Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

CA is not my friend

Posts

CA is not my friend

#1

CA is not my friend

Mike Foster

Some here might remember me dissing CA before. My original reason for this is that I learned more about the chemistry of CA. A Smithsonian conservator discussed CA with Steve Sinner and mentioned that it was a glue that is not at all archival. The CA is accelerated by exposure to water, which is why you can actually spritz CA with water as an accelerator. Not sure what is in the commercial accelerators, but I would bet they are largely water, although they do have a chemical smell. Problem is that the cured CA keeps reacting with exposure to water over time (although much slower) and will eventually turn into dust. So the Smithsonian folks strongly discourage the use of CA in any work that wants to last any length of time. I am sure the rate is affected by all sorts of things, including top coats of other finish.... but the fact remains, eventually dust.

All that has nothing to do with this post though. I bought a bottle of CA from an unnamed distributor that claims purity and excellence. They tend to promote buying in larger quantities. Well I bit on it a couple years ago and bought a 12 oz (or so) bulk bottle. I store this on the shelf with all my other glues ( although it was living in my freezer for a while). I went to get some epoxy a few days ago and found that the whole dang shelf was flooded with CA about 1/4" deep. It was about 1/2 cured. To top this off, I had been using the CA recently and found that it wouldn't cure completely for over 1/2 hr. I chalked that up to perhaps being out of date. Well, I did not inspect the bottle the CA came in as it was obvious it leaked because it was standing upright on the shelf. Spent about 45 minutes this evening cleaning up the mess. Some cured that needed to be chiseled off, some only partially cured that needed to be scraped off and cleaned with acetone. Should have put on a respirator, but just couldn't be bothered and tried to keep from breathing the fumes as much as possible.

So you can be sure I will never buy CA from the unnamed supplier again and never in bulk. I actually still use CA some, but really only very rarely. I always try to come up with a better alternative. Let me just say that I really don't understand the folks that use CA as a finish. In my opinion, there are much better alternatives. OK, now I feel better.

Re: CA is not my friend

#2

Mike,

GaryG in MD

Sorry to hear about your CA mess.

I never buy large quantities of things that can dry/harden/gel -- that's what stores are for. As you have learned, bulk discounts often do not lead to long-term cost savings. Speaking of which, I need to buy some thin CA -- just ran out today. I buy it in 2-oz bottles and store any unopened spares in the frig. That's what the butter keeper is for, right?

I beg to differ on your "finish" comment.

I wouldn't use it on anything bigger than a pen, but I have found CA to be the best pen finish BY FAR!

It is very quick and easy to apply, virtually foolproof if you use the correct, simple techniques, and provides a non-yellowing and durable result. From raw wood to a perfect, ready-to-use shine in 5 minutes flat. Can't beat it.

...GG

Re: CA is not my friend

#3

Re: Mike,

John Kaner

uplimg] First time I saw CA was at Plattsburgh AFB in 1976. They were using open pint bottles and applying it to the repair the honeycomb sections inside of the wing. I got a bottle and took it back to the Fire Station. Had lot's of fun seeing what could be glued together... Glued some quarters to the stall floors, funny watching people try to pick them up...

I always wondered if my Corian pens would fall apart due to CA failure... Here's some I did using CA...

Re: CA is not my friend

#4

Ric Taylor

My Experience is Different

Ric Taylor

Mike,

I've been using CA since 1974 for various applications and hobbies. I still have some of those items from 1974, and all I can say is the tightly glued joints and the loosely glued joints (where CA was used as filler in a gap) are just the same today as they were way back then. Climate is not as issue, as I have moved several times to widely varying climates, bringing those items with me. I store my unopened bottles in the fridge.

I've heard several people in recent months make comments saying CA is not permanent. I have seen those comments online, and I've also heard them in my club meetings. That has not been my experience, and I have never had any problem. I don't know what the magic touch is, I just know that it works for me and I have never had a failure, with my items still going strong after nearly 40 years.

I do agree with other comments that smaller bottles are more economical in the long run.

Ric

Re: CA is not my friend

#5

Dick Hines

Re: My Experience is Different

Dick Hines

A friend of mine used to build BIG RC planes. He built the frames of the planes using CA glue. He had one that was so big he had to remove the wings to get into his pickup. As far as I know the only problem he had with the CA was when he crashed landed. Then all bets were off.

Re: CA is not my friend

#6

Re: My Experience is Different

Bernie Rose

I have on my bench a small empty CA bottle that sits along side a small screwdriver and a box cutter that are on permanent display and rigidly attached to the bench top. I used to worry about the stuff I keep in the freezer until I double bagged them with plastic grocery bags.

Re: CA is not my friend

#7

Re: CA is not my friend

Steve Russell

Hello Mike,

The specific base used in cyanoacrylates varies by product and manufacturer, but may include Isopropanol, Heptane, Acetone, Electronic Grade Acetone, Perfluorocarbon, or Propylene based Glycol Ether. The active ingredient in kickers/accelerators is usually an amine. Hope this helps.

Steve Russell

President and CEO

LSWA, Inc.

Maui No Ka Oi Bruddah...

Re: CA is not my friend

#8

Re: CA is not my friend

Jim Breeden

Steve - Big Island also ! ;)