Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Fluteless gouges

Posts

Fluteless gouges

#1

Fluteless gouges

robo hippy

This clip explains why this has become one of my favorite tools. The more I use it, the more I can find to do with it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=suRxCxdMn4k

robo hippy

Re: Fluteless gouges

#2

Re: Fluteless gouges

Bill Howatt

Very informative! Thanks for creating/posting.

Bill

Re: Fluteless gouges

#3

Re: Fluteless gouges

Paul Singer

Reed,

Thank You so much. I am out of town right now but will be trying it out as soon as I get home. I have had a 5/8 DT fluteless gouge for over a year and have not mastered it so I have left it alone. Now I have some info on using it I think it will come out of hiding.

Paul

Re: Fluteless gouges

#4

Re: Fluteless gouges

Peter Lamb

Excellent video thank you for you continuing contributions to the field

Re: Fluteless gouges

#5

Steven Antonucci

Fluteless gouges or bevel rubbing scraper?

steven antonucci

Call it whatever you want, but if you can rub the bevel on a scraper, why wouldn't you just rub the bevel on a gouge instead? It's the bevel support that makes the cut clean, and you are using it most of the time to push like you would with a gouge, except you don't have a flute to move the chips away, so they pile up instead?

I can see that it works, but I don't see any advantage to removing the flute?

Can you comment?

Steve

Re: Fluteless gouges

#6

Steve,

Jorge

It does not behave like a scraper it is just a skew with a different shape and the BIG ADVANTAGE of the flute-less gouge is a lot less vibration and so you can overhang a lot further out.

I saw Michael Hosaluck using one in 2005, I bought it from him, and have used it a lot. As I did like it, I did get several from Doug Thompson, so both my lathes are always endowed with at least one. They are great to shape the outside of bowl or vases, the perfect weapon to shape eggs.

Re: Fluteless gouges

#7

Re: Steve,

John Lucas

Seems like with a 70 degree angle it would cut nearly as cleanly as a bowl gouge with a 50 degree angle or my Stewart Batty grind that is 40. Still would be useful for bowl bottoms although my Hunter #5 has what is effectively an 82 degree bevel with a 30 degree cutting edge. Not saying it's a bad tool just saying I think there are other options.

Re: Fluteless gouges

#8

Re: Fluteless gouges

John Lucas

Reed it doesn't skate back as bad as a skew because the bevel angle is so blunt. When I spent time with all my different skews I found the less accute the angle the less it had a tendency to skate, however it didn't cut as cleanly either.

Re: Fluteless gouges

#9

Steven Antonucci

Bevel or not bevel, that is the question!

steven antonucci

I can see that it cuts, but I don't see how it is different than a gouge with a flute that has the same nose angle, except that there is no flute to eject the shaving? A piece of steel at 40 degrees is the same if I have a flute (or marginally different at the extremes of the wings...but close enough at the nose that it won't matter)

I guess what I am saying is that this is not very different than riding a bevel with a gouge? A square bar may register without rolling on the tool rest? If anything, I think the large bevel is kind of odd, since we're grinding the heel off of a bowl gouge to make it smaller.

I can see that it works and I probably could go it since I can ride a small bevel gouge on the inside of a bowl. I just don't think removing the flute adds anything?

S

Re: Fluteless gouges

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Very Informative.....

Jesper, Denmark

I just ordered one from Doug Thompson, so this was very good timing. My intention/anticipation was to sharpen it as I do bowl gouges with a 60° Nose angle. With the Oneway jig, this should make the bevel angle gradually steeper along the wings, ending in 90 ° at the ends.

re-thinking............

Comments?

Re: Fluteless gouges

#11

Re: Fluteless gouges

Philip Duffy

Looks like a round nose scraper to me- - just like all of mine that work so well as described in the video. If it looks like a duck - -- - -.!! Phil

Re: Fluteless gouges

#12

Alan Zenreich

Re: Fluteless gouges

Alan Zenreich

Reed,

Very well done... Best of your videos to date. Keep them coming!

Re: Fluteless gouges

#13

Re: Fluteless gouges

robo hippy

The advantage to this type of tool is, to me, the nose profile, which is more blunt rather than pointy or swept back. I tend to hold my tools more level, rather than dropped handle. Just more comfortable. The advantage of the blunt nose means that you can get a higher shear angle, especially on the inside of a bowl. On the outside, the lathe bed is not in the way so you can drop your gouge handles if you want, and especially with a swept back gouge, you can get a very high shear angle. On the inside, it is a different story. The bowl rim, tool rest, and lathe bed are in the way so you can't drop your handle as much. This is where this tool works best. The last quarter to 50 cent size bit in the center often comes off in one piece rather than a string of shavings because the high shear angle very gently slices and lifts off the wood. Rubbing the bevel does give the cleanest surfaces. Included into this formula also is the shear angle. 45 is good, 60 is better, and I am not talking about bevel angles here. Think of it as going over speed bumps in the parking lot. If you hit it square on, it is a fairly big bump, like when scraping. If you hit it more at an angle, the bump is much more gentle. The higher the angle, the more gentle the bump is.

Jesper, this tool can be ground to any profile. I use it mostly for a shear cut. I did the one for a detail tool and love it. I wish I could have had clips showing Allen Batty using it. So, it can be used either way. I don't use gouge jigs, just platform sharpen. I don't really know how it would work in a jig. Probably like a standard gouge.

I hadn't really thought about chip ejection. Not really an issue with me. On the inside of a bowl, some times they do pile up on the wall of the bowl.

A round nose scraper? No, not really, the difference is the bottom of the tool. I can do some of the same things, like shear scrape, but the more ) shape nose is better for shear cuts and being able to ride the bevel.

robo hippy

Re: Fluteless gouges

#14

Re: Fluteless gouges

Bill Jacksonville, NC

I really enjoyed the video, and now like to have a fluteless gouge. Thanks for posting Robo Hippy!

Re: Fluteless gouges

#15

Re: Fluteless gouges

Mavdad55

Robo, thanks for the video. I know a lot af you are gonna scoff at this, but I have a crown schewgouge and like it. It is a mix, much like what you are showing which looks like it does a shearing scraper and bowl gouge, one that I don't have to drop the handle to make a shearing cut with. By the way if you want to make long sweeping cuts on spindles then a traditional or continental gouge to improve stability. Eli Avisera uses a similar tool.

http://www.traditionalwoodworker.com/Eli-Avisera-Half-Round-Bar-Combination-Tool-3_4-by-Hamlet/productinfo/239%2D0413/

Re: Fluteless gouges

#16

Re: Fluteless gouges

don stephan

Not sure a fluteless gouge will be my next purchase, but I have to say your camera angles and audio were absolutely first rate. And the content was well organized and flowed well. Please make more!