I quit teaching photography. I used to teach a nature photo class every year but every question out of their mouth was how do I do this or that in photo shop. Not how do I get the photo. They weren't interested in Nature. What plants are edible, how do you identify the tree, or about ecology, and how natural things work together. They weren't interested in learning how to get the best photo or even composition. It was just how can I play with the photo after I get it. I tried to explain that you get the best image you can and then manipulate it afterwords if necessary.
I just couldn't get through to them that if the composition and concept or idea of the photo was bad, no amount of manipulation would make it good. Gees that's just like turning actually. If the form is bad what ever you do to it won't make it good.
It's possible that it's rendering as white text in some browsers. I picked that page as just one of many pages that have surfaced that quote.
I was a very early adopter of digital technologies, often combining photographic and digital techniques... Well before it was fashionable.
Unlike the originator of this thread, I embrace digital imaging.
Years ago, I ran black and white and E6 processing lines... Did photo compositing and in-camera masking.
Things that took days to do in a darkroom, I can do faster, and BETTER with digital. Even camera work benefits.... I now routinely photograph theatrical productions at 1600 ISO and higher
I do not look back fondly on the days of trying to push the ISO of Tri-X during development, never mind doing it with color film .
A good photographer, using film or a digital camera, can make someone look thinner, or taller - without PhotoShop. And negatives and prints have been being "touched up" almost since photography was invented. Hell, even Ansel Adams, who took great pains to get the perfect composition and perfect exposure, spent as much time developing his negatives and then much more time in the dark room "dodging and burning". And there are special bellows camera attachments that will adjust for normal lens distortion that cause straight lines to appear curved.
Much of what PhotoShop can do is taken directly from the Old Days of cameras and tripods and film - without the chemicals and without working in red or amber "safe lighting".
Charlie, you are right. There are dodge and burn tools in Photoshop. Anyone who has done photocompositing or dye transfer printing will find the layer and masking tools familiar.
Alan I did a double take, for a moment I was reading it as "Photo composting." As John says most of the poorly derived digital images manipulated in Photoshop need that - composting.
Having used an Artiscope scale reduction camera for many years I understand the dodge & burn techniques as we struggled with lighting exposures on large format (3' square) images.