Been turning bowls. I get some tear out on opposite sides of the interior of them. If the pith were horizontal at 3 and 9 o'clock (anybody still got and analog clock?) the tear out would be at about 2 and 8. Right where the grain angle changes from "vertical to horizontal".
One thing I noticed is that it is less on larger bowls, above 12 inches in diameter and more on bowls in the 8 to 10" range. Is this true or just a coincidence? Or does it change with the type of wood? I am turning green ambrosia maple.
I am turning with an Ellsworth gouge. Keeping it sharp helps. Any suggestion on how to avoid the tear out?
That is the stereotypical location for tearout. Wood species does matter-some wood cut cleanly easier than others, etc. Size matters? Not so much. Some forms have more wood in problematic areas, a flatter bowl compared to a taller bowl.
When I'm roughing a bowl, I'm doing just that "roughing". Not concerned with tearout. For finishing cuts, I like the stubby grind gouge (Batty, Mahoney, Lucas) for the interior. I like to undercut the rim of my bowls so I use a small gouge with swept back grind for the undercut and about an inch of the bowl's wall. Then I switch to the stubby grind gouge for the interior. It's the near vertical sides of the stubby grind that shears through even the most stubborn grain. I always refresh the edge before the final cut. No tearout.
As a practice exercise, I challenge students to take a gouge, refresh the edge, and try to take the smallest cut they can. Do it with all gouges. Produce the smallest, tightest shaving they can. It's the epitome of tool control and also the cleanest cut. With practice you'll be able to do finishing cuts with small gouges and big gouges. Just because a gouge is "big" it doesn't mean it has to be a bulldozer.
If you are trying to make one pass from the rim to the foot, I suggest working your roughing cuts as practice runs for that final cut. I see a lot of people that start the cut with a 1/32" shaving, and they are trying to cut a 1/2" by the time they get to the bottom of the bowl.
Try making passes that the shaving is the same width and thickness the entire length of the cut. If you can do this, you will solve the tearout problem.
...an application of a stabilizing material such as wax, mineral oil, or my favorite, thinned lacquer. I seldom turn spitting wet wood, so on dry wood the lacquer acts as sealer and undercoat for the final finish. Tearout occurs where the fibers are not cleanly sliced, and stabilizing the fibers allows them to be sliced rather than simply bent over or yanked away.
I would add that the shape of the bowl can matter -- achieving a smooth, fair curve from rim to center can help. If you have "sides" and a "bottom" you probably have a sharper curve where these meet, which is not only a less attractive form, but can cause tear-out because its hard to keep the edge and bevel engaged properly through this small radius curve.
Second, "ambrosia" Maple has discoloration from a beetle infestation, which is sometimes accompanied by softer wood fibers if there's a decayed area. If you do have any soft or slightly punky areas, they may have to be treated to stiffen the fibers and help you get a clean cut. Thinned lacquer or shellac can help, or one of the super-toxic wood hardeners.
The third of my two thoughts ( -- like the four books in the Hitchhiker's Guide trilogy ), and differing with Greg to some extent, is that species and hardness can be factors. Softer woods tend to require more care, as do ring-porous woods that don't cut as cleanly. If your technique is perfect, wood species doesn't matter much, but we can get away with a little more on really hard, fine grained woods. I never have tearout on Eastern Hophornbeam, for example, but try Hemlock or Tamarack for a real nasty time.
I find that oils, or thin lacquer, help in reducing tear out and also aide is sanding. ( I frequently use a sanding wax mixture of mineral oil and bee's wax. Almost any wax will work for sanding.)
I think it is impossible to totally get rid of tear out on any bowl type object that is turned in flat grain orientation. For 1/4 of a turn, you are cutting down hill with the grain, and for 1/4 of a turn you are cutting up hill against the grain, then the pattern repeats. The tear out sections are reversed when inside and outside the bowl. What happens is that the fiber tears before it cuts. Causes can be many. If you don't think you have tear out on the outside of your bowl, just hand spin it in reverse, and leave the other hand on the bowl. You will feel it.
Dull tools is one major cause. If your tools are dull, it doesn't make any difference what you do with them, you will not get a clean cut. Easily solved.
Shear angle is another. A scraping cut, with the cutting edge at 90 degrees to the spin has no shear angle, and will tear a lot. This is a scraper flat on the tool rest, or a gouge, with handle level and cutting with the wing (note here, the nose of the gouge will be at a shear angle, so the wing scrapes, and the nose is shearing). This is mostly a roughing cut. With most gouges, the nose angle will allow you about 45 degrees of shear angle. On the outside of the bowl, you can drop your handle and get a higher shear angle. This is not easy to do on the inside of the bowl as the rim and bed of your lathe get in the way. Here you can roll your tools more on their sides. This helps. The higher the shear angle, generally the cleaner the cut. My favorite tool for this finish cut is a fluteless gouge from Doug Thompson. I have a You Tube clip up if you type in robo hippy, and/or I posted it here a few weeks back. I have also ground some spindle/detail gouges to a ) nose profile and they do a very similar job.
Some times it is the wood. Some will tear if you just look at them. Figured wood will tend to tear more because the grain goes in all directions. Crotch feathering is difficult to cut as well, again because the grain goes in many different directions. Wood that is rotting will tear because there is little in the way of grain structure left to support that which is being cut. A bevel rubbing cut generally does a better job of leaving a clean surface than a non bevel rubbing cut.
Some times it is how you are cutting. The finish cut is really a pressure sensitive thing. If you push too hard, you will tear, no matter how sharp your tool is. It also makes a different sound. You can remove a 1/2 inch wide shaving and have it be a finish cut. The important part here is how thick the shaving is, not how wide. A thinner shaving means you are letting the tool cut, and a thicker shaving means you are forcing the tool to cut. Having a uniformly width shaving works if the bowl profile is perfect, but most of the time, I have bumps and dips on the inside of the bowl, so the shaving can start narrow, get wider, and then taper down to nothing. I can start at the rim with an angle hair shaving, and finish at the bottom with a 1/2 inch wide shaving. Feeling the wood cut is especially important as you get near the center because while the rpm remains constant, the feet per minute rate goes down to almost nothing as you reach the center, so your push rate also goes to almost nothing.
Getting the wood wet with oil, water, wax or whatever does help lubricate the fibers and make them cut a bit easier. This works a lot better on dry wood than it does on wet wood, mostly because the wet wood is already lubricated.
You can remove a lot of the tear out with very gentle shear scrape cuts. This is a scraper up on its edge at a 45 or higher angle, handle slightly lowered, and very gentle pull cuts towards the rim. It should take several passes to remove tool marks and tear out.