Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Line of fire and shear scraping?

Posts

Line of fire and shear scraping?

#1

Line of fire and shear scraping?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

So I have been turning a lot more recently - and reading all the 'line of fire' and safety related posts. Very enlightening and thought provoking. Keep this first rate education coming!

Most of what I do keeps me out of the LOF without any difficulty, except shear scraping.

How do you accomplish shear scraping while staying of the LOF?

I'll see if I can describe what I had been doing. The swept back wing on a gouge is in an almost vertical position, the gouge is very closed (other wing almost touching surface), and the handle is pointed down and against my leg. That puts my torso and head/neck in the LOF!

Any hints? I don't have any specific mentors but basically learned this from Ellsworth's book (title escapes me).

Henry

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

#2

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

robo hippy

Henry,

I don't know if you saw my video clip about standing out of the line of fire or not. Here is a link:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F4qIM_-Jzgk

I would guess you are talking about shear cuts on the outside of the bowl. This would be a pull cut. You do have to extend your arms out a bit, and move with your body. I show that cut at around 15:20. I prefer scrapers. The actual technique will differ a bit depending on if you are turning on a long bed lathe or a short bed lathe.

robo hippy

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

#3

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Yes - correct assumption. I was asking about shear scraping on the outside of a bowl. I do not have a short bed lathe.

I re-viewed your video - at the time you suggested. I see your technique has the gouge overall at maybe a 45 degree angle (relative to horizontal), rather than a 80-85 degree angle. That allows you to at least keep your head, but not (all of) your torso out of the LOF.

Henry

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

#4

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

Dale Bonertz

Henry,

I have always contended that you cannot keep your body out of the line of fire 100% of the time. There simply are some cuts that you are going to put yourself into the LOF. There are also some projects that will put you into the line of fire. In Robos video it is a pretty shallow bowl and you will notice that parts of his body are in the LOF but he keeps his head out of the line. On deeper bowls this becomes more difficult. The key in my mind is to inspect the blank very good before putting yourself into that risky position. The types of cuts that put you into the LOF are used after the main turning has been done. You should be able to thoroughly inspect the piece prior to these cuts. If there is any doubt then don't make that cut. Another advantage to teaching yourself to turn left handed or maybe a better way of saying this is opposite handed. It is much easier to keep yourself out of the LOF even more often than being so one handed. If you can use both hands then you will easily keep your head out of the LOF but you will still put body parts into it on occasion. Risk management is a good term for these situations. If you manage the procedures by using sound practices prior to taking the risk all should end well.

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

#5

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Agreed Dale. Keeping my head out of the LOF is primary - and so is blank examination. A more careful examination throughout the process is something I am adding to my lathe practices.

I do turn left handed with some regularity. I find this shear scrape cut, at least as as I have been doing it (with gouge almost vertical) to be the most difficult to 'master' using my left hand (not that I have have 'mastered' anything in turning).

Thanks for the response.

Henry

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

#6

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping? *LINK*

John Lucas

Use a John Jordan shear scraper. It is designed as a pull cut tool and keeps you out of the line of fire.


http://www.johnjordanwoodturning.com/John_Jordan_Woodturning/Tools_and_More.html

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

#7

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Thanks John.

I hadn't thought about using another tool. Reed's video shows him doing this cut with a scraper as well, and that is an approach I had simply not considered before. 99% of what I do to turn a bowl is with a single bowl gouge.

Henry

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

#8

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

robo hippy

I do prefer a scraper for that cut. I use what is/was called an 'inside' scraper which is swept back to the left side. Burr is straight from the CBN wheels. Part of the reason is the mass of the tool, much more than a gouge. Another part is that you can see the edge cutting as you move, where with a gouge, it is rolled all the way over. I am not adept with a gouge for this cut, but can fake it.

You can never have every body part out of the line of fire. Hands and arms are always there, and the body a lot of the time. You just can't hold your arms out that far for any period of time.

I never totally trust any piece of wood until it is sanded, signed, finished, and off the lathe. The piece in the video clip had a color stain that is typical for madrone. There was no tell tale black line to indicate any existing fault. I have turned many that were identical to it with no problem. I just will not stick my head in that line any more. Kind of like defensive driving. It is the ones you don't see that can get you.

robo hippy

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

#9

Re: Line of fire and shear scraping?

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Have to agree with Dale, not sure we can always prevent being out of LOF while turning 100% of the time. Whether you have small, medium or large body, at some point in your turning process will be in line of fire.

To minimize this exposure, everyone needs to develop their own mental checklist procedure for whatever tool using and project turning.