Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

do you?

Posts

do you?

#1

do you?

GaryG in MD

When we turn green wood directly to final thickness, we hope it won't crack and accept the fact that it will warp. There's natural beauty in the final form.

BUT

I'm about to finish that oak side-grain NE, and I have found that my nice, carefully turned SHAPE is no longer "nice". The heartwood shrank more than the sapwood (which surprised me a bit), so now my fair curve ain't so fair.

The question is: do I go at it with sandpaper and try to even out at least some of the lumpiness that's destroying the nice line, or do I just say "Mother Nature" and slap on the oil?

This, of course, is a totally subjective question.

What I want to know is "what do YOU do?"

...GG

Re: do you?

#2

Steven Antonucci

Try rewetting it?

steven antonucci

may just dry a different, more pleasing way second time?

S

Re: do you?

#3

Re: Try rewetting it?

GaryG in MD

Well, that's a "revolutionary" thought.

I have to admit I never thought of that one.

Has anybody out there tried that? ...GG

Re: do you?

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: Try rewetting it?

Brad Vietje

I've done this , but only a very few times -- maybe only twice, and not in the past 8-10 years. I no longer try to re-round things after they warp, but I did it to allow sanding something that was getting too oval, and I don't thing the final shape was affected at all.

When I make a thin, green-turned object, I tend to let Mama Nature have her way, and learn from watching the process. I've certainly gotten better at predicting the movement, but a chunk of reaction wood from a horizontal branch can still give us surprises -- or fits.

As an aside -- green turning is yet another case where balancing the figure in the piece matters enormously. If the pith is closer to one edge than the other, or if the sapwood and/or growth rings are not balanced, you're more likely to get unpleasing shapes as they dry.

BTW: I oil the wood before it dries -- a trick I learned years ago from Luke Mann. Adding the oil, or oil-based finish when the wood is still "wet" or green, slows the drying akin to what Anchorseal does for bowl blanks, and lessens the checking that can still occur if a piece dries too fast.

All of this seems counter-intuitive, I know, since we often use "oil & water" as two substances that don't mix, but it works very well. Oil will certainly penetrate further into a dry piece of wood, but if the depth of the penetration is not so important, oiling the piece when wet starts the penetration of the finish, and more finish is added as the wood dries, or in my case, after the wood has dried and stabilized, so the penetration is not that different -- just slower. This method is especially good for green-turned & wet sanded burl wood, allowing the wood to wrinkle and take on a very pleasing texture that doesn't get sanded off after it's dried.

The only down side I have noticed is thinking a bowl is done moving when it still has a ways to go. I remember a thin Red Oak ogee-curve bowl from about 8-10 years ago that I thought had stopped moving, and I was very proud of its graceful lines.... but Oak species tend to dry pretty slowly, and when this one was taken out of a box some 4 months later to put on display at a craft show, it had warped quite a bit more, and while symmetrical and still pleasing, not really what I expected, and not as nice as the photos I posted here and at WoW's ....

That's the experience that teaches us how this stuff all works.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: do you?

#5

Brad Vietje

Found it... from 10 years ago.

Brad Vietje

This is the bowl before the warping was finished. Don't know if I ever sold it, or if I still have it somewhere. Figure is balanced, but I finish turned it too soon. this is from my liquid dish detergent experimental days...

Ended up losing a lot of the classic lines :\

Re: do you?

#6

Re: Try rewetting it? Yep!

mjonesrdg

Several years ago I posted here the results of a big-time save of a cherry vase form that I had re-hydrated by soaking in a bucket of water. I have done a few since then and believe that re-hydrating is a useful concept and practice. Results are no more predictable than is the dehydrating (drying) processes that we all employ, and you can best appreciate the value by doing some dunking along the way. I've always said, "try re-hydrating just before you send it to the burn pile", because you've got nothing to lose. Wood shrinks when it loses it's water, and expands when it gains it back.

Re: do you?

#7

thanks for all you thoughts, Brad...

GaryG in MD

I thought about oiling it to slow drying time but didn't.

Thanks for the "go ahead" on that technique.

Next time I will.

I triple brown bagged it, and that seems to have done a successful job.

I don't mind general lumpiness -- that's "wood", but it really messed up the nice profile I had. The balance/orientation on this one is perfect, but now the heartwood shrank in and left the sapwood proud. I HATE sanding, but I guess I'm going to have to get at this one to just make the slope change less obvious.

Just thinking out loud here, I guess the downside of using oil as a drying retardant is that if you have to sand to get the shape back, it's easier to sand raw wood than oiled wood that clogs the paper.

Nice oak ogee!

...GG

==============

Re: do you?

#8

Re: Try rewetting it? Yep!

GaryG in MD

Thanks for the info.

I can't chance it with this historic wood, but I'll keep it in mind for the future. ...GG

Re: do you?

#9

Re: Try rewetting it? Yep!

John Jordan

Oil won't affect the drying one way or another-it can't replace the lost water, and it takes a lot of coats to build any kind of film thickness-longer than it takes the wood to dry.

John

Re: do you?

#10

Hi John,

GaryG in MD

Interesting thought.

How about this...

Wax (in the form of an emulsion like Anchorseal) is water permeable but we use it to slow transpiration.

Seems to me like a coat or two of oil would be similar.

Thoughts?

If I don't want to put wax on a piece (because I won't be turning it all away), I often use shellac to slow drying since, as Russ used to say, "Everything goes over shellac." The problem there is potential unwanted yellowing. ...GG

Re: do you?

#11

Re: Hi John,

John Jordan

No, oil finishes do not affect the migration of moisture. Fine Woodworking published a well researched article on this some years ago. All the finishes they tested not impede the transfer of moisture in either direction.

I'm not sure about shellac on wet wood, but cheap nitrocellulose lacquer/sanding sealer/Deft brushed on heavily will slow the drying and it can be easily removed. Putting the piece loosely in a paper bag would serve the some purpose, but slowing the drying probably won't help much.

I don't think you posted a picture of the problem you had-that might help.

John

Re: do you?

#12

this thread...

GaryG in MD

has been wandering in circles on several interconnected topics...

It's just a standard, side-grain, wave-edged NE bowl.

I triple paper bagged it, and it dried without cracking.

My original question was related to the fact that the heartwood shrank more than the sapwood and put a small but obvious (to the trained eye) dip in the profile.

I sanded at 320 to get rid of the fuzzies and put just a small bit of effort into reducing the dip -- not that you can do much at 320 (and I wasn't going back any farther!).

It is what it is...

Since this is a kind of "rustic" form to start with, I guess it's ok that the profile not be mathematically perfect. Most people wouldn't notice it anyway. ...GG