Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Oneway tower jaws

Posts

Oneway tower jaws

#1

Oneway tower jaws

Mavdad55

Has anyone tried these? With all the discussion about tennon vs recess, no one mentioned the use of oneway profile jaws. These have a larger range of safe contact when the tennon is larger than the closed size due to their shape. True they have teeth, but I would assume most folks finish the bottom of the tennon last which gives you a chance to remove the teeth marks.

Oneway now has tower jaws which have both the profile shape, for longer tenons and dovetail at the outside edge; for the type of holding you have all been discussing. So I was looking to see if anyone has tried these in both modes, profile and tennon. They also have the advantage of getting the wood farther away from the chuck body, making it easier to work on the backside.

Re: Oneway tower jaws

#2

Re: Oneway tower jaws

Sergio

I regolarly use the Vicmarc tower jaws, called shark jaws. I love them and they are also great for holding the spigot of longer spindles in long vessels. I always try to get as close as possible to the perfect round so that they do non make any mark in the wood and hold at their best. Obviously using long spigots this may not be completely true.

Re: Oneway tower jaws

#3

Re: Oneway tower jaws

Jeff Smith

I've got the OneWay Tower jaws for both the Stronghold and the Talon chucks - I like them, they work well. I use the ones for the Stronghold pretty often - mostly to reach a little deeper into a rough turned blank and grip on a shallow recess for truing up an out-of-round tenon. I tend to use just the dovetail portion of the jaws when I turn the piece around to hollow the bowl, even though the tenon needs to be pretty short - about 3/16" max. Haven't used the 'profiled' portion of the jaws yet - just haven't had the need for a tenon that long yet.

Re: Oneway tower jaws

#4

Re: Oneway tower jaws

Jorge

I use them in my Stronghold regularly when I am turning vases, I make a tenon almost as long as the jaws. It work great, never had a problem.

Using the dovetail portion works in sound wood if it is on the small side, not so in spalted or otherwise deteriorated wood or on big pieces.

Re: Oneway tower jaws

#5

Re: Oneway tower jaws

Chuck Engstrom

I have a #3 set of Oneway Stronghold tower jaws I haven't used for a couple of years after the first pieces I put in them came flying off. The gripping dovetail at the top takes a larger diameter than the serrated section deeper in the jaws, and this means you have to cut a short tenon, just less than 1/4" deep, to grip with only the top dovetails OR a substantially longer one, at least 3/4" deep, to have enough wood into the lower serrated portion to get a proper grip with the serrations only, since your tenon will NOT be gripped by the dovetails if it's already gripped by the serrations deeper in the jaws.

Needless to say, I learned this all the hard way, as it was not mentioned in whatever literature came with them. I just sort of assumed that it was all the same diameter in there (it sure looks that way until you put a straight edge on it) and a 1/2" deep tenon would do fine, but I didn't realize it would only be gripped by two serrations and not at all at the top dovetail, and the piece came out pretty quickly. It took a while to figure out what the problem was, and I have to say I think they would be better and much safer if the gripping diameter were the same throughout, or at least discussed in accompanying literature.

When used in for expansion into a socket, they're just the same as all the other Oneway jaws and work just fine, giving you further depth from the body.

Best to all -- Chuck

Re: Oneway tower jaws

#6

Re: Oneway tower jaws

robo hippy

Well, I haven't tried them, the tower type ones on my Vicmark. I can see them being an advantage for end grain oriented things as the longer grip will help stabilize longer pieces. With bowl grain orientation, I can't see any advantage other than getting the piece farther away from the headstock. I took a workshop with Allan and Stuart Batty some years ago, and Stuart used a tenon for his bowl turning. He said that a longer tenon, in flat grain orientation was actually a weaker hold than a shorter tenon. Nothing over 1/4 inch. After pondering that one for some years, I think that if perfectly made to fit the chuck jaws (angle and diameter wise), it may not be weaker, but for sure offers no advantage, and wastes a bit of wood depth. I do use extended jaws for sanding. I use a recess, so with it extended, I can sand all the way down the outside of the bowl.

robo hippy

Re: Oneway tower jaws

#7

Re: Oneway tower jaws

Mavdad55

Thank you all for the comments. At this at this point I think I will skip the tower jaws and just purchase the standard dovetail jaws. All I have today are number 2 and 3 profile jaws, which I like. I was wanting to try dovetail jaws and thought the tower jaws would give a little of both, but it sounds like you don't get the best of either holding method with the tower jaws.