Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

Posts

New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

#1

New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

Barry Irby

I watched the video about coring posted by Dale Bonertz on You Tube. Lots of good info. He commented you will never use the straight cutter/Parting tool.

I had never used mine. Today I was trying to clean up a large blank of nearly dry peach wood. It was 12 to 14" in diameter with hard rough bark on it. I have a spindle roughing gouge but don't use it on things like this because it has a weak tang. I was making some headway with my bowl gouge. It dawned on me that I had the straight cutter and it still has the old square point on it. I put the heavy handle on it (Bonertz does not use it either.) That long stiff tool with the heavy handle does a good job of hogging off the bark and out of round sections. Give it a try.

(It also dawned on me that I could bend it to a curve and use it like its brothers.)

Re: New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

#2

Re: New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

Dale Bonertz

That would be a good use Barry. The video was edited so to be clear I do use the straight tool on occasion. They left in the joking part of it is in the handle and on my shelf. It is good for a conical core, slicing a platter size of the face of a deeper blank or cutting a thicker chunk off the face if it is no good like the pith area. I don't use the old handle ever though. I think he changed them now so they are more usable. I am 51 and those old handles take me and my son to lift and hold on the lathe. :)

You would be shocked on how I learned to use the straight blade. I used it off of the tool rest with no turret to get a conical core. I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS. My mentor taught me this method for the speed of turning our bowl blanks. I no longer do it this way and haven't for years. I have learned to slow down a bit and be a little safer in my approaches. Johannes has a coring tool similar to how we used to use the McNaughton straight blade. Except his tucks under his forearm and arm pit. We used it with that heavy handle and by peer stupidity and muscle.

Re: New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

#3

Re: New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

robo hippy

Barry,

I am trying to figure out if you are using it like a scraper from the side, or plunging down the side from the end/bottom of the bowl and cutting off a cone shape. I have heard of people doing that. Kelton did used to make a 'left handed' version of his tools so you could core from the headstock end. Not sure if he does that any more or not. A bit less vibration with them as the wide part of the bowl was right on the headstock.

I just use scrapers for removing bark and all my roughing. They just work better for me than gouges. Beefier, and better at taking heavy loads.

If you want to bend the straight blade for coring, you can tweak them a tiny bit, but if you really want an arc, it is difficult. I am not sure what the steel type is, but you can fracture it by heavy bending.

robo hippy

Re: New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

#4

Re: New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

Barry Irby

I am approaching the work as if it is a giant parting tool. (Wait, it actually is a giant parting tool.) I hold the handle horizontal or slightly down and "part" into the work until I am through or nearly through the bark. Then I skip a space about the width of the cutter and go again. Then go back and take out the rib I left behind. I also use it to knock off the corners until the piece is nearly round. It really takes the beating out of the process. With the long blade and heavy handle its less brutal on me than using a gouge. (I do not have one of the big heavy roughing gouges.)

I have only done this once, so the experience is very limited. But worth a try. Until this it had laid in the drawer of unused tools for about ten years.

Re: New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

#5

Rude Osolnik used a similar straight .........

JamieDonaldson

...Stewart tool for coring long before current coring tools were available. He called it a spear, and the secret to safe use is to keep the kerf wide enough to avoid binding.

Re: New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

#6

I'm not coring this time.....

Barry Irby

Just using it to rough the exterior.

Re: New use for McNaughton Straight Cutter

#7

Re: Rude Osolnik used a similar straight .........

Dale Bonertz

Jamie,

That is funny you bring that slicer up. When I used to core off of the tool rest I used the McNaughton to go down most of the way and then would switch to the Stewart Slicer to finish the last inch or so. It was narrower than the McNaughton so it was perfect for the last little bit.