Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Coring, observations.....

Posts

Coring, observations.....

#1

Coring, observations.....

Barry Irby

I have what I believe is the medium set of McNaughton cutter for coring blanks.

They have about an 8, 10, and 12" radius. They have a long and miserable history. They came with old style chisel or straight across cutters. They were very poorly bent and I soon figured out that they MUST be a segment of a circle. I sent them to the US rep and he declared they were bent well enough, reground the tips to a point and sent them back. They still would not work worth a damn because they could not track into the slot they were cutting. A friend helped me re-shape them into circles and they worked MUCH better. Then I foolishly lent them to an acquaintance. He did not follow my instructions to sharpen them along the front edge like a scraper. He ground the hardened metal off the top. Without that, they stay sharp about half a second. Mike Hunter stepped in here on Wood Central and offered to install some of his cutters to rescue the knives. He did that for a reasonable amount of money. It was like a miracle. Those things cut like a laser.

The problem that remained was that the cutters were just barely wider than the thickness of the steel. They actually would not cut a path wide enough to clear the knife.

So, for the last few days, I have been tweaking the knives. I have been observing them carefully and learned a number of things. To work well they have to be very carefully bent to conform to the curvature of the path to allow the knife to follow. I have been inking them and watching where the ink rubs off and either bending them or grinding and filing away a bit of steel. It has been a tedious and aggravating process, but they are getting better and better.

Re: Coring, observations.....

#2

Re: Coring, observations.....

Bill Howatt

The McNaughton system requires a bit more "adjustment" than say the Oneway system, IMO, although I've never used a Oneway.

I do not expect the knife to go into a single knife-width kerf for the entire cut. I always open up the kerf where it enters the blank and probably widen it with a bit of wiggling as it goes through the blank. You should not need a bit wide kerf though.

Bill

Re: Coring, observations.....

#3

Ditto what bill just said


Re: Coring, observations.....

#4

Re: Coring, observations.....

robo hippy

I have maintained for some years that the blades on the McNaughton are not properly bent. For sure, the newer Mark 8 blades are far better than the older sets. and having the newer spear point centered on the blade is a huge improvement. If the blade was a perfect arc of a circle, you should be able to follow the cut by just keeping the blade in the center of the kerf. If you look carefully, you will note that in just about every blade, the last inch or so of the blade goes straight rather than following the arc of the circle. This is why the blade always drifts to the outside of the cut. This is a smaller problem on small cores and a larger problem on larger cores. If you can tweak that last little bit in just a hair, they will follow the arc a lot better, and you do not have to continually adjust.

robo hippy

Re: Coring, observations.....

#5

Re: Coring, observations.....

Bill Howatt

In his video Mike Mahoney goes in as far as he can for a first cut then on the second cut he opens it up by about 1/8" by cutting the next bowl (this is going from small to large bowls) and follows this line through to where he left off.

He also mentions wiggling the tool for more clearance and also moving the banjo if binding occurs. Nothing in the setup has to remain permanently set during the cutting process.

Bill

Re: Coring, observations.....

#6

Steven Antonucci

and making sure your cutter is sharp

steven antonucci

it is amazing to me how much better the tool works when it is sharp. I turn my grinder on for a second, and then back off so as to not generate a lot of heat or remove too much metal. it is nearly effortless when it is done correctly, and much, much different when you have a dull cutter.

I have no idea at all of my knives are segments of a circle... never checked?

S

Re: Coring, observations.....

#7

Re: Coring, observations.....

robo hippy

The part about wiggling the tool as you go in is to open up the kerf. This is not necessary on the other coring systems, and my opinion is that with a perfect arc of a curve, you do not have to wiggle, at least not till you have ground the tip way down.

robo hippy

Re: Coring, observations.....

#8

Joe Fleming

Re: Coring, observations.....

Joe Fleming

Excellent and dead-on observations by all. I'm a McNaughton user and agree with these comments. Joe

Re: Coring, observations.....

#9

Re: Coring, observations.....

Jeff Smith

these are great observations - don't really have anything of substance to add, but...I've been using the MacNaughton for about four or five years and have finally gotten comfortable with it. A while back I watched a video of a demo of Mike Hosaluk and Del Stubbs turning a bowl. Mike grabbed the MacNaughton, looked at the blade carefully, then stuck the tip between the ways and promptly adjusted the curve by pulling on the handle and bending it slightly to shape. That petty well took the mystery out of it for me. I relaxed and just tried to figure out where the tip was going to wind up.

It's a great tool; keeps some pieces from turning into shavings on the floor, and maximizes use of the timber. By the way - I think if I had had the information that Dale Bonertz has put out lately both on YouTube and in the AAW journal sooner I could have shortened my learning curve by a long shot. Apologies for any names I've mangled in spelling.