Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

Posts

Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

#1

Steven Antonucci

Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

steven antonucci

Last night, we had a session on using chainsaws and cutting wood for various projects. I did a quick fly-by of the pile prior to cutting and I knew that there would be some issues.

One of the larger pieces of wood was an apple crotch that exhibited some rotting from the outside. Once it was sawed to rough, I could see how deep the wood had been compromised. I also knew that it would be raffled off at the end of the meeting, and I was doing my best to cull out the stuff that was obvious firewood, but I let a couple of the apple pieces get up to the table for the discussion part.

I was amazed to see people oohing and aahing over the one apple crotch, talking about the enormous platter that they could make out of it. I pointed out that it had some soft spots, and people immediately looked for "ways to deal with soft spots".

When everything from CA glue to wood hardener had been discussed, I simply interjected "Guys, this is the kind of blank that nearly killed Adrian Coblenz" I talked briefly about the fact that the soft parts were well past saving and that the best solution would be to just simply make a smaller piece out of it, using only the wood that was safe. It took a while, but everyone got there.

By the end of the meeting, people started looking at a lot of bad wood with a much more critical eye. We have a lot of new turners that can easily be lured by the beauty of a spalt line, and with their level of skill, they run the risk of running into problems.

Moving forward, I will look through my pile of wood and bring in a piece to describe WHY it's never been on my lathe at both clubs in the effort to build on our club's collective education about what is good, and what is risky. What is risky today may only be risky because of the person cutting it. It may also only be risky for the project you are considering. Knowing how to "Read Wood" is a skill that I think needs more attention in the clubs, and I was surprised to see how much people didn't know.

Steven

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

#2

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

Dwight Rutherford

Good thread! Good idea to show to all.Thanks !

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

#3

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

robo hippy

Steve, our club meeting is on Thursday and I am taking a piece in for show and tell. It is a slab from a sugar maple about 14 inch diameter. When fresh cut, there was a pretty brown ring about 2 inches in from the outside. To me, this shouted 'ring shake'. Most would have looked it as design feature. As the end cut dried, the ring mostly separated from the center. I do try to take pieces like this in to share my knowledge. I NEVER trust any piece of wood till it is sanded, finished, and off the lathe. Maybe having a show and tell for exploded pieces would help. I have one crotch piece with a bark inclusion all the way through it. There are other examples out there.

robo hippy

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

#4

Sounds like an excellent subject for many.........

JamieDonaldson

...more clubs to address!

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

#5

Re: Safely turning questionable wood

Doug Wolf

Steve, You said "We have a lot of new turners that can easily be lured by the beauty of a spalt line, and with their level of skill, they run the risk of running into problems." and I couldn't agree more.

That being said, I would like to say that with proper experience and knowledge of the wood being turned, some questionable wood can be safely turned. Please note the cage and tailstock and the wood never turned over 450 rpm. It's a 17" Walnut crotch with a bark pocket almost all of the way through both pieces.


Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

#6

Steven Antonucci

There are ways to reduce risk

steven antonucci

The conversation at our club was around reading wood and figuring out what you might expect to see. Someone had a piece that looked like yours does, and we cam to the conclusion that it would be extremely risky for probably 80% of the club, and just risky for the other 20%.

The risk of turning wood that looks like this is probably 80% in the hands that hold the tool and the knowledge of the person that is standing at the lathe. It can be done with less risk, using a lot of the ideas you presented (low speed, safety cage, turning from the tailstock end to get out of the LOF). If you do this, you can almost completely remove the possibility of injury.

The remaining 20% is harder to get at, because it involves the unknown. The wood and bark can let loose even under experienced and knowledgeable hands. At this point, so may lose the piece (which is no big deal), but you are unlikely to get hurt.

I would have finished the back of this piece in a very large donut chuck that I made for platters. Once it is pressed inside the donut, it's not going anywhere,

Steve

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

#7

sure but......

Dick Coers

....swimming with sting rays can be fun too, just ask Steve Irwin the day before that fateful day. What you are discussing is more like making a statistically based choice. You are trying to improve your odds for success with a cage and slow speed, but without xrays or other analysis of the wood, it still is up to chance. It's your choice......

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

#8

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

robo hippy

Just curious Steve, was standing out of the line of fire a topic?

robo hippy

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

#9

Steven Antonucci

It is a topic that gets reinforced every chance...

steven antonucci

we get to talk about it.

We actually discussed the line of fire in two ways. First, since we were focused on chainsaws and safety, we talked about how to stand to minimize kickback, and avoid contact with a spinning chain.

Since there was no lathe in this meeting, it was mentioned but not illustrated. One person (female) who appeared to be new to the group actually took the comments to heart and asked me "which pieces were safe?" for a beginner? I guided her towards pieces that did not have any obvious issues.

Steve

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

#10

Alan Zenreich

Re: Safety notes from NJW meeting last night

Alan Zenreich

I had to miss the meeting because of other commitments.

However, I just saw photos from the newsletter.

Though they may have been used but not photographed, I was dismayed that none of the people in the photos had on chaps, and although all had hearing protection, only one wore a face shield (though it looks like some had glasses). None had hard hat / face screens designed for chainsaw use.

Just shaking my head.

The safety gear is available, and relatively inexpensive. Can't say the same for impetus to use the gear.