Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Ellis Walentine

Yes, folks, late again this month, we need your thoughts on yet another vexing woodworking question. This time it's regarding the future, and maybe the essence, of woodworking. Specifically, CNC vs craftsmanship.

The Museum of Art & Design in Manhattan has an exhibit this Fall of computer-assisted production, not only in wood, but across a range of decorative and functional objects. Also, a major highlight of this year's AWFS in Las Vegas was the introduction of new CNC equipment at more affordable prices for smaller shops. The question is whether this still qualifies as woodworking or is it just computer programming? Are consumers even aware of how things are made? Do they care, or are they just interested in utility and/or aesthetics? And, does the concept of "craftsmanship" apply to CNC-produced furniture and other wood objects?

What do you think?

As usual, we'll publish a digest of your opinions in the next issue of Woodworker West magazine. Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#2

Steven Antonucci

it depends upon why you buy things

steven antonucci

For me, I have all of the stuff that I "need". I am now buying things that I want. I also sell things this way. I sell to want, not need. If you need a bowl, Wal-Mart is waiting. If you want a bowl, I am waiting. I want people to want the things I make because I made them. The implications are that I am necessary.

CNC is about manufacturing. Most people will never be able to compete with a machine. Even those at a master level can only produce a few masterpieces in their lifetime. A machine doesn't have this limitation, which is both good and bad. It means more people can have something at a lower price. I'm not sure if that is good or bad, but I know it is true.

I think design is important, and machines make things that might be completely impractical for most people to manufacture, but I'm not convinced that easier is always better? You really need to define your requirements to ascribe better or worse. We do know that well made, handmade furniture has survived hundred or more years. I don't know if I would be as confident with some of the machine made pieces lasting as long. I also think that they tend to play to a very odd design standard that may not have the long term staying power of traditional design.

Can it be better through technology? Probably, but I am not sure that's what we're seeing right now.

Steve

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#3

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Greg Haugen

There are so many aspects to take into account.

Is there a place for craftsmanship in CNC work and manufacturing? Sure. No matter what we do during our day, passion and attention to details will show in some and not others. I am a graduate of a Cabinetry/Furniture/Carpentry Technical College program. We had a class on CNC programming. I really enjoyed it and accelerated at it, a lot of others .....well......not so much. It is a craft and a skill.

Do people really care from where and how things are made? Some do, some don't. There are educated consumers and consumers that merely consume. The major issue in our economy is just that, too many merely consume. Quantity, not quality. Yes. In our world today, some have an addiction to the big box store-I want it cheap and I don't care where it is from. While other want to know where something is from and who made it. A classic example of this is the regular food market and the organic food market. Both are very strong.

Part of the CNC topics reminds me about a topic from when I was a kid and it was about fast food restaurants. The big hype was that they were going to be run by robots and little to no people would be needed to run a restaurant. That was 20-25 years ago and where are robots?

For most, the joy of making doesn't come from pushing a button. Look at the "traditional" woodworkers. Electricity isn't new, but don't tell a traditionalist to put down their handsaws and use a table saw. CNC will be an option, but it won't push everything to the side.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#4

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

John Lucas

It's only one more step. We made dovetails by hand, then many switched to dovetail machines, and now CNC.

Same with carving. The trick will be to educate the customer. However CNC if done right could match most of our hand cut techniques. Will we have to introduce personal flaws in order to highlight our work from the machines?

On the plus side, if you can imagine it, you could make it. The next step above CNC of course is simply printing your imagination. Of course that can't be done in wood yet but they will probably figure a way in the future. Might even be able to print grain patterns.

Those of us who are computer illiterate will never step into CNC so I guess I'll just have to learn to sharpen my tools better.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

bob davis

most only interested in end product. could care less how it was produced.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#6

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

George Guadiane

There are serigraphs and giclees in the flat art world, they sell for less money than an original work and they are generally in limited editions.

At some point, someone has to program the machine. That may (or may not) take a great deal of skill, in and of itself, so, in the overall, I'd say that CNC PRODUCTS like the laser "carved" "art work", they might have a tiny place in the ART world, but based on price.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#7

Joe Fleming

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Joe Fleming

A craftsperson doesn't just know how to accomplish a task. A true craftsperson knows why they do it the way they do it. A craftsperson will be concerned about the grain orientation, color and figure matching, the fit of the tenon, and the quality of the finish. If a machinist considers these things when machining wood, then they are applying craftmanship to the piece, regardless of the tools used. The risk with increasing automation is that we forget why we do things the way we do.