked today, as we came in from the shop "You know, if I wear the helmet I don't cough after spending a day in the shop"

She has Asthma and other genetic lung issues

Re: Emphysema

#6

Harry Robinette

Re: Emphysema

Harry Robinette

I have COPD and the Doc says it's from dust mainly. I put in a 1200CFM Delta that's at my lathe's with 4" flex duct that I can position right up almost hitting the

wood. I got a Laguna 1400 ambient air cleaner and now am working on a better positive air pressure face shield. Dust mask are useless 90% of them don't stop any dust smaller the a tooth pick.( I jest) I can understand what your going thru.

We need a face shield respirator that actually works for turners and is affordable.

I know that everyone says there all affordable we just don't want to spend the money and in part there right,but at over $500.00 for a decent one and their not made for turners.

Listen to your doctors and hope you get better.

Re: Emphysema

#7

Re: Emphysema

Steve Criscenzo

Barbara

I am very sorry to hear about your diagnosis. I hope you can find an accommodation that allows you to keep turning.

As I have stated in some of my recent posts on safety, we as a community often discuss safety in response to a dramatic event such as an injury from a blank dismounting from the lathe but neglect the less dramatic but equally serious hazards such as long term exposure to dust. This gets back to safety culture.

I am pushing for and have offered to help in preparing a hazard analysis for turning based on industrial safety practices. Hopefully, the end result is a document that helps us to better identify and mitigate many of the hazards in our craft.

Mitigating the hazards of wood dust requires several approaches including:

• Be aware of the hazard – what activities create dust, what are the hazards

• Minimize dust creating activities – for example, can better technique reduce the amount of sanding we need to do?

• Capture the dust at the source – better dust collection, what dust are we actually collecting

• Clean ambient air – Ventilation or air cleaners

• Personal protective equipment (PPE)

The PPE issue is very complicated. Some of the products sold as dusts masks do little to protect our lungs from the type of dust exposure we encounter. It is important to understand the limitations of any equipment and learn the proper use. Above all, we need to consistently use whatever PPE we determine best.

It is unfortunate that some of the better respiratory protection equipment costs as much or more than many of our lathes. Maybe market pressure can change this situation.

Steve

Re: Emphysema

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: I am by no means an expert....

Jesper, Denmark

On the health issues, but I do have some expertize in filtration. My understanding is that the real health issue with airborne dust is the particles below 0.5 micron.

These will NOT be removed with any filter, which does not have a high differential pressure across them. Hence, dust masks, Helmets supplied through dust filters and the like will not remove the really small stuff. Anything claiming 100% is not really seriously addressing the technical issues.

As I see it, there are only two avenues to avoid breathing this dust:

1. Remove the dust at the source and

2. Positive air supply from clean outside air.

Current standards for air velocity at the entrance to a manually operated spray booth is 100 fpm - not easy to accomplish in a turning situation.

Re: Emphysema

#9

Re: Emphysema

Barbara

I think I have discovered this early, since I have no shortness of breath. I will do everything I can to keep my lungs healthy. This is a huge wakeup call for me. My intent in sharing this is to bring this up for discussion and awareness. Thanks for your comments. And Gary, you're so right!

Re: Emphysema

#10

Re: Emphysema

John Lucas

Barbara when I first started woodworking (many many years ago) no one wore dust masks. You could go in any woodworking shop and no one had on a dust mask. The bigger shops at least had dust collection systems. We didn't give it a thought. Years later Dust collectors at reasonable cost came around but they were still high and hard for small shop owners to justify.

They started to become a priority for me mostly because my shop was in the basement and my wife got tired of the dust. Well now they are common especially with turners who throw a lot of sanding dust. I run mine constantly while turning wood that doesn't throw curls or anytime I'm sanding or using CA glue.

I'm still bad about not wearing a mask. I did buy one to wear when spraying Lacquer and I wear it when sanding Walnut. It's not very comfortable so I don't wear it often.

I keep looking at the powered helmuts but man are they expensive. Yea I know I've heard the argument that it's cheaper than one trip to the emergency room but you know, when you've been working in wood as long as I have it's hard to convince yourself. But at least I'm getting serious about it now and maybe one day soon will purchase a system. Your wake up call hopefully will help.

Re: Emphysema

#11

Re: I am by no means an expert....(ditto)

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Likewise, I am not a medical expert, nor in my case a filtration expert.

I would agree that no filtration solution would be 100% effective - just because 100% is a whole lot (orders of magnitude?) more difficult than 99.99% no matter what you are discussing.

It would be easy to read into your response here, and conclude that none of these solutions has any value. Isn't a 90% or even 70% filtration rate a huge improvement over no filtration at all? Or is any high differential pressure device less 10% effective and basically useless?

Without industrial air handling equipment, what can a WWer do to keep dust out of their lungs?

Henry

Re: Emphysema

#12

Re: Emphysema

Mike Gibson

Similar to John, when l started work there were no dust masks and now l am paying for it, l take a pill every day to keep my tubes open. A couple of feet in front of my lathe l have two 20" fans sucking the dust outside, winter and summer, during sanding l have the dust extraction system working and l wear a powered respirator face shield all the time. Take it very seriously folks. Michael

Re: Emphysema

#13

Alan Zenreich

Re: Emphysema

Alan Zenreich

Barbara,

Lauren and I always wear respirator helmets (typically a 3M Airstream, or variant) any time the lathe is on, or at the grinder, or any similar activity in the shop.

We also use BreatheEasy units when working with volatile organic compounds (spraying lacquers, or casting resins)

We consider them investments to help protect us from several of the obvious and unseen hazards in the shop.

Our use of protective gear was one of the reasons I have also spent considerable time and resources working out ways for demonstrators to be heard clearly while wearing such gear.

I will be happy to discuss the details about our configurations, if you drop me a note via private message or email.

Re: Emphysema

#14

Jesper, Denmark

Re: I am by no means an expert....(ditto)

Jesper, Denmark

I don't think you can conclude that some filtration does not have value. Clearly, it is better to have most of the dust removed rather than none at all. The point is that that "large" particles you remove are also the ones, which get caught in your mucus coated interior of your nose and broncials, which get picked or soughed out.

Most of the real fine stuff is still there.

The point of my comments were not to rely on statements such as 100% removal and not to get lulled into a false sense of security, 'coz you did wear a dust mask.

In an industrial setting here, NO air from dust extraction can be re-used for people breathing, but has to be vented outside. The same regs apply in the US for solvents in paint emissions.

On the other hand, one might consider that occasional hobby use is different and much less hazardous than a daily 8 hour exposure.

So, no cheap and simple solutions, I'm afraid, only pointing out some technical facts.

Re: Emphysema

#15

Re: I am by no means an expert....(ditto)

Stuart Johnson

Does a vapor mask filter out the real small stuff? I use a 3M half face mask with the pink particle filters but don't know how efficient they are. With a vapor filter you can't even smell lacquer or solvents.

Re: Emphysema

#16

Jesper, Denmark

Re: I am by no means an expert....(ditto)

Jesper, Denmark

A vapor mask uses a completely different technology from a particle filter. It uses activated carbon to adsorb vapor and is not designed to filter out particles.

Re: Emphysema

#17

Re: I am by no means an expert...thanks

Stuart Johnson

So much for my vapor / particle thought. I guess it's back to doing the best we can, improving when we can and realizing even staying in bed with the covers over our head has some risk.

Re: Emphysema

#18

Alan Zenreich

Re: I am by no means an expert...thanks

Alan Zenreich

Stuart,

The 3M breathe easy system accepts cartridges that are high efficiency / organic vapor... Best of both worlds in each cartridge (particle/vapor).