Variation on a Theme
barbara dill
A day too late for the exhibit. This is Moon Ascending. I like it better because it has more movement. I need to be sanded, but I'll be out of town and wanted to post it now. Comments?? 
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Variation on a Theme
barbara dill
A day too late for the exhibit. This is Moon Ascending. I like it better because it has more movement. I need to be sanded, but I'll be out of town and wanted to post it now. Comments?? 
after looking back and forth between the two...
GaryG in MD
Hi Barbara,
I find that I like both forms, generically, but for slightly different reasons.
The first one is more complex, or fussy, depending on how you look at it.
It will appeal to different people in different ways. I think its statement is one of "decoration", while this second one is more pure "design". That appeals to me at a very basic level -- very clean, kind of like a Brancusi column.
I enjoy the quirks in the first one too because it makes me think more about what's going on.
Having said all that, I'm afraid you may have noticed the word "generically" above. I have to say that the little "nick" in this second one really bothers me. It interrupts the flow. I don't know if you did it on purpose as an accent or not, but, to me, it seems like a mistake. Without that nick, it would be pure. This way, I find it stuck in the middle. Hmmm... BUT, I see another "nick" higher on the dark side. I think there may be more going on here than can be seen in one flat photo. Perhaps I'm totally missing something. So let me just say that I'd like to see what one looks like without the nicks. Mod3? ;-)
JMO, GG
Names
Ellis Walentine
Hi Barbara,
I think that the "Moon Ascending" name you've given this piece is important, because it suggests the imagery you're seeing in it and guides the viewer to apprehend it in this light.
Names add context and meaning to a piece.
Interesting. Nice piece, by the way. I like the unfinished rawness of it, straight off the tool and your vision.
Ellis
upon further examination,
GaryG in MD
I see a couple of those "nicks" on the dark side too -- I missed them because they blend into the background. I misunderstood the shape. What I'm seeing is a photographic effect from that particular angle. There's more going on here than can be seen in one flat photo. I'm intrigued by this piece. Can you post shots from other angles? ...GG
Re: upon further examination,
barbara dill
Good morning Gary, Thanks for your comments and insights. You are correct...the "nick" is the beginning of the profile that is towards the back. I will post more views next week when I return. I an enjoying this experiment, or this turn of events!
Re: Names
barbara dill
Thanks you, Ellis, for your comments. I, too, like the rawness of this with the tool marks. I sanded it by hand yesterday evening, but will refrain from sanding some in this series. I first worked with wood in the 80's by carving with a mallet and chisel. I always preferred the gouge marks to a sanded surface.
Re: Variation on a Theme
robo hippy
I am trying to visualize the process. Looks like two sets of beads, turned on two centers. Nice piece, and I generally don't really like 'art' pieces. Here the process is as much of a puzzle as the piece is.
robo hippy
Re: Variation on a Theme
charlie belden
"Vs" on one axis, beads on the other axis. Less obvious - Barbara's piece has a twist to it - which is not obvious in a single photo or even several photos. and getting that twist is easy in theory - not so easy to do.
Most multi axis pieces really need a video to convey what you'd see if the piece were actually in front of you.
Vs and Beads with Twist
charlie belden
I've been creating virtual 3D models from photos of Barbara's pieces in order to work out how they could be done.
For this piece you could turn V cuts on one axis, then on the same blank, turn beads on a second axis. To incorporate a twist in the piece you'd tilt the two axis slightly in opposite directions.

After you've been through Barbara's articles on her structured approach to multi axis turning and understand Cause & Effect, you can look an Effect and work back to the Cause. And if you use SketchUp, you can actually start DESIGNING multi axis pieces. Knowing where the centers of the axes are to be placed on the blank and images of the OUTCOME you're after "all you have to do is turn the piece". OK - so THAT part takes some turning skills - and in Barbara's case - some really good turning skills . . .