A Richmond, Va, neighbor cut down a big hemlock. I cut one bowl blank from it, not expecting much, and it was horrible. Fiber clusters and pure damnation made me give it up after a few minutes. Then I turned some branch wood between centers to make some gnomes for Christmas, and it couldn't have been better. Beautiful surface, no need to sand.
...(I'll assume) because you were turning the bowl in the side-grain orientation, which means the end grain comes around twice per rev. (If that's not the case, then ignore this response.) The branch would be longitudinal in the end-grain direction, and you're not cutting any end-grain. ...GG
I've had similar trouble with hemlock and other softwoods. One time I asked Jerry Glaser about it and he sent me these demo pieces of Doug fir and even a piece of balsa that he had turned with a really sharp A11 1/2" bowl gouge. End grain and side grain are as smooth as silk. I've lost his cover letter, so I can't tell you precisely how he sharpened for this difficult wood.
The sapwood almost exploded in scrambled fibers when I tried to turn a bowl from a fresh-cut log. I wonder how any tool could be sharp enough to turn green hemlock in side grain orientation. It certainly speaks volumes about Glaser's sharpening and turning skills if he were able to do it. But between centers it is great. I've turned/carved about 50 gnomes from branch wood, and as I wrote before, it's a delight to work with. It made me wonder if it would work to turn end grain bowls or vases from the trunk. I have access to a lot of it, and the grain is very nice, albeit soft, especially the sap wood.
I guess that might explain it. But, I must say that I tried to duplicate the surface quality Jerry was getting and I couldn't come close with my own tools.
I had the pleasure of meeting Jerry in his home in the '90's. What a gracious gentleman, and master toolmaker he was. He shared his tiny workshop and showed me his collection of exotic woods from everywhere, it seemed.
In his living room resided two Sam Maloof rockers, one of Macassar Ebony. He encouraged me to sit in it, but I was leery of breaking something of such beauty. Jerry told me that Sam had gifted the chair to him. What a history he was able to share in a short visit, discussing the evolution of Bob Stocksdale's gouge, and the subsequent development of his tool line. I could have stayed for many more hours.
Since this was a shopping trip, he sold me a few gouges, and sent me on my way in order to get back to work grinding gouges. His grinding jig worked so well for his purposes, and when you got one of his tools, it was sharp.
One of the more memorable times I have had over the years.