Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

CBN Grits

Posts

CBN Grits

#1

CBN Grits

Dale Bonertz

I have switched to CBN wheels which I really like. The problem is that they put on a very fine/nice edge on my gouges but for roughing they seem to fine. I used to use a Norton 32A 60 grit wheel for my roughing gouges and the edge seemed to last longer. This leads me to my question. Has anyone played with the CBN 80 grit wheel versus the 180 grit for roughing gouges? Does the edge hold better using the 80 grit CBN wheel?

Re: CBN Grits

#2

Re: CBN Grits

robo hippy

Most of the time I sharpen on my 180 grit wheel. I have sharpened my gouges on both. Mostly the bowl gouges (Thompson with finger nail grind) go on the 180, but my scrapers and bottom feeders generally go on the 80, and I can't say I really notice a difference with either the burrs on the scrapers, or the cutting of the bottom feeder vs the fingernail grind gouges. I have never turned with a gouge sharpened on a 60 grit wheel. I don't even have one that coarse. I know Mike Mahoney and Jimmy Clewes like the coarser wheels.

robo hippy

Re: CBN Grits

#4

Re: CBN Grits

John lucas

I have been sharpening my spindle roughing gouge with a 320 grit sanding belt. I think it actually holds an edge longer but haven't figured a way to prove it yet There was a. Article in Woodturning magazine several years back where they did prove that a keener edge lasted longer

Re: CBN Grits

#5

Re: CBN Grits

Dale Bonertz

Thanks guy's. Jesper the link is not working for me.

I rough turn a lot of bowls for roughoutbowls using six 3/4" gouges and six 5/8" gouges. All of the 3/4" are 15V one of the 5/8" is 10V and the rest of the 5/8" are M4 (I think, 1 or 2 may be M2). After spending at least six months with the 180 grit CBN I can confidently say for roughing bowls, with and without bark, that the edge is not lasting as long as when I was using my Norton 32A wheel. Having said that I do like the edge that the CBN puts on the gouge and I especially like the no dust factor with the CBN. I sharpen them twice for what I used to get out of a once sharpened on a 32A. I can live with this, if I have to, because I believe that I am taking the same amount of metal with both options (the CBN seems to take less metal per sharpening). What I was hoping is to find if anyone has experimented with the 80 grit versus 180 for longevity. On D-Ways site I noticed he says he reshapes and sharpens his larger gouges on the 80 grit. I will contact him to see if he has noticed any longevity difference this way. I have talked to Detmer with Optigrind and he told me that some professional turners are ordering 100 grit from him for the reasons I mention above but he has not received any feedback to date as to whether or not it is working for them. Thus why I ask here. I hope more will chime in but in the meantime I will investigate further with Dave.

Re: CBN Grits

#7

Thanks Alan

Dale Bonertz

I followed that thread and even responded. It did not cover the information I am after in regards to the longevity of the cutting edge.

John,

I read that article in the journal and it made sense however if my memory serves they tested their cuts on finishing pieces. The tests were not done on roughing which entails so much more demand on the cutting edge. So far from my experience the cutting edge coming off of the 180 CBN is a nice edge for finishing cuts but weaker for roughing. I sent Dave an email and also sent one to Dietmer. I have heard back from Dietmer and he thinks that a rougher edge for roughing bowls may have some merit. He is checking with some of the users to see what they say. I have not heard back from Dave, however it is Sunday. Still investigating and may need to go back to the 60 grit for all the roughing I do and use the CBN's for finishing. Kinda sucks since I like the no dust, wheel not changing size and the edge off the CBN. I guess I need to decide if I want to sharpen less often and put up with the disadvantages or not.

Re: CBN Grits

#8

Re: CBN Grits

Dale Bonertz

Dave got back to me and said he sharpens his gouges on the 80 grit. He mentioned that he doesn't keep track of how long an edge is held, he sharpens when they need it which is most likely what most turners do. Another turner saw this post and has offered me his grinder with an 180 and an 80 grit so I can see for myself. Aren't turners great, thanks Don Cobb.

Re: CBN Grits

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: CBN Grits

Jesper, Denmark

I'll acept the experiences of the experienced turners, who claim a longer lasting edge from coarse grinding wheels for use on wet wood - but it does not seem logical, unless it relates to the burr.

We generally tend to ignore the burr from grinding gouges, but there must be an effect from a stronger and longer lasting burr from coarse wheels? I suppose the question is if the burr is as important in gouge performance as it is on scrapers?

.....and thanks to Alan for fixing the link.

Re: CBN Grits

#10

Re: CBN Grits

Dale Bonertz

To tell the truth when finish turning I think it really does not matter as much. Sharpen when it needs it and go since one is after a quality finish of the tool. That is why I like the edge off of the CBN better since it seems to leave a finer/sharper edge or burr. However for rough turning, especially production rough turning, as I do so much of the longevity of the edge becomes more of an issue. I want to be able to get that three exteriors done with one sharpening rather than the 1 1/2 that I now seem to get. I think the difference in the burr rougher/stronger burr when roughing plays an important role with this longevity because I am cutting through bark and intermittent surfaces more often. In finish turning, at least TDT (turn, dry, turn), your are cutting a piece slightly out of round but can maintain more edge on the piece more of the time.

These are my current thoughts on this but as most things I try to stay open minded and learn. I'll need to continue playing with this to find out for sure. I changed my grind slightly shortly before switching to the CBN wheels which also may be playing a factor. Since I use 12 gouges when roughing I think I'll take six with my old grind and six with the new. Three of each of these I'll sharpen on the 180 grit and three I'll sharpen on the 80 grit and see if I can notice a difference.

Re: CBN Grits

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Not a direct comparison, but.....

Jesper, Denmark

I used a blue 80 grit wheel for sharpening gouges with a Varigrind on the right side and a white 120 grit for all else on the left side. Since I installed the 180 grit CBN wheel on the right for gouges and moved the blue 80 grit to the left - for mainly sharpening scrapers, I do seem to have scrapers that stay sharp longer.

I assume that the burr from the 80 grit blue wheel is stronger than the burr from the old 120 grit white wheel.

I don't production turn, so a 20 second double swipe to refresh an edge is not really an issue for me. This question of the burr function on gouges does seem interesting, and a question, which was not discussed till very recently.


Re: CBN Grits

#12

Steven Antonucci

burr on a gouge?

steven antonucci

Certainly, that is a very odd notion?

Assuming that you had any burr on a gouge, the only thing it would do is break off and cause metal stains on wet wood. You know all those little black dots? That is your burr...

For roughing out, it doesn't matter if you are sharpening at 80 grit or 1000 grit. Both will get the job done, the 1000 grit edge will hold up longer. It won't be 1000 grit sharp any longer than the 80 grit will be, but it will degrade to an 80 grit edge over time. For moving wood, it really isn't that critical to have the best edge for the entire job.

People like the CBN wheels because they are finer. Also, they never get out of round. That's two good reasons. Finer means sharper, which makes the edge last longer. Tormek owners have known this for 10 years.

S

Re: CBN Grits

#13

Can't prove that

Dale Bonertz

statement by me. I have been roughing bowls with my CBN wheels for over six months. The finer edge is not holding up as long as the edge I was getting with my 60 grit wheel. I first thought that was the case but felt that I needed to get several hundred blanks under my belt than just jump to that conclusion. I am still working on finding out for sure but that is a bold statement you just made as gospel. I have no doubt the tormek and CBN leave a nicer edge for finish turning but that finer edge does not hold up as well in rough turning through bark and interrupted cuts, at least to date with what I am experiencing.

The thinking of 1000 grit wheel will last longer philosophy because it goes down to an 80 grit wheel level doesn't make any sense to me. You have a cutting edge with very little burr and it is very sharp. Once you cut with the tool it is the same as sand paper when dull it is dull. It does not dull down to a 500 grit sharpening and then down to a 120 grit sharpening and then down to a 60 grit sharpening. That is utter nonsense in my opinion. Sand paper does not dull down to different grits either. The advantage of these edges is they are sharper and leave a nicer finish from the tool not necessarily longevity, even though it has been proven to last longer on finish turning.. Maybe this is because when I am finish turning I sharpen when I need to sharpen for a quality surface rather than push the tool past its usefulness and thus a poor surface.

What I am trying to figure out is when roughing does the more serrated edge that yes is a burr put on the gouge edge like a burr is put onto a scraper edge from the grinder wheel. Does this edge work through the burr/serrate and then you have a cutting edge left for a limited time and is this why the rougher wheels work a bit better for rough turning (note I am strictly talking about rough turning since I don't believe this is the case in finish turning). I find it interesting that it is pretty consistent that production turners like the 60/80 grit wheels so much when rough turning. They can't all be wrong or maybe their experience tells them otherwise.

I am going to try this on CBN wheels 80 grit versus 180 grit but from what I have learned to date the edge isn't much different between the two with CBN. Advantage to the 80 grit is it removes material quicker for shaping is what many have told me. Having said that Dave at D-way responded to me and said he sharpens his gouges with the 80 grit for turning and scrapers with the 180 grit. Again why unless his experience just taught him it is better that way.

I may be totally wrong on this and my tests will determine that. I read with interest the article in the AAW journal a few years ago and I agree that a sharper edge may last longer when finish turning. These edges being from CBN and Tormek. But I'll say it again that I think those tests were done on wet and dry wood in more finish type turning applications. I do not recall them cutting through bark and interrupted cuts which as we all know are hell on edges.

Re: CBN Grits

#14

I'm speculating on the physical.........

JamieDonaldson

.......characteristics of the courser grind having a sawtooth type pattern, with areas at the edge varying in thickness next to finer on a micro scale. Those thicker tooth-like areas would be stronger and less subject to chipping or breaking, whereas the more uniformly smooth thin edges from the finer wheels would degrade more quickly, regardless of the material being cut. :b

Re: CBN Grits

#15

Jesper, Denmark

Re: burr on a gouge?

Jesper, Denmark

I guess we have opened a can of worms here? There seems to be widely differing opinions, which usually is how one learns, as the statements are discussed and the technical aspects are examined.

The two basic questions asked are:

1. Does coarser grinding last longer when roughing a bowl?

2. Does a burr have a function on a gouge?

As I see it, in a conventional push cut with a bowl gouge, the cutting action is varying in different parts of the gouge. The tip is more or less shearscraping and leaves the final finish, but the wings og the gouge cut at a different angle and does the bulk removal - maybe closely approaching the function of a scraper.

If that statement is correct, then there is an indication that a coarser grind would last longer for roughing, as the burr is stronger.

I don't do production, so the decision to sharpen is simple: as soon as I feel something is not quite optimal, the first reaction is to sharpen. I have not paid attention to the longevity, so have no opining on the gouge useful life between sharpening.

The burr on scrapers does seem to last longer sharpened with 80 grit as opposed to 120 grit - but then I also have turning friends, who insist on honing away the burr on scrapers - go figure.

Re: CBN Grits

#16

Jamie and Jesper

Dale Bonertz

What your saying is in align to what I think is happening but where I get confused is when I see proof that the sharper edge lasts longer from Tormek. Now again that may simply be the difference between roughing and finish turning. I think we can all agree that a sharper edge will give you a better finished surface. It occurred to me this morning at 4 am when I awoke to contemplate this that it may be that there is an optimal nose and wing angle for the different applications roughing versus finishing. This optimal angle then is affected some by the grit or even type of wheel that is being used. More acute is sharper but more fragile while more obtuse is stronger but not as sharp and both I would think change a bit by what wheel is used.

I know, who cares, use what works and get over it. My mind is weird on some of these things that need to make more sense that is why I enjoy the discussions.

Re: CBN Grits

#17

Steven Antonucci

yeah, I think I can?

steven antonucci

So, in a nutshell, edges are ALWAYS sawtoothed because of the way that turners will typically get them (rotary wheel).

The 80 grit wheel will leave 80 "teeth" in an area that a 1000 grit wheel will leave 1000 "teeth". If you break 10 teeth, it is a lot worse than if I break 10 teeth. I don't think you'd dispute that, but I know where you'd go next... that the smaller teeth are much more likely to break, right? Let's test that theory with almost any material?

Metal structure is typically composed of lattices of iron with carbon in the voids to keep the structure from deforming. A larger tooth (i.e. 12.5X the size) will see torque forces 12.5X greater than a smaller tooth because the tooth is longer. Even though it is at a microscopic level, it is still 12.5X. Under these forces, it is more likely to break an 80 grit edge than a 1000 grit edge.

However, you probably don't notice it as much because the 80 grit edge isn't all that sharp anyhow. As it degrades, it loses "teeth", mimicking the effect of only having 60 teeth from a 60 grit wheel (albeit not the exact same thing, since the spots where teeth broke away are no longer sharp at all).

I can tell you that you'll get a similar effect from the Tormek graded to 220 or 1000, with the loss of "teeth" over time being much more noticeable because the edge WAS so much better when it started, but a dull Tormek ground gouge will still be much sharper than a dull 80 grit wheel ground gouge because the fractures are much smaller. When you lose a "tooth" that is 12.5X the size of the Tormek tooth, you leave behind a much larger blunt edge. Add to the overall discussion that any dry grinding wheel is also heating the metal up, which reduces it's strength, meaning more fractures are likely... and you've got Metallurgy 101.

You are certainly entitled to disagree with me, but I am not wrong.

Steve