Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Thinking through problems

Posts

Thinking through problems

#1

Steven Antonucci

Thinking through problems

steven antonucci

Dan Bailey's nested bowls had me thinking this morning. I asked if it was a big first/small first approach... and it got me to kicking around how I would attack the problem if I wanted to make a set? (probably not...but I enjoy thinking about it anyhow!)

How many of you will try to make something just because of the process of thinking something through? Are you more likely to tackle a new project because of a challenge or less likely? Do you prototype ideas if you are not sure?

As I thought about how I would approach the problem, I assumed that it would be easier to make the smaller bowls first, since you could assemble them into a circle and know how big the largest bowl would need to be. I have no idea if it would open me up to other issues, and that's kind of exciting? (do you need two big bowls be able to serve that many small bowls? Could the two bowls somehow become a top and bottom to encase the little bowls?... I better stop before I get past the point of no return and have to do this...)

So... how do you manage new ideas (to you, at least?)

Steve

Re: Thinking through problems

#2

Re: Thinking through problems

john Veerkamp

I try to cogitate over the "problem" for several days and come up with possible approaches. If it is a one of the solution may be different than a production/repeated item. Then I start testing bits of the solution in prototype until a workable whole solution emerges. Occasionally one time through is all it takes. More often not. Depends on how complicated and familiar the situation is.

Re: Thinking through problems

#3

Steven Antonucci

Re: Thinking through problems


Re: Thinking through problems

#4

Re: Thinking through problems

robo hippy

Most of the time, little planning goes into my turnings. I do mostly bowls, and the more warped, the better. Grain orientation is not as important as shape for these warped forms. I generally plunge right in. If I am trying some thing different, I do one, ponder for a bit, do another, and some times do a bunch to refine a design idea. I never draw things out, mental concept only. Well, when I do furniture, I do draw them out....

robo hippy

Re: Thinking through problems

#5

Re: Thinking through problems

John Stegall

I guess I am more like RH, I just dive in and design on the fly. I do not seem to get in a mode where I will do more than one of something. I want to know how but once accomplished have a vey hard time doing another. I also find myself going long periods between turning on the lathe. That is part of my new plan, turn daily and do multiples. Then I need to read up on posting pictures.

Time to go turn something out of a pvc rod I have.

Re: Thinking through problems

#6

Alan Sweet

Re: Thinking through problems

Alan Sweet

I guess it depends on my comfort level with what project I am doing.

I read somewhere that if you have you make more than six decisions about doing something you better start a list. This probably applies to me.

If I have done something before, then my mind just kind of replicates the same process. (No decisions)

If I have not done something similar before, I'll probably do a design.

In all cases where it is needed, I'll make a cut list, bf measures, check out screws/glues and review of my applicable finishing products.

In most cases, at least one trip to a big box or wood working boutique.

Re: Thinking through problems

#7

Steven Antonucci

never heard six decisions before?

Steven Antonucci

But it seems viable?

I have a project in my head that requires multiples. If I needed one item, I know how to do it. If I needed 12 of them, I would suck it up and get it done. I may need hundreds (depending on my level of sanity?), so I prototyped something I thought would work, but it turns out to be a horribly inefficient way of making my thing. Even worse, when I tried to assemble it, it wasn't even close. It will need a drawing, or at least calculations. Conceptually, I made 10 pieces. In reality, none.

Sometimes,my brain comes up with things my hands cannot do. Other times, my hands are ready, but my brain is not. Both are opportunities for growth.

S

Re: Thinking through problems

#8

Re: Thinking through problems

mjonesrdg

At my age, an afternoon nap on the sofa has become an "integral" part of my wood turning affliction. I will nearly always start a new/different project with mental design in that quiet time. I can't draw for sour owl sh*t, but I will often take the concept to a sheet of drafting grid paper and using dividers and french curves, make elevations and plan view drawings to scale. It is at this phase that I work out how to hold the various pieces that will make up the turned construction.

And yes, I sometimes make a prototype or two before I commit a precious piece of figured wood to the design.

I am also not good at doing repetitions....the same form multiple times....but I will often come back after a year or so, and do one again making the adjustments that my eye, or skill level, or tooling allows for an improvement.

My aversion to doing repetitive work has made a very low production turner out of me. However, that, (and my age) serves to keep me out of trouble.

Re: Thinking through problems

#9

Re: Thinking through problems

robo hippy

Some times I sits and think. Some times I just sit.

John Coffee from the Green Mile.

robo hippy