Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

Posts

turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

#1

turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

Darrin Hill

i have a big sorby roughing gouge and was sharpening it on a wheel yesterday and was wondering how long my gouge would last if i sharpened more often, even though when sharpening you take off very little..

Then it struck me that wally has been around since they invented the lathe... and wheel.. and knew noah personally...(sorry wally)...

But he bought his first lathe in the 30's... before some of our oldsters were even born..

was curious how the tools have changed in the past 70 odd years, how often does he replace tools .. how long has that roughing gouged lasted him after he sharpens every day...

thought this might be interesting on lathe evolution...

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

#2

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

John Lucas

Just as a point of interest. I have had the same roughing gouge for about 20 years. Granted in the early days I probably didn't sharpen it as much as I should. I use it a lot because I do a fair amount of spindle turning although they to tend to be smaller. I don't know how long it was but it's still fairly long.

I'll look at some of my other tools and be ready to chat on Wednesday. Now that I think about it my parting tool and flat scraper came from the same set of tools as my roughing gouge.

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

#3

Ellis Walentine

Technique has something to do with it

Ellis Walentine

You mentioned taking off very little when sharpening. The longevity of the tool is entirely dependent on how much you take off, so a conservative sharpening technique would seem to be critical. I'll be interested in seeing how others conserve metal when sharpening. I know I've worn a couple Ellsworth gouges and many hollowing tips down to half their length or less.

This also brings up the heat treatment method for various tools, and whether the hardness is uniform as the tool gets shorter. That would affect wear, although with powdered metal and HSS tools, I suspect this is pretty much a non-issue.

Good suggestion for a chat, Darrin. Thanks.

Ellis

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

#4

Steven Antonucci

I have passed on some tools, but never consumed 1?

steven antonucci

I would guess that it is almost impossible for even the most avid hobbyist to consume any tool in his or her lifetime once they know what they are doing? I am certain that you can over-grind stuff in the beginning, ad that probably accounts for 50% of the wear on a conventional tool.

If you were a full on production turner, I could see it happening. I've moved a lot of wood in my lifetime, but Glenn Lucas moves that much in a year. I bet he goes through tools.

In 10 years, check back in with me. I'll probably be down to the last inch on my Oneway by then. Luckily, I still have a Sorby and Thompsons to back it up.

Steve

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

#5

Re: I have passed on some tools, but never consume

John Lucas

I've used up a couple of bowl gouges. Those were the hardest to learn to sharpen back when I started. No jigs of any sort and my free hand sharpening on a 40 grit gray stone lacked a lot of finess. Each time I sharpened I tried to reduce the number of facets from the previous sharpening :) Never was sure if it was a dull tool or my techniques so I would sharpen again, finding a whole new set of facets to try and find that bevel to rub. :)

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

#6

Steven Antonucci

and then you learned to sharpen...

steven antonucci

and now you grind the heel off and make facets again ;)

S

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

#7

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

dick gerard

I purchased a "Super Flute" bowl gouge when they first came out. Used it extensively for 20 years. Finally, the flute was less than 2 inches in length and the metal at that point was so soft as to be unusable. Since then, all my bowl gouges, skews, etc., are powdered metal. I have no idea how long they will last, but I am fairly sure they will be part of my estate when I transition to the next plane of existence. ANd yes, I was an early advocate of sharpening jigs.

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

#8

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

Wally Dickerman

Darrin, Actually I knew Noah's grandfather.....Many of the tools we use today didn't even exist when I started turning. All were carbon steel. I still have a few from a set of Greenlee tools that I bought in the 50s. Tools were made for the spindle turner. If you wanted to turn bowls you had to make your own tools. I still have some of my shop made tools. The bowl gouge wasn't marketed in this country until around 1980. It took a while for it to become known. I bought my first bowl gouge, a Sorby in 1982 or 83. It's worn out but I still have it. The flute is less than an inch long. The handle is 12 inch long. High speed steel wasn't used for turning tools until the late 70's and early 80's.

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

#9

I thought I was in hog heaven when........

JamieDonaldson

...I bought my first set of Greenlee tools back when, they had such a nice finish on both metal and handles! Then I met Rude Osolnik, and soon found out that pretty handles and shiny tools were not the secret to quality turnings. I've worn several bowl gouges down to nubs over the years, but don't recall any other tools that have been ground completely away in my 26 yrs. of turning.

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

#10

Dick Hines

Re: turning topic for wed - wally's tools..

Dick Hines

I have some old Sears tools that belonged to my Dad. Don't use them any more but would not part with them.

When I was in high school, not saying how long it has been, there were no chucks and the bowl gouge was not thought of yet. All the bowls ahd screw holes in the bottom that were covered with felt.

I use a bowl gouge for most all my turning. I have one I bought form Doug Thompson at the AAW Symposium in Richmond, Va in 2008. Not much left but still use for roughing out side of bowls.