Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

new turning idead to debate

Posts

new turning idead to debate

#1

new turning idead to debate

John Lucas

I hopefully will have time to experiment with these concepts more in the next couple of months. I got to spend some time with James Johnson in Texas and of course a week with John Jordan in Indiana. Both use course ground tools. By course I don't mean dull but John and James both sharpen with 60 grit wheels. James claims the sawtooth edge cuts green wood better. Can't argue with either of those guys if you look at their turnings and watch them turn. They see no advantage to sharpening with finer grits.

OK I'm turn mostly dry wood and tend to sharpen with finer grits. I've been turning ornaments this last week and I think I get a much cleaner finish when using a tool sharpened with 320 grit abrasive. In fact I turned an Osage Orange finial and the 600 grit paper actually dulled the finish. Now it is an oily wood and could have been slightly burnished by the bevel, but then the bevel was pretty highly polished. I will be turning more in the next few days and will try to turn a lesser hard and oily wood and I'll do it with gouges sharpened on a 100 grit wheel and with a 1000 grit belt and see if I can see the difference. I'll have to see if I have a courser wheel laying around to try that.

Maybe in the next month I'll have time to turn some green wood and try the same experiment. In the meantime It seems like what grit we use to sharpen with is a pretty minor thing. For the most part most of us end up with a pretty good product no matter how we sharpen. Reminds me of the old golf story. People only look at the score card, not how you got there.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#2

Re: new turning idead to debate

Sergio

If you want to cut down a green tree it is better a chain saw sharpened with a file. Turning green wood is generally not the final stage of turning. A honed edge will always cut cleaner than a coarse one.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#3

Re: new turning idead to debate

Ralph Lindberg

Similarly Mike Mahoney prefer's a "courser" or as he said a "serrated" edge.

He made that remark at an Olympia (WA) symposium a few years back, as Dave Schweitzer offered to let him sharpen his tools with one of Dave's (D-Way tools) CBN wheels.

Personally I prefer a cleaner edge.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: new turning idea to debate

Jesper, Denmark

John, here is another aspect, which might have an effect on your deliberations and tests:

I was going through sharpening all my tools on the present 80/100 grit wheels to have a base for trying out the CBN wheel on it's way to me from Austria. In sharpening the parting tool - pretty standard flat tool with maybe an included angle of close to 80° ground symmetrically - I noticed that it cut better on one side than the other. It turned out that the side that cut the best had the last ground facet down, so that it cut with a burr.

I sorta suspect that the burr on both this tool and gouges also have an effect - particularly when shearscraping with the wings of a gouge. I cannot remember this ever having been discussed.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#5

Re: new turning idea to debate

Sergio

The burr is "the cutting edge" of a scraper if the angle of presentation to the wood is wright. A honed tool cuts cleaner becouse the edge is "clean". This is important in chisel work and less in turning becouse of the speed of the lathe (see example of green wood and chain saw where the speed is important like the sharp edge of the chain which is rough sharpened with file).

Re: new turning idead to debate

#6

Steven Antonucci

Man, I hate this "debate"...

steven antonucci

Ever see a veneer mill with a serrated blade? There is a limit to how fine is practical, but finer is always better than coarser. In addition to the better surface, a finer edge is stronger than a coarse edge because the metal is supported equally in all directions.

If you have ever carved, you know that the serrations leave marks in the wood surface. A polished bevel leaves a cut surface that reflects light. I don't go nuts on roughing cuts, because I am cutting away the final surface, but finish cuts get finish sharpened.

Steve

Re: new turning idead to debate

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: new turning idea to debate

Jesper, Denmark

The cutting of the burr on a scraper makes sense - it lowers the angle of cut to a slicing effect. This might also be the case of the parting tool - it's presentation is often ( at least in my case) a bit haphasard, and may be closer in function to a scaper than a gouge.

I don't quite get the analogy of the chain saw or the gouge in rough cutting wet wood. If there is a burr, in both cases, I'd suspect it is quickly gone from the brutal treament the edge gets from rapid removal of a lot of material at high speed. Whether a sawtoothed edge from a coarse grinder is beneficial is beyond me for the moment. Is there an analogy to a coarse grinder removing material faster than a fine grinder? - or is there an anlogy to sawtoothed plane blades?

That a tool is sharpest when the two surfaces, which meet to form the edge are as flat as possible is logical - reference hand tool discussion of plane and chisel blades and their honing. That this also would leave the cleanest surface again is logical.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#8

Re: new turning idead to debate

robo hippy

Well, with the original cordless power saws (this means arm opperated) there were two basic types, a cross cut saw with fine teeth and little set, and a ripping saw, with coarser teeth and more set to the teeth. On my table saw, I have a combination blade, which is more like good at both cross cut and ripping operations. I would think maybe that the more serrated edge might rip through wet wood a little better, but for a better finish cut, you may want a more fine edge, as well has a high shear angle. I have never tried a 60 grit wheel though. I don't think they make them in CBN wheels, and I can't think of any reason to use a standard wheel any more.

robo hippy

Re: new turning idead to debate

#9

Re: new turning idea to debate

John Lucas

I suspect the burr is gone in seconds when shaping the wood. However when shear scraping John Jordan does raise a burr with his ceramic stone. IN shear scraping your using very light pressure so the burr lasts a little longer.

I have also experienced the burr cutting of a parting tool but it only lasts a little bit also.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#10

Re: Man, I hate this "debate"...

John Lucas

steve I don't know how sharp they actually get a veneer knife. I know it's sharp but what grit do they actually use for the final grit. Anyway it's a totally different process. They are trying to cut very thin layers. We are often cutting 1/4" or more when shaping a bowl.

Same is true for carving. You use a thinner sharper edge because it not only cuts clean but requires less force to cut which is important since your cutting with hand pressure. When shaping a bowl you typically take much thicker cuts.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#11

Re: new turning idead to debate

steve criscenzo

It is possible that the serrated edge may cut green wood faster but green wood cuts easily any way. A fine edge will give a better finish cut so unless I am going to have two sets of tools sharpened on different grits I am going with the fine grind.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#12

Re: new turning idead to debate

Bill Jacksonville, NC

John go ahead and satisfy your curiosity.

When selecting grinding wheel to sharpen your tools personal preference, how you sharpen, and how often have to touch up an edge only thing that matters. Sharp tools do not care if you are working with green or dry wood.

I often go straight to turning after using my medium 46-grit wheel. Touch up the edge either 80 or 100-grit depending what bought last. I never go from a medium to fine wheel.

Cannot find article by a man whose first name is Lynn unable to spell last name really go into V’s and W’s on tool bevels sharpening tools. Fred Holder might remember.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#13

the reason this intrigues me

John Lucas

Well first of all the 3 turners who have suggested this have great reputations and don't take anything lightly. Second is when I replaced the Hunter #4 cutter this last year I examined the edge. It still cut cleanly. Not as clean as the new one but incredibly clean especially if you look at the edge under magnification. It's serrated like knapped flint. (see photo)

So is it possible the gullets in the courser ground edge are actually sharp? Don't know but it's worth looking into if for no other reason than to satisfy my curiosity.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#14

Re: new turning idead to debate *LINK*

David Walser

John,

I have heard the serrated edge theory before and I used to subscribe to it. It made intuitive sense and lots of well-known turners claimed it was true. Then, I read an article in a back issue of Woodturning that changed my opinion. The article contained highly magnified images of tool edges fresh from the grinder. What to the naked eye appears to be a serrated edge is nothing of the sort. A burr is formed by the grinder that folds back over the tool's edge. While the burr is ragged, it bears no resemblance to the serrated knives I have in my kitchen. Those knives are sharp at each serrated point and everywhere in-between each point. So, while I understand the theory of a serrated edge cutting better, looking closely at the edge we can see that the edge left by a 60 grit wheel is NOT a serrated edge.

Of course, that doesn't mean a tool with a rough burr doesn't cut better than a tool with the burr removed. To test this question, the author compared the cutting ability of tools sharpened on a dry grinder and a Tormek. The Tormek sharpened tools removed more wood and stayed sharp longer than did the tools sharpened on the grinder. He did not offer any opinion as to which tool left a better surface. He was only measuring the volume of wood removed in a given time. (Alan Lacer, in the AAW journal, compared the surface left by tools sharpened using different methods. His overall conclusion was a honed tool leaves a better surface.)

I found two of the author's observations interesting: First, the dry ground tools started to cut better after about three minutes into each test cycle. The author believes that it took this long for the burr to wear away. Once the burr was worn away, the tool was sharper than it had been straight off the grinder and, therefore, cut better.

Second, the Tormek sharpened tool cut more efficiently 12 minutes after sharpening than did the dry ground tool 6 minutes after sharpening. At 12 minutes, the Tormek sharpened tool was not cutting as well as it had at first, but it was still performing about as well as the dry ground tool did at its best. Indeed, a “dull” Tormek sharpened tool was shaper than a tool straight from the grinder.

Note: I'm not trying to start a debate about Tormek. I think the author's results are transferrable to CBN wheels (or any other method that leaves a shaprer edge than an 80 grit wheel).

I've provided a link to an excerpt of the article from Tormek's website. (Scroll down to the bottom of the page.)


http://www.tormek.com/en/woodturning/index.php

Re: new turning idead to debate

#16

Lyn J Mangiameli

Ralph Lindberg

He wrote some great stuff, as I recall he took ill and was not able to continue in our, ah, obsession.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#17

Re: new turning idea to debate

Sergio

The burr is raised and utilized by cabinet scrapers which cut and do not scrape as evidenced by the fine shaving created and not dust. The dust appears only when it is time to recreate the burr. Furthermore, leevalley sells a tool to burnish a burr on turning scrapers that works exactely like the tool they sell for cabinet scraper. There is also a good description of the burr concept. Lee wrote a good book on sharpening ant the theory behind it.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=20266&cat=1,330,49233

The analogy with the chain saw is that the file used to sharpen it, lives a rough jagged edge on the cutting tooth that helps cutting at the high speed of the saw chain. Speed is an essential factor also in turning. When lathes where hand operated (very slow) tools were made of high carbon, that, lacking the various metals present in the new steels, allowed for a sharper edge. Wood chisels are stil manufactured in high carbon or simpler alloys than those used in turning tools simply because they allow a sharper edge and a cleaner cut. Speed often takes the place of a sharp tool and allows for a fast movement of the gouge. At lower speeds it is possible to get the exact same clean cut that is obtained at high speed but the turner must allow more passes of the wood on the cutter per unit of time and this is more difficult and proper of a better turner.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#18

Re: new turning idead to debate

Mavdad55

Well if this is about green wood, then a rough cutting edge makes more sense to me. Think about trying to trim a livr tree limb. If the saw teeth are fine it clogs and stops cutting. If coarse it works better at clearing the sappy wood.

Now a course ground chisel is not jagged in just one plane. Once the burr wears off you end up with a form of teeth in multiple planes, clearing wood at different angles.

Have you used a Japaneese style trimming saw... It works better than just a course saw. It too cuts on multiple planes with different angles.

Re: new turning idead to debate

#19

Re: new turning idead to debate

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Do not think many experienced turners really demand you sharpen your tools one way or the other. If you ask them will tell what and how they do something.

With so many abrasives compounds at our disposal besides friable aluminum oxide wheels like zirconia, ceramic & diamond today more discussion or debate definitely called for.

Thank you Ralph with you help was able to find Lyn’s article “Sharpening Turning Tools: Some Fundamental Principles.”

www.morewoodturningmagazine.com/articles/sharpen.pdf

Lyn explained why used a coarse wheel for changing bevel angle and his Tormek for touching up his tools. While have a lot more abrasive products than did in 2004; principles of sharpening your tools has not. Pretty sure like John, Lyn would love to review them all.