new turning idead to debate
John Lucas
I hopefully will have time to experiment with these concepts more in the next couple of months. I got to spend some time with James Johnson in Texas and of course a week with John Jordan in Indiana. Both use course ground tools. By course I don't mean dull but John and James both sharpen with 60 grit wheels. James claims the sawtooth edge cuts green wood better. Can't argue with either of those guys if you look at their turnings and watch them turn. They see no advantage to sharpening with finer grits.
OK I'm turn mostly dry wood and tend to sharpen with finer grits. I've been turning ornaments this last week and I think I get a much cleaner finish when using a tool sharpened with 320 grit abrasive. In fact I turned an Osage Orange finial and the 600 grit paper actually dulled the finish. Now it is an oily wood and could have been slightly burnished by the bevel, but then the bevel was pretty highly polished. I will be turning more in the next few days and will try to turn a lesser hard and oily wood and I'll do it with gouges sharpened on a 100 grit wheel and with a 1000 grit belt and see if I can see the difference. I'll have to see if I have a courser wheel laying around to try that.
Maybe in the next month I'll have time to turn some green wood and try the same experiment. In the meantime It seems like what grit we use to sharpen with is a pretty minor thing. For the most part most of us end up with a pretty good product no matter how we sharpen. Reminds me of the old golf story. People only look at the score card, not how you got there.




