Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

Posts

Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

#1

Jesper, Denmark

Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

Jesper, Denmark

I have been grinding my scrapers at a 80° angle for years - from a viwpoint that as much metal as possible under the cutting tip would be more stable and reduce vibration.

The actual cutting angle is determined by the presentation of the upper surface of the tool and it's presentation to the wood, so the sharpening angle should have no influence - except when the bevel gets in the way in confined spaces.

Since updating some tools and revising my grinder set-up, I have changed this to 70° - mainly to be able to leave the platform toolrest in one place for both scrapers and the new Thompson fluteless gouge. It seems that the burr at this angle is more robust and lasts longer.

Does this make any sense??

Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

#2

Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

Jorge

Hello Jesper,

Yes it makes sense. I use same 70* angle

Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

#3

Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

John Lucas

I now use a 45 degree angle. I don't use my scrapers to hog wood. They are only used to remove small amounts or to shear scrape. I have also added a negative rake to them. The negative rake allows you to put less forward pressure on the wood so cuts with less force.

For shear scraping I'm not sure the negative rake has any advantage but it doesn't seem to hurt.

I think a lot it has to do with weather you raise the burr by hand or if you use it straight off the grinder. I do both depending on the tool and what I'm doing with it. Using the tool flat on the tool rest (which I seldom do) the burr off the grinder seems to work just fine. For shear scraping I prefer to control the size and I guess you could say the grit of the burr by raising it using either a diamond hone or ceramic stone. The finer the hone the smaller the burr but it will often cut cleaner.

Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

#4

Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

Sergio

Hello Jesper, the raising of a burr is due to the plastic deformation of the metal at at the edge being machined. It is raised in every machining operations when a cutting, drilling or grinding tool touches the metal. The type of burr and its size and shape depends from many factors and the angle between the metal and the grinding wheel is one of these. So, yes your observation make sense but the seventy degrees is only one of the factors involved, the pressure, the type and speed of the wheel etc may all be involved.

The paradox is that in metallurgy the burr is a big problem and its removal can be responsible for a big part of the costs of a final product while in woodturning and woodworking it can be a sought byproduct of the grinding process.

Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

#5

Steven Antonucci

I have no idea what angle my scraper is?

steven antonucci

If I had to guess, it is less than 80? Interestingly enough, is I need to fine scrape an interior, I reach for a skew with a rounded edge, and use it as an NRS. It works better than shear scraping. YMMV

Steve

Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

#6

Steven Antonucci

and no burr...


Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

#7

Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

robo hippy

The first scrapers I got, the Artisan set from Craft Supplies some 18 or so years ago came sharpened in the 60 to 70 degree range. I kept pretty much the same angle, and now with my platform, I keep it at 70 degrees. I have seen more pointy angles in the 45 degree range, but, like John does, I don't think they are used for heavy roughing. As to the burr, I use the one straight from the grinder. There is a big difference in the burr from the CBN wheels when compared to the standard aluminum oxide wheels. The CBN is much better, as in more durable for heavy roughing, and for making finer finish shear cuts. I have played with the honed burrs, but not seriously put them to work. I didn't notice any big differences, so to me, they are not worth the extra effort. I have gone back and forth on my CBN wheels from 80 to 180, and don't notice any real performance difference either. I have burnished burrs, by hand with a triangle burnisher, and the results to me have been pretty much the same. I haven't tried the burnishing tool from Lee Valley though. Main thing with a burnished burr, you want very light passes to turn the burr. If doing it by hand, if your bevel angle is 70 degrees, you want the burnisher to be at 80 to 90 degrees. If you over burnish, you can actually turn the burr over like a breaking wave, and it is very difficult to cut with. I haven't put the negative rake scraper to a serious test either. Most of the wood I turn is on the softer side, and if the NR scraper had any real advantage, it is in the much harder woods. For finish cuts, I always use a shear angle rather than flat on the tool rest. It just cuts cleaner.

robo hippy

Re: Scraper sharpening angle - any difference??

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Thanks Guys......

Jesper, Denmark

Lots of interesting comments here. I'll stick with the 70°, as it seems to work both for hogging a la Robohippe and delicate shearscraping.

One additional comment: I just received a Thompson scraper - it is better in a couple of ways in relation to the older tools. The thicker 5/16" makes it more stable than the more common 1/4" and the steel just stays sharp longer than anything else.