...but you already knew this..(faceshields)
mjonesrdg
I was very impressed by Adrien’s post with pictures of a damaged Trend Pro Air shield and description of injuries that he sustained while wearing it. I found the discussion that followed on this forum piquing my interest and I went on a bit of a research mission to learn more about the face shields and headgear that is marketed to the wood turning community. I had hoped that I could come back here with a slew of very definitive and informative conclusions to share with you.
I found instead, differing interpretations of the ANSI testing standards for both “low impact” and “high impact” designations. (steel ball vs. pointed rod, ..15 inch dia. vs. ¼” dia. steel ball, and at differing velocities.) A PDF download direct from ANSI would come at a $57.00 premium, so the various interpretations may be the result of manufacturer’s descriptions that more closely match their individual testing regimens,
At Betty Scarpino’s suggestion, I re-read Andrew Chen’s article that appeared in the April 2013 ‘Journal’. This author does not make choosing “correct” face shields much easier. He introduces into the mix of style choices, polycarbonate and non-polycarbonate, he speaks to varying thicknesses, and, Andrew states that although he personally wears a (non compliant) PAPR, he urges cautions for it’s use. Appropriately, he reminds us that the face shield is a last line of defense, and all other precautions should be taken.
Going online shopping , I looked for the ANSI certifications first, then country of origin, (would the Chinese, I wondered, conform to the ANSI standards?) followed by style, convenience, and price. I found in Packard’s catalog, a notation on one face shield, “Made in USA”, but most of the entries from other catalog’s did not stipulate. The Trend Airshield, made in the UK, did not have the ANSI “bug” but the Trend Pro Airshield did. Craft Supplies USA offers a bubble visor made of ‘Lexan’ (might be a polycarbonate, might be superior….might not) and the catalog still shows the (incorrect) ANSI z87.1 designation. Woodcraft’s “Bionic” carries both the (incorrect) ANSI and the Canadian CSA z94.3 bug. Grainger Industrial Supply offers more face shield/headgear options than I could assimilate in an afternoon, but also they introduce new terms and materials to consider: Propionate, Noryl, and various fiber/metal configurations, and all carry a boiler plate ANSI z87.1 designation. I also checked Bailey’s, Garrett Wade, Gemplers, and did a few keyword searches for riot/tactical gear.....both in new and surplus suppliers pages.
I kept my thoughts regarding the American Association of Woodturners in mind throughout this little mission of mine….thinking mostly about how helpful the organization could be to the woodturning community in accomplishing more of this legwork for it’s members…..but I also considered that such organizations might just want to walk softly around this issue. My (current) personal conclusion being that I might just be better off without face protection….. that some of my work at the lathe is scary enough to keep my head and face well away from the direction of the chips and curls.
Maybe the AAW has come to the same conclusion. They have advertisers to consider as well.
My little mission has taken me on a rather circular path….where I finish without the definitive information that I wanted to provide…..and only a little greater frustration with the likes of the AAW. They could, after all, request copies of testing and quality control reports from a few of the major suppliers to the trade. They could provide the actual ANSI Standards from the “horse’s mouth” and they might ask members-at-large to do a “real” in depth examination of the Personal Protection Equipment that is readily available to the public. Further, any such substantive information and conclusions could be disseminated to the general public. Such real value assistance to wood turners might even result in an increase in memberships.
My efforts, I’m afraid, fall woefully short.
My thanks again, to Adrien….for getting some of us to thinking…..for allowing me to share your post and pictures over on the WoodBarter and Woodturner’s Resource forums.



