Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

Posts

'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#1

'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

As the thread title suggests, I am wondering what about the “safe limit” of tool overhang beyond the tool rest. I just watched an EasyWood Tools infomercial on YouTube that gave 2”, 3”, and 4” overhang limit for their 3 sizes of tools. Those numbers were disappointing because 4” is about the limit of my ability to cut smoothly with my ½” bowl gouge (my only bowl gouge). Note that for most bowls my tool rest is much closer than 4"; I only use that much overhang when that is my only option - for deeper pieces with a tall shape.

So my questions:

- Does a larger cross section bar improve that 4” ‘limit’ to anywhere near 8 -10”? (assuming appropriate length handle).

- If that 4” number make sense, how can anyone accomplish a deep HF where the tool rest is by definition set outside of the piece?

- I have been considering a carbide insert tool to extend my reach, but assume I would need to make one with a quite beefy bar (more cross section area than EWT bars) and a ‘long’ handle to get longer than 4" reach. Anyone have experience to confirm or contradict my assumptions?

Thanks

Henry

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#2

Stuart Batty's site with excellent info...

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

I just followed a link here on WC to Stuart Batty's site. He has a series of excellent videos, one of which was describing parting tools and tool overhang. He mentions a 7:1 ratio. I had not heard or read that number before, but if that is a general rule, that is really helpful.

Is it a general rule/guideline?

Is that 7x number a guideline for other types of lathe tooling as well? (i.e. gouges, scrapers, carbide tools)

Note - I recognize the differences between a massive gouge and detail gouge ... and the differences between their capabilities for tool overhang.

Thanks

Henry

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#3

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

john Veerkamp

Safe overhang is a function of bar diameter and handle length. There are rules of thumb out there, others on here can give more specific information. I have successfully hollowed up to 12" with both the Jamison(sp?) system and the Jordan.

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#4

Are those hollowing systems carbide cutters?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

John: i don't know the details of the various hollowing systems. Are either of those systems set up with carbide insert cutters? What size bar (cross section) is used to gt 12" deep?

Henry

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#5

Re: Are those hollowing systems carbide cutters? *LINK*

John Lucas

Either system will take a Hunter style carbide cutter. They take different cutters and I would have to look them up but I believe you can find it on the Hunter website.


http://www.hunterwoodturningtools.com/

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#6

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

John Lucas

Henry It varies somewhat with the tool, the size and how you use it. I'm assuming it will also wood density will also affect it. Just from my own experience I can hang a cutting tool out a little further than a scraping tool but that's with my own tools, no one elses so I'm sure it varies.

I use my 1/2" bowl gouges frequently about 4" or slightly more over the tool rest. My Thompson detail gouge will go further probably because it's thicker. My 5/8" bowl gouge has gone somewhere around 8" over the rest but I prefer not to do that. Much better to try and adjust the rest so it doesn't overhang. You just simply get an easier cut with more control.

For hollowing I find that my 1/2" bars with a 3/16" cutter will go about 8" before you really fight the chatter. A little more if you take really light cuts and cut with the grain. My 3/4" bars will go 10 to 12". I hollowed out to 14" one time with my 3/4" bar with a 3/16" cutter but really had to go slow when I got that deep. I used a 1 1/2" bar in Frank Sudols class many years ago and turning 14" deep to about 1/16" wall thickness was a breeze.

If your having to hang things over the tool rest very far get a curved tool rest. Robust and Oneway both sell excellent ones as well as Bestwoodtools. Each one has their merits so ask a lot of people. I have the Robust and Bestwoodtools. The Robust is much more solid with almost no vibration but it's overall thickness causes problems when reaching in some vessels. The Bestwooodtools rest is thinner and will reach in places you can't get to with the Robust but of course it has more vibration and chatter when you get the tool out hear the end.

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#7

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

robo hippy

How far you can hang out off the tool rest depends on several things. Tool shaft diameter is one. Handle length is another. The size of the cutter is still another. Most standard tools will hang out an inch or four, depending a bit on size of the shaft. Beyond that it gets risky. If you have checked out hollowing tools you will notice they all have 1/4 inch wide tips, or less. This is mostly because if the cutter is any bigger, you will have too much pressure on that end, and that see-saw will launch you and or your tool.

What are you trying to cut?

robo hippy

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Stuart Batty's site with excellent info...

Mike Stafford

Henry, the 7X ratio refers to the amount of handle that should be behind the tool rest when compared to the amount the tool overhangs the tool rest.

Similar guidelines can be found in the front of every Craft Supplies catalog although their guidelines call for a minimum of 5X handle length. By the way the Craft Supplies guidelines suggest overhangs for bowl gouges of no more than 1 1/2" for a 1/4" gouge; 2 1/2" for a 3/8" gouge; 3 1/2" for a 1/2" gouge and 4" for a 5/8" gouge. The overhang for spindle gouges which are significantly less in cross section are correspondingly 3/4"; 1 1/4"; 1 3/4" and 1 3/4" where the last spindle gouge is 9/16" rather than a half.

Most boring bar hollowing systems are 3/4" in diameter or more which provides significant increases in overhang because none of the steel is removed to create a flute and the cutter diameter/cross section is significant smaller as well.

I have a 1" diameter hand held steel boring bar which is 36" long and when I add my 24" aluminum handle (I need help to pick it up) I am able to reach 10" or so over the tool rest. I have a 1/4" square HSS scraper mounted in it.

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#9

Steven Antonucci

Rules, tools and people

steven antonucci

I think the "rules" are a little bit misleading. I prefer to think of them a guidelines (Captain Jack Sparrow and the Pirate Code)...

Guideline #1: Every tool has a practical limit of how far over the rest it can reach before it vibrates. Doesn't matter whose hands are on the other end of it. Any change in sound is your warning bell...

Guideline #2: Not every tool behaves the same at the same distance over the rest. A scraper is far more "grabby" as you reach than a bowl gouge is because there is no bevel support. Do not rely on thickness of steel to make up for this, because all it means is that the forces will transmit to the other end of the long lever you are holding.

Guideline #3: The longer the reach, the smaller the cutter. If I have an option between a smaller cutter and a larger cutter, and I know that I am extended over the rest, I will always choose the smaller cutter.

Guideline #4: Slow the lathe down as you extend over the tool rest.

Guideline #5: Know your limitations. Just because I can reach 14" over the rest with a 5/8" bar with a hook in it, doesn't mean that you can. There is no formula that objectively assesses the human at the lathe.

That said, if you want to get a bit of practice in, try cutting a bowl with the tool rest pulled back 4-5" from where you'd normally put it to experiment and find your comfort zone.

Steve

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#10

Thanks all

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Thakns for all the responses.

I found more info available on Stuart Batty's catalog - pg 16, where he suggests ratios of: 3:1 for negative rake scrapers,

5:1 for gouges, skews, and parting tools (said 7:1 in video), and

7:1 for conventional scrapers.

As Steve suggests, there are no hard and fast rules; it makes sense to me that the size of the cutter and the cross section of the bar will play into the maximum overhang. Handle and the handler are other clear factors.

I've solved my immediate project needs by thinning the walls of the piece, and therefore being able to project the tool rest farther. This is a vase with about 4" opening, and about 8-9" tall. Species is Bradford pear, and as Ellis has stated (back in the Archives) that it does cut like like butter (green).

Thanks all for helping me think through this a bit.

Henry

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

Lyle Jamieson

Some good info in this thread. There are many variables...wet-dry wood...porous grain-tight grain... sharp tools...experience of turner...scraping or slicing cuts...big cutters or little cutters.

You asked about carbide tools. The Hunter Nanograin carbide is different then the other carbide. The Hunter cutters can be set up to be used as a scraper -OR- like my hollowing set up, that has bevel supported slicing cut.

There are turners that exceed the limits of the tools they use. I do not turn with vibration. Vibration is not fun or safe.

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

#12

Re: 'overhang' from tool rest - limits?

robo hippy

I am still trying to figure out the 'things bouncing off the wall part'. I do have one good sized hole in my wall. I guess if it was concrete, and not framing and sheet rock, it might have bounced.......

I think we all hang out too far some times. Mostly it is to see how far out you can reach and still keep control. You can still rub the bevel of a gouge a long way off the tool rest, but you need a bottom feeder type of gouge.

robo hippy