Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Cracking problem

Posts

Cracking problem

#1

Cracking problem

ken chase

Hello:

Purchased a lovely piece of Ambrosia Maple from North Carolina.

Thought I did everything right. Turned the hollow form to about an inch thickness

placed it in a shopping bag sealed closed. A few days later I opened the bag and found

numerous cracks. I live in the desert. May be the problem. Question is.....Can I find a source

of figured interesting varieties of turning blanks for hollow forms that has a low enough moisture

content to avoid this problem in the future. I'm patching the cracks and filling with sawdust and

plan to dry the piece in the microwave. Can't get much worse.

Thanks

Ken

Re: Cracking problem

#2

Re: Cracking problem

Barry Irby

Ken I don't live in a desert so my experience doesn't Really count but I would suggest two things. There is some indication that a shopping bag does very little to slow the drying process. Not sure what you would do, but you might try a plastic bag with a few holes in it of taking the object out once a day and turning the bag inside out until it stop "sweating". You might try packing some wet shavings into the shopping bag with your object. And it might be better to either turn it thinner, maybe a half inch or better yet, turn it green to finish and put some finish on the exterior and force it to dry to the inside.

Re: Cracking problem

#3

Re: Cracking problem

Ken chase

Thanks Barry:

I'm just getting back to turning after a long hiatus and have forgotten much.

I used plastic to cover the piece when it was still on the lathe. Too bad didn't continue

To do so when I removed it. Appreciate the feedback

Ken

Re: Cracking problem

#4

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Cracking problem

Lyle Jamieson

1) Use half the tree without the pith. 2) Make sure there are no cracks before you start. 3) Turn green to finish wall thickness. No more cracking. The drying and shrinking in an end grain hollow form, done in this way, will not be noticeable when you get done. In my opinion the only reason to double turn a hollow form is when you want to put a lid on it and it has to be perfectly round.

Re: Cracking problem

#5

Re: Cracking problem

Stuart Johnson

Wally D. lives in Tucson and coats his with Johnson's Paste Wax then sets aside to dry. I don't remember if he coats both the inside and outside or just the outside.

Re: Cracking problem

#6

Re: Cracking problem

John Lucas

I've had excellent success with paper sacks to dry turnings. You may need to dampen the outside slightly before placing in the bag. Maybe the outside is trying to dry too quickly.

Re: Cracking problem

#7

Re: Cracking problem

Ken chase

Will do. Thanks

Re: Cracking problem

#8

Re: Cracking problem

Ken chase

Thanks.

Re: Cracking problem

#9

Re: Cracking problem

Ken chase

Thanks

Re: Cracking problem

#10

Use Lyle's advice

Dick Coers

plus I use landscape waste bags because the paper is thicker and they are double thickness. They work great! If you were to use plastic, you have to take the turning out each day and turn the bag inside out. That gets the condensation that forms in the bag out, but you still stand a good chance of getting mold. Did your piece have the pith in it?

Re: Cracking problem

#11

Re: Use Lyle's advice

Ken chase

Dick:

I'm honestly not sure. Both ends have a flame pattern and I don't recall seeing pith.

I'm a bit rusty and may not have paid enough attention.

Will try the heavy bag next time.

Thanks

Ken

Re: Cracking problem

#12

Re: Use Lyle's advice

George Van Beynen

Dick, you may try the heavy bag but may consider Wally's paste wax or do as I do and use Anchorseal. Not being in the desert I have practically zero loss.

Re: Cracking problem

#13

Re: Cracking problem

Don Wilcut

I agree with Lyle, 100%!

Re: Cracking problem

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: Cracking problem

Brad Vietje

Ken,

I agree with Lyle, of course -- he's a master of the hollow form -- but will add two thoughts:

1. Leaving any turning 1" thick will almost always crack if you are turning on the pith. The wood needs to shrink as it dries, and it shrinks toward, and around, the pith, so if you want to turn the full diameter of a log, you would be best to drill the pith out to leave room for shrinkage, and like Lyle says, turn to final thickness (probably 1/4" or even less) to avoid cracks. Avoiding the pith entirely is a safer bet!

2. Use Mesquite if you have a source near you. It is the most stable wood I've ever encountered, and is much less likely to shrink and crack. There are a number of types of Mesquite, and they may not all be so stable, but that's a wood species that is more likely to be local to you, and to work well in the desert air.

You didn't mention where you are or which desert, but taking green wood from a damp and humid environment and moving it to a dry climate does present an additional challenge when seasoning the wood. Store rough-turned pieces in the coolest and most humid place you have available -- maybe on a concrete floor -- and only slowly move to higher, warmer, drier locations as it loses weight and stabilizes. You can place pieces in paper bags, and store these in closed cardboard boxes for extra tempering of the moisture gradient, which would probably create a moldy mess for me, but might be a good strategy for you.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

(damp & humid in spring and summer; dry and cold in winter; orange, red & yellow in the fall :) )

Re: Cracking problem

#15

I never re turn the piece...

Dick Coers

so wax or anchorseal are of no use to me. I never re turn any of my work actually. I turn for the organic look/movement of the wood for my bowls, and movement is hardly noticeable in my end grain vessels.

Re: Cracking problem

#16

Re: Cracking problem

robo hippy

I prefer the warped pieces as well. You can twice turn hollow forms if you want. I do not like to pack anything in shavings, especially green shavings. Mostly I have had 'spots' appear on the piece I am protecting, and they don't seem to turn away or sand away. If I want to protect it while drying, I will soak the end grain bottom in finish, for me generally that is walnut oil. The end grain is most vulnerable. I then wrap the outside with stretch plastic film from bottom to top, covering all, but leaving the top open. I do this for a month or so, then take off the plastic. It is fairly humid here, so things do not dry out too fast. Having the pith in a piece is asking for trouble, even if you dry it successfully. Wood always moves with seasonal and weather changes. It will fail eventually, even if you flood it with super glue.

robo hippy

Re: Cracking problem

#17

Contact me

Dale Bonertz

I rough turn and kiln dry bowl blanks. Dan who I took over for still rough turns and kiln dries hollow forms on occasion. I'll put you in touch with him - use P

the PM. Only thing to be aware of is we live in a pretty dry climate. Spalting is really hard to get here.

Re: Cracking problem

#18

Re: Contact me

ken chase

Thanks. I'm interested in many species not just maple. What I hope to find is wood

that is dry and not subject to cracking. I know it's harder to work on dry hardwood but

I've done it for quite some time with mesquite which is plentiful where I live in Palm Desert Ca.

Thanks

Ken

Re: Cracking problem

#19

Lyle Jamieson

can't dry a tree

Lyle Jamieson

You can not dry a tree. If it is big enough to turn it will crack before it will dry. If you have thin stock like for a platter then you can dry it first. But a 12 inch diameter tree, or a 6 inch thick half tree will likely crack before it dries...and besides it would take years for the inside of the tree to dry.

Re: Cracking problem

#20

Right Oh, Lyle


Re: Cracking problem

#21

Steven Antonucci

with the possible exception of mesquite

steven antonucci

I once turned a 10-12" bowl from mesquite that I left 1" thick. Didn't seal it, didn't return it after it "dried". if it moved 0.005", I would be surprised...

Every other wood... YMMV.

S

Re: Cracking problem

#22

Re: with the possible exception of mesquite

Dale Bonertz

Yes mesquite is pretty cool stuff. For those of us who don't get it much it is like turning an exotic wood. For those of you who get it all the time I suppose you get bored with it. I love mesquite.

Re: Cracking problem

#23

Re: can't dry a tree

charlie belden

There is a way for a tree to dry with little cracking - if it was debranched and the trunk left standing - for several (3-5) years. Apt to find rot at the top and bottom - but in between can be sound and crack free. Requires that you network well with local arborists / tree trimmer guys - city tree trimming crews. Helps if the tree was reasonably maintained - pruned by someone who knows how to prune properly - and kept "balanced" to minimize stresses in the trunk. Worked with birch bark birch, sugar maple, deodor cedar, apple and claro walnut.

Could be I've just been lucky.

Re: Cracking problem

#24

Re: Contact me

Ken chase

Dale:

Sorry it took so long to reply. I'd like to see what you have for sale. Do you have

A website with photos?

Thanks

Ken