Danger in the wood
steven antonucci
I held off on commenting on Adrien's diagram and the comments it generated, but I think it bears inspection and discussion. If you refer back to the thread:
You'll see that Adrien suggest that the platter split into four pieces, including one down the middle through the crotch feather figure. When I look at the crotch, I see no evidence that there is a split there? (no glue line?) If you've ever tried to split a crotch for firewood, you'll probably come to the same conclusion that I did: the piece didn't fail because it was a crotch.
Instead, what I see is a piece with two piths running through it. Why is this important? Well, for one, piths usually have cracks in them to begin with from the start. Secondly, there is a section of ever platter where the grain and the shape of the platter give a crack a "straight shot" across the width of the platter. I usually move my cut lines at least 1" outside the pith, and this puts the growth rings at an angle to the cross section of the platter instead of perpendicular. In effect, the grain is traversing 3/8" instead of 1/4", even though the platter is 1/4" thick.
Obviously, voids and rot give us less wood to support the cut, but they also induce vibration. If you've ever turned a cowboy hat, you know that the last thing you do is flex the outer rim up to make the profile. It's basically a platter on the other rim, and it flexes willingly the thinner you get. Once you cut the outside, you never move back out because it will be fluttering (and you will lose the brim of your hat). If Adrien had turned the back of this platter (and finish sanded it), and then started turning the front of it to final thickness, finish sanding it as he progressed to the middle, and kept the speed down and stood out of the Line of Fire, this piece of wood would have been "safe".
So my 2 minute Safety Brief would have looked like this:
Lathe 700 RPM max.
Cut a smaller platter to remove piths running through wings
Consider slowing the lathe down even further to see if vibration can be taken away as the piece gets thinner.
Sharp tools with no forward pressure to keep the piece from flexing
Stop and check often (flexing the piece by hand gently to see how little forward pressure would deflect the platter along the grain)
Steve



