Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

face shields *LINK*

Posts

face shields *LINK*

#1

Keith Tompkins

face shields *LINK*

Keith Tompkins

I have been reading the current posts concerning face shields and helmets with some interest, and would like to weigh in on the subject. First, I am stating unequivocally that in no way am I suggesting that one should not wear some form of face or head protection. Safety precautions are an absolute must, especially if one is turning large, out-of-balance , or flawed pieces of wood. However, it seems that many are trusting that currently available face shields or headgear will provide adequate protection in the event of an accident. In light of the current rash of accidents, it's obvious that this equipment will not prevent serious injuries, nor were they intended to do so. Most shields meet some ANSI standard, but these specs are woefully inadequate for preventing any serious injury. While many feel that Adrian's shield may have saved his life, consider the piece of wood that fractured his headgear probably weighed just a few ounces yet managed to penetrate his skull! (As an aside, I have a possible theory why his plate exploded: I'm assuming his plate was chucked in the usual manner, with the jaws tightened in the expanding mode. Left overnight, the wood naturally began to dry; the pressure from the chuck jaws prevented the wood from moving and shrinking, and a crack began to form at the weakest point. The next time the lathe was started....well, you know the rest.) I was a bit surprised by some of the emotional responses on previous posts, but the fact remains that many of us are assuming their equipment will adequately protect them...when it won't. Sadly, it's a false sense of security, like it or not. So what to do? Until a proper helmet/shield is designed and marketed, this is similar to what I'm wearing. (See link) While designed for playing hockey, the helmet is designed to prevent or lessen the chance of concussion. The shield/cage is manufactured to ASTMF513 specs, which requires the unit to withstand impacts from a hockey puck fired from an air cannon @ 80 mile per hour without fracturing or contact the wearer's head. Several units provide lower face/throat protection as well. One more thought...it's always wise to stand out of the line-of-fire, but a shattered bowl doesn't always behave as we would expect. Pieces can bounce off walls, the lathe bed or tool rest, or even the ceiling causing unexpected injuries.


http://hockeyfaceshields.com/

Re: face shields *LINK*

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: face shields

Jesper, Denmark

The Hockey helmet might not be a bad idea. I have thought of a motorcycle helmet as a possibility, but it's too damn heavy and not enough ventilation when stationary.

Re: face shields *LINK*

#3

Re: face shields

cranskin

It looks like you have to purchase a helmet also. Is that correct.

Re: face shields *LINK*

#4

Steven Antonucci

look at riot helmets... $100


Re: face shields *LINK*

#5

Okay, so now I'm wondering...

Tony Shaftel

...how one might add airflow to a hockey or riot helmet to get PAPR capability. Forgive me if this has already been discussed.

Re: face shields *LINK*

#6

Re: face shields

Philip Duffy

I have a welders mask, the ones with the heavy glass, that is total protection. With the heavy green glass up and out of the way, you have total protection from flying debris. Standard safety glasses underneeth for the eyes are still used. If you need the protection of that level it should be for a short period of time; until the workpiece is balanced and smooth. At that point a standard clear acrylic shield is nice to use. I found my welders mask at a pawn shop and the cost was very low- -$20. Philip

Re: face shields *LINK*

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: look at riot helmets... $100

Keith Tompkins

Hey Steve, I checked out some of the police supply sites; seems most of them will sell to only authorized police or corrections agencies. There are used pieces on ebay.... I like the hockey mask because of the steel or titanium cage many of them offer.

Re: face shields *LINK*

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: face shields

Keith Tompkins

Interesting....at the bottom of the link I provided is a link to a story by a Denver newspaper. The inventor of the shield I posted had his hockey career ended by a slap-shot that left him with steel plate in his head. The article also stated there were 85,000 head related injuries a year before the shields/cages were used.

Re: face shields *LINK*

#9

Steven Antonucci

some riot helmets with lexan and steel too


Re: face shields *LINK*

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: face shields

Keith Tompkins

Hi Cranskin, Yes, I would think so.....

Re: face shields *LINK*

#11

Re: face shields *LINK*

walta

Keith Tompkins post got me looking at the hockey helmets.

I found a helmet that comes with a similar shield.

This helmet is made of 2 parts so it can be adjusted to fit your head.

49.99 Plus shipping seems like a bargain so I bought one.

Walta


hockeymonkey.com

Re: face shields *LINK*

#12

Re: face shields

Gary clarke

Let us know if it fogs up during turning. Looks like it will work.

Re: face shields *LINK*

#13

Re: face shields

walta

I do not think fogging will be a problem for me as the old shields never fog on me. The new one has more vents in front and is made for hockey players who are skating hard.

It may get to hot as other hockey helmets got negative reviews for not being warm enough.

I have not sneezed in it yet but that is always a mess.

Also I think this item is on closeout.

Walta

Re: face shields *LINK*

#14

Re: face shields

Stuart Johnson

I use a 3M half face respirator. It will be interesting to hear if there is room for it or something similar.

Re: face shields *LINK*

#15

My 2 cents on face shields

David Frame

To all concerned,

I use a V-Guard hard hat.($10) Connected to it is an aluminum rim that goes around the front brim of the hat that is connected to a spring which holds it to the hard hat.($10) An acrylic shield(.58) is attached to the aluminum rim via plastic tabs and a good dust mask.(3M tekk protection #8511) All the items I mentioned can be bought at any safety supply shop.

For $20.58, you can't beat it. I have been using this face protection for 41 years with the exception of this new style of dust mask. Way back when, I used those cheap dust masks that had the thin piece of aluminum around the bridge of the nose.

I do understand those of us that need air force fed into a mask. I was just diagnosed with COPD and I'm looking for a forced air mask myself.

Re: face shields *LINK*

#16

Jim Evans

Re: My 2 cents on face shields

Jim Evans

I have a used CPAP machine that I'm going to adapt to some type of helmet/face protection. It may look weird, but some/any protection is better than none.

Re: face shields *LINK*

#17

Re: face shields

walta

Wearing them together is not a problem see photo.

Some people will not like this but I do not use a shield when sanding and I only wear the dust filters when sanding.

When the visor is up I do not like the way the chin pad hangs down and block my view.

After looking at the photos I may add some foam to lift the helmet and get my eyes center in the visor.


Re: face shields *LINK*

#18

Do they come in black ....

Geoff Whaling

"In a galaxy far far away...."

Seriously though, not much call for Ice Hockey safety equipment here in Australia.

If its designed for an impact from 6ozs (170g) travelling at 80-90mph (145kph) then its perhaps the closest readily available to withstand a similar impact level from a largish chunk of a wood turning comming of the lathe at speed.

There is an American Standard for Ice Hockey helmets - "ASTM F1045-07, Standard Performance Specification for Ice Hockey Helmets", is used to assess the performance of players’ helmets and is intended to reduce the risk of head injury without compromising the form and appeal of the game. It would be prudent to establish just what the standard specifies for impact protection and what the testing criteria are.

Not being familiar with the sport I googled a few results Wiki said "Even with the helmet and visor/face cage, concussions and facial injuries are common injuries in the sport."

Another study "Evaluation of impact attenuation of facial protectors in ice hockey helmets" stated in the abstract "In conclusion, this study demonstrates that facial protectors function beyond their role in solely preventing facial injuries, complementing the role of the helmet in attenuating head deceleration during impact. Consequently, the utilisation of facial protectors may reduce the severity and incidence of head injuries"

They are still not a fail safe, so traumatic brain injuries are still possible, but its a very good and probably the best option available!

The better option is to not create the flying objects in the first place.

Re: face shields *LINK*

#19

Re: My 2 cents on face shields

David Frame

Jim,

If you are going to use a CPAP machine, I would guess you have sleep apnea. I was diagnosed with it 7 yrs ago. I could not get used to wearing the gear, nor the sound of the machine. I now wear a mouth piece and it seems to work fine. But my hat is off to you, a CPAP with a full mask would be perfect for the shop.

By the way, I developed COPD as the direct result from smoking cigarettes. I finally put them down 4 yrs ago last April when my doc told me I had it. Now I have to use a quick inhaler and a 24 to 36 hour pill that I have to inhale through a different apparatus. Everyone told me that I would get it, but I didn't listen. Now I have to pay the price by not breathing well and being tired all of the time. I now use face and lung protection all of the time, even for the smallest amount of time in my shop.

David

Re: face shields *LINK*

#20

Re: Do they come in black ....

Bill Howatt

There is a lot of call for ice-hockey equipment here in Canada!

While helmets have reduced the head injuries, there was an item on the news a short while ago stating the helmets need to be improved and certainly aren't a bullet-proof answer to head injuries which are still occurring at what is seen as too high a rate. Probably not surprising since nothing is going to stop all injuries.

Given that a hockey helmet is intended to protect against flying missles and general whacks to the head from all angles I would say that it is a good place to start for protection and even though it shouldn't necessarily be a criteria, but it is, the price is inexpensive.

Even if your face isn't cut or your bones broken, any blow that causes your brain to rattle around inside the skull can be very serious so the best protection is what we all know, do whatever is necessary to avoid being hit in the first place. Unfortunately, things happen in spite of our best intentions so having head protection of some type is far better than none.

Bill

Re: face shields *LINK*

#21

Dan Jechura

Re: face shields

Dan Jechura

what size did you buy? and how did you decide what size you needed? Hat size?

Dan

Re: face shields *LINK*

#22

Re: face shields

walta

My head measures 22.75 the spec sheet for this helmet says 22.5 – 24 for the large.

One of the things I liked about this helmet is that you can adjust it to fit and is made in 3 sizes most others have 5 sizes. For me I opened it to its largest setting and it is almost too small for me.

You could buy locally and try them on.

The black was sold out in large on this web site. This brand is heavily discounted and may be on closeout.

Walta