Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

Posts

...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#1

...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

mjonesrdg

I was very impressed by Adrien’s post with pictures of a damaged Trend Pro Air shield and description of injuries that he sustained while wearing it. I found the discussion that followed on this forum piquing my interest and I went on a bit of a research mission to learn more about the face shields and headgear that is marketed to the wood turning community. I had hoped that I could come back here with a slew of very definitive and informative conclusions to share with you.

I found instead, differing interpretations of the ANSI testing standards for both “low impact” and “high impact” designations. (steel ball vs. pointed rod, ..15 inch dia. vs. ¼” dia. steel ball, and at differing velocities.) A PDF download direct from ANSI would come at a $57.00 premium, so the various interpretations may be the result of manufacturer’s descriptions that more closely match their individual testing regimens,

At Betty Scarpino’s suggestion, I re-read Andrew Chen’s article that appeared in the April 2013 ‘Journal’. This author does not make choosing “correct” face shields much easier. He introduces into the mix of style choices, polycarbonate and non-polycarbonate, he speaks to varying thicknesses, and, Andrew states that although he personally wears a (non compliant) PAPR, he urges cautions for it’s use. Appropriately, he reminds us that the face shield is a last line of defense, and all other precautions should be taken.

Going online shopping , I looked for the ANSI certifications first, then country of origin, (would the Chinese, I wondered, conform to the ANSI standards?) followed by style, convenience, and price. I found in Packard’s catalog, a notation on one face shield, “Made in USA”, but most of the entries from other catalog’s did not stipulate. The Trend Airshield, made in the UK, did not have the ANSI “bug” but the Trend Pro Airshield did. Craft Supplies USA offers a bubble visor made of ‘Lexan’ (might be a polycarbonate, might be superior….might not) and the catalog still shows the (incorrect) ANSI z87.1 designation. Woodcraft’s “Bionic” carries both the (incorrect) ANSI and the Canadian CSA z94.3 bug. Grainger Industrial Supply offers more face shield/headgear options than I could assimilate in an afternoon, but also they introduce new terms and materials to consider: Propionate, Noryl, and various fiber/metal configurations, and all carry a boiler plate ANSI z87.1 designation. I also checked Bailey’s, Garrett Wade, Gemplers, and did a few keyword searches for riot/tactical gear.....both in new and surplus suppliers pages.

I kept my thoughts regarding the American Association of Woodturners in mind throughout this little mission of mine….thinking mostly about how helpful the organization could be to the woodturning community in accomplishing more of this legwork for it’s members…..but I also considered that such organizations might just want to walk softly around this issue. My (current) personal conclusion being that I might just be better off without face protection….. that some of my work at the lathe is scary enough to keep my head and face well away from the direction of the chips and curls.

Maybe the AAW has come to the same conclusion. They have advertisers to consider as well.

My little mission has taken me on a rather circular path….where I finish without the definitive information that I wanted to provide…..and only a little greater frustration with the likes of the AAW. They could, after all, request copies of testing and quality control reports from a few of the major suppliers to the trade. They could provide the actual ANSI Standards from the “horse’s mouth” and they might ask members-at-large to do a “real” in depth examination of the Personal Protection Equipment that is readily available to the public. Further, any such substantive information and conclusions could be disseminated to the general public. Such real value assistance to wood turners might even result in an increase in memberships.

My efforts, I’m afraid, fall woefully short.

My thanks again, to Adrien….for getting some of us to thinking…..for allowing me to share your post and pictures over on the WoodBarter and Woodturner’s Resource forums.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#2

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

jerry bennett

Everyone misses the point.

NONE of the "face shields" available anywhere in the world are designed to withstand an five pound object flying at two hundred miles per hour. Face shields are glorified eye protection only. That is all they are designed for. Even a catchers mask is not ideal in that situation. Every article I have ever read in various magazines makes this point, manufacturers make the point. There are no face shields available that will protect you from a bowl explosion. none.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#3

Steven Antonucci

Give that man a cigar (both of you guys)

steven antonucci

So there in lies the rub?

Are you wearing a face shield thinking it is 4x as protective as just goggle? Or 8X as protective as nothing at all? If you are, you are at risk.

Aside from being good at stopping "nuisance" particles (stuff that might be uncomfortable- like a stringy shaving) from being pushed into your face, or into your open mouth- a face shield bring little added value to a well trained turner.

Am I advocating that new turners do not wear them? Absolutely not. Any face shield is better than any pair of goggles on a new turner. Will it stop a 5 pound bowl? No it will not. Can it potentially prevent an injury? Absolutely.

A long time ago when I was still learning, I had a platter break in two pieces. One went up and punched a hole in the ceiling above my lathe. The other one hit me square in the inexpensive face shield I was wearing. In effect, it was the hardest shot I have ever taken, but the face shield distributed it over a greater surface area, which prevented me from getting hurt. It was the last line of defense.

The "accident" would have been a complete non-starter if I hadn't been in the LOF. I am glad the shield did its job, but it should have never been put to the test. Like Jerry pointed out, there is a limit to what any shield can stop, and I'd guess that it's way less than 5 pounds, since my platter may have been 1/2 pound at best...and I wouldn't want to get hit any harder than it hit me.

As far as Mike's point goes, there are standards and there are applications. Regardless of the standard we pick, you'll always have to wonder if that little sticker means anything for the thing that you have turning. It would probably be interesting to see what kind of weight and height they drop on the mask to test it, and then translate that to a meaningful example of a rotating mass on the lathe. In simple terms, when things spin, they exert more force. There's a lot more energy there than you think.

Steve

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#4

Betty Scarpino

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

Betty Scarpino

1) American Woodturner is a journal, not a magazine (there is a difference, which I try to uphold). Magazines exist primarily as vehicles for advertisements, so their content is geared toward satisfying the needs of vendors, as in doing product "reviews." AAW's journal does not cater to advertisers. Membership dues are enough to pay for journal production.

2) Who are "they" when you speak of "the AAW"? "They" are US ... you, included. Andy Chen stepped forward to write an article. You did some research, why not write an article or a letter to the editor? In spite of what many Forum participants think, only a small percentage of AAW members look at the Forums, and at that, not regularly (your voice is only marginally heard). The AAW is not sidstepping this issue, but as I wrote earlier, the many volunteers ("they") would welcome constructive help in establishing policy.

3) When Andy Chen's article on faceshields was published, a representative from Trend called me to complain about Andy's unfair treatment of his product. The rep's follow-up letter was poorly argued and not based on facts, so my reply had many questions for the rep to answer. I've heard no response. I have, however, heard that sales of Trend have increased.

4) Jerry is correct. And, I want to emphasize that wearing a splash-guard faceshield (the kind with the metal strip around the clear shield) is worse than not wearing a faceshield for eye protection. That metal strip can detach upon impact and impale itself into a person's face or eye.

5) What the AAW does need to do is come up with a sound, reasonable, enforceable safety policy for its symposium. As for local AAW chapters (independent entities) and their activities, that's a whole 'nuther large problem to consider.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

Lyle Jamieson

Is not using a face shield the answer?? It may not help me MUCH if a 5 pound piece hits me square in the face at 200 miles an hour...but what about the glancing blow...what about the smaller particle slicing into your face and ripping a chunk out...what about a piece hitting you in the mouth and knocking out a bunch of teeth...and on and on and on. At your next meeting take a show of hands of turners in the last year that have had a piece come off the lathe and were just plain lucky they didn't get hurt. I will be using a face shield and my students will be using them or not be in my class.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#6

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

Geoff Whaling

Betty I have already done considerable research on this topic & you are welcome to the article.

It expands upon what the Z87+ actually means.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#7

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

Dale Gillaspy

Tagging on to Jerry's point, and with all due respect to Betty, a face shield is not, and was never intended to be, eye protection. A face shield is just that, face protection. Putting aside impact ratings for a second, a face shield allows debris and dust to get around the sides and into your eyes, which can be irritating and distracting while holding a tool, not to mention dangerous to the eyes.

If you are wearing a shield like the Bionic or Trend, an argument could be made that they were designed to protect the eyes as well as the face. You cannot make that argument with a standard flip down face shield.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#8

Betty Scarpino

eye protection

Betty Scarpino

Dale, maybe I didn't write as clearly as I intended ... my point was to say that IF a person is wearing a faceshield for eye protection, selecting the splash-guard type with the metal band is worse than not wearing one at all because of the metal band.

Even so, a Z87+ does offer some eye protection, but you rightly stated that a Trend works even better for eye protection from dust and small debris. My contact lenses tell me that!

I wear a faceshield and often wear my Trend. I also make students wear a faceshield, as you do, Lyle. Jerry was not advocating not wearing a faceshield.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#9

I agree with Jerry and Betty......

Greg Haugen

It effects everyone when someone gets hurts. It's terrible. Over the last few years some of the worst accidents had common factors, speed and wood coming apart-and actually platters in general. The surface speed, not necessary the RPM, is incredibly increased with platters. Also a crack, often not seen, becomes separate pieces because a platter has little to no room to stay together, compared to a bowl or a vessel with more fiber surface. A simple crack can open and split on a platter from centrifugal forces.

Thinking that someone is safe at turning at high speeds, off centered pieces, or crappy wood just because they're wearing a faceshield is like driving 150 mph and thinking you'll be just fine because you're wearing a seat belt or jumping off of a bridge and thinking you'll be ok because you have a snorkel. There are precautions to take BEFORE any safety equipment is valid. When, and if, we get to the point of better face shields, then neck injuries or chest injuries will become the issues because of the sheer forces involved.

I do wear a shield. More for the piece of bark that will fly off or for shavings. It is not my only "safety net". My speeds, my wood choices, my tool sharpening, and my chucking/work holding practices are what I count on to stay safe.

Safety "precautions" are the best personal safety equipment, and the shield is just one part of them.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#10

Betty Scarpino

evolving attitudes

Betty Scarpino

Geoff, as Mike Jones's post illustrated, all those facts and numbers are confusing and interpretations of what they mean vary. Also, standards change as do designs and products.

I think a discussion like this is helpful because the woodturning community is still evolving and maturing. We are in the process of a significant attitude change from a previous era where it was cool and macho not to wear a faceshield or any protective gear. Manufacturers are beginning to understand the needs of this growing number of woodturners. Individuals are considering (and reconsidering) their attitudes toward PPE.

Speaking as editor of American Woodturner, I want its contents to help lead the way toward fun, informed, and safe woodturning. Content loaded with bewildering facts and figures won't accomplish that. What I liked about Andy's article was that he left it up to the individual to decide what faceshield to use. Andy wears a Trend because of the other protection it affords, even knowing that Z87+ is rated higher for impact.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Alittle discussed aspect.....

Jesper, Denmark

In talking safe speed, it seems only RPM and centrifugal force are considered. There is another aspect to this:

Centrifugal force increases with the square of the increase in speed. So, double the speed and the centrifugal force is quadrupled. Centrifugal force works radially.

On the other hand, the hoopstresses increases with the cube of the increase in diameter. So as the diameter increases by a factor of two, the hoopstress is 8 times as high. Hoopstresses work circumferentially - but are the result of centrifugal force.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#12

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

jerry bennett

Lyle, I do not advocate not using a face shield. I do use mine for the very reason you do. The point is people seem surprised when a piece of wood parts their hair and they immediately go looking for the specs on the face shield.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#13

I gave it all up . . .

Doc Green

I used to fly an ultralight. Gave it up. Too dangerous.

I used to fly a Cessna. Gave it up. Too dangerous.

I used to ride a motorcycle. Gave it up. Too dangerous.

I used to turn wood. Gave it up. Too dangerous.

However, I'm still active. My current project is installing a seat belt and an air bag on my rocking chair, and a guard rail on the couch.

~Doc (tongue in cheek, of course)

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#14

Re: Alittle discussed aspect.....

sergiov

There must be a little of cofusion here that must be clarified otherwise the discussion make little sense.

ANSI Z87-1 was proposed for EYE PROTECTION

ANSI Z89-1 is proposed for HEAD PROTECTION

here is a description for Z 87

"The current edition of the standard is Z87.1-2003. Lenses in all protectors must at a minimum meet a basic impact requirement: the 1 inch drop ball test. Models can achieve “high” impact levels indicating elevated performance. The following “high” impact tests apply to lenses, as well as to the frames or product housing:

• A lens retention test is conducted via a “high mass” impact. A pointed 500 gm (1.1 lb) projectile is dropped 50 inches onto the complete protector mounted on a headform. No pieces can break free from the inside of the protector, the lens cannot fracture, and the lens must remain in the frame or product housing. This test is a good measure of the product’s strength, simulating a blow such as from a tool that slips from the work surface or when the lens collides with stationary objects.

• A high velocity test is conducted, at 20 specified impact points, where the projectile is a ¼ inch steel ball traveling at specific speeds depending upon the type of protector. For spectacles, the velocity is 150 ft/sec or 102 mph. The pass/fail criteria are the same as for the high mass test, plus no contact with the eye of the headform is permitted through deflection of the lens. This is meant to simulate particles that would be encountered in grinding, chipping, machining or other such operations. In the United States, compliance with the standard is self-certified, based on test results generated by the manufacturer as part of its initial design and ongoing Quality Control procedures. No independent certification is required. Products meeting the basic impact standard shall be marked “Z87” on all major components. Those products which pass the “high” impact tests listed above can carry a “Z87+” marking on the lens(es)...

Here i the description for Z89

"...ANSI/ISEA Z89.1-2009 was prepared by the members of ISEA's Head Protection Group as a revision to ANSI Z89.1-2003, and approved by a consensus review panel of users, government agencies and safety experts.

Industrial head protective helmets meeting the requirements of this standard are classified as Type I for top protection, or Type II for lateral impact protection. Both types are tested for impact attenuation and penetration resistance. Type II helmet performance requirements include criteria for impact energy attenuation from impacts from the front, back and sides as well as the top; off-center penetration resistance, and chin strap retention...."

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#15

Lyle Jamieson

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

Lyle Jamieson

The thread started with mjonesrdg stating " My (current) personal conclusion being that I might just be better off without face protection…" I don't think that is a smart message to send from his extensive research.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#16

Re: eye protection

Steve Kniffen

In 29 CFR 1910, Subpart I, App B, Personal Protective Equipment. OSHA provides guidance in selection of PPE https://www.osha.gov/pls/oshaweb/owadisp.show_document?p_table=STANDARDS&p_id=10120 . If you scroll down to the table titled Eye and Face Protection Selection Chart, you'll see item #1 is Impact. It describes various hazards and the 3rd column says to wear spectacles with side shields and a face shield. Then it lists some notes. Note 3 says: (3) Faceshields should only be worn over primary eye protection (spectacles or goggles). So technically it's not "either/or" faces shield or safety glasses, it's "and/both".

Am I glad OSHA regs don't apply to my home shop, you bet I am, but I also am glad they provide this information so I can make an informed choice for myself. If what I'm turning is something I feel needs a face shield, you can bet my safety glasses are under it.

Steve

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#17

Steven Antonucci

More accurately, a face shield doesn't matter

steven antonucci

The reality is that having a face shield on offers very little protection from the types of impacts we've heard about. They're not designed to withstand that kind of force, and the word face shield is tossed about as if they were all equivalent.

I teach people to turn wearing eye protection because I know that it is better than having no eye protection, but a "face shield" has limited value when standing at the lathe. Once you get above a certain mass/speed combination, none of the gear out there really helps at all.

I think that there are enough facts available to paint an accurate picture of what value wearing a face shield might have at the lathe, but until recent discussions, people have equated face shields with being "safety"...and that is just not the truth. I wear a face shield when turning very wet wood to keep the spray out of my face. I wear one when I am using CA glue on the lathe for the same reason. I sometimes wear one when roughing bark because getting hit in the face with bark stings. I never wear it as protection against dismounts, because I know it won't.

All Mike appears to be pointing out is that there is no consensus about what a good helmet would actually look like based upon they types of things that can happen on the lathe.

It would be nice to see someone use a lathe in testing a turning face shield. That's a demo that I would sit through...

Steve

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#18

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

Jerry Klug

I am reluctant to bring up another tangent to the face shield discussion but here I go... I used to ride motorcycles to commute to college and work. That was year round in Seattle, rain, snow or fog I was cautiously riding. This was a number of years ago but at that time polycarbonate helmets were just becoming popular. I always used a Bell fiberglass helmet probably because they were accepted by the professional racing community. The early poly helmets could break in two (not minor cracking) if they fell from a store room shelf at the dealer when the stock was not rotated and the stock was getting old. Seems the early ploy helmets were very susceptible to degradation from atmospheric contaminates like smog.

Can current riders like John Jordan or John Lucas may be able to tell me if polycarbonate has improved such that timely replacement is no longer an issue?

I have and use a Trend for dusty conditions and a Uvex Bionic for less dusty but when there is potential for flying debris. I chose the Bionic because of decades of wearing Uvex safety glasses in industrial settings.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#19

Steven Antonucci

Agree...but it is a non sequitur?

steven antonucci

Nobody would argue that a face shield adds safety when used properly for its intended purpose. The argument "against" face shields is that they are not being used for their intended purposes. Almost all of the face shield and PAPR equipment on the market is splash guard and dust small debris, not blunt force impact.

Might you get some implied protection from having one in place? Perhaps, but the number and types of events that they actually provide any protection is very limited. It would be akin to assuming that a bullet proof vest would provide protection against someone with a knife because they are both weapons.

I read the test procedure quickly, and it looks like they fire a 1/4" steel ball bearing at the lense at 150MPH to see if it breaks. This is not a substitute for a 1 pound block of wood hitting you at 50mph. The ANSI standard is only about the glasses ability to not shatter- not the transmission of the pressure wave it creates upon impact.

Killed some time googling...

Steve

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#20

Alan Zenreich

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

Alan Zenreich

In case anyone is interested, the 3M AirStream and BreatheEasy PAPR helmets that Lauren and I use are rated:

Headgear meets the requirements of ANSI Z87.1-2003 (Eye and Face Protection) and ANSI Z89.1-2003 Type I, Class C (Industrial Head Protection)

Of course, these helmets add HEPA dust protection, and optionally organic compound (fumes) protection with the BreatheEasy.

And a little more detail about the specs:

http://multimedia.3m.com/mws/mediawebserver?mwsId=SSSSSufSevTsZxtUM8_vmx_BevUqevTSevTSevTSeSSSSSS--&fn=RegUpdate24_1076FOD.pdf

What we could use are some more affordable (lower priced) versions of these industrial protection devices.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#21

Alan Zenreich

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

Alan Zenreich

I just looked carefully at the clear shields (visors) on our four 3M helmets. Three are marked "Z87.1 2003" and one is marked "Z87+".

They were made in different years, and if I can easily determine if there is any difference, and one is better than the other, I can simply order replacement snap in visors.

I know that there are high impact visors made for the mining and welding versions of the helmets.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#22

Alan Zenreich

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

Alan Zenreich

A little more information about the Z87 standard... updated in 2010.

From the Uvex FAQ

http://www.uvex.us/uploadedFiles/ProductConfiguration/ProductLiterature/Uvex_SP_ANSIZ87_2010_FAQ.pdf

IMPACT & COVERAGE

o Protectors were previously classified as either basic or high impact. In Z87.1 – 2010, the distinction now is that they are either non-impact or impact rated devices.

Impact rated protectors must meet the established high mass and high velocity tests, and defined, continuous lateral coverage is now mandatory.

Those protectors satisfying the requirements will carry the Z87+ mark on both the lens and the frame or housing. Compliant prescription products will be marked with Z87-2+.


Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#23

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

mjonesrdg

Betty wrote: in italics)

1) American Woodturner is a journal, not a magazine (there is a difference, which I try to uphold). Magazines exist primarily as vehicles for advertisements, so their content is geared toward satisfying the needs of vendors, as in doing product "reviews." AAW's journal does not cater to advertisers. Membership dues are enough to pay for journal production.

All the more reason, I say, for the AAW to "get off the dime", Publish something that means something regarding face shield proper use.

2) Who are "they" when you speak of "the AAW"? "They" are US ... you, included. Andy Chen stepped forward to write an article. You did some research, why not write an article or a letter to the editor? In spite of what many Forum participants think, only a small percentage of AAW members look at the Forums, and at that, not regularly (your voice is only marginally heard). The AAW is not sidstepping this issue, but as I wrote earlier, the many volunteers ("they") would welcome constructive help in establishing policy.

I am an American, but I often refer to the government as "they" and I seldom think that "they" are us (even when technically that might be so). I am not a writer. Nothing in my education nor experience qualifies me to go beyond what I have done here.

3) When Andy Chen's article on faceshields was published, a representative from Trend called me to complain about Andy's unfair treatment of his product. The rep's follow-up letter was poorly argued and not based on facts, so my reply had many questions for the rep to answer. I've heard no response. I have, however, heard that sales of Trend have increased.

Now THIS (correspondence), would be interesting to see!

4) Jerry is correct. And, I want to emphasize that wearing a splash-guard faceshield (the kind with the metal strip around the clear shield) is worse than not wearing a faceshield for eye protection. That metal strip can detach upon impact and impale itself into a person's face or eye.

The bigger issue, I think, is couched in the user's belief and subsequent behaviors regarding face shield use. If "suiting up" with duly stamped and certified as "z87+" equipment would result in even slightly more emboldened practices, that equiment could be seen as an "attractive nuisance". I would have that AAW, all the forums, and all the related publications would stress that these face shields (and particularly the headgear) are not made to protect against flying debris.

5) What the AAW does need to do is come up with a sound, reasonable, enforceable safety policy for its symposium. As for local AAW chapters (independent entities) and their activities, that's a whole 'nuther large problem to consider.

I very much appreciate, Betty, your contributions here in this forum. Please do not ever take this crotchety old man's "stingers" personally.

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#24

What most don't understand

Geoff Whaling

What most turners don't understand is that the impact testing standards of ANSI Z87.1, CSA - Z94.3, AS/NZS 1337.1:2010, CE EN166 etc do not offer the impact protection levels required to prevent injury from the types of hazards that are currently causing very concerning injuries and the deaths of wood turners.

Ballistic rated (Military Standard 662) PPE items may offer an increased level of protection - though they are not tested to the impact levels wood turners potentially may experience. We must look at what we are doing in a wholistic sense - ballistic rated PPE may just transfer the injury from say the face to neck or even the back of the head as the falling turner strikes another object in a resulting fall from a high energy impact. The true answer is to avoid the impact!

The “impact” rated spectacles and face shields are neither guaranteed shatterproof nor unbreakable for all hazard types, and do not guarantee that you will escape uninjured from an event. They are tested to meet and offer a minimum standard of protection as specified by the standard.

The level of impacts we are talking about frequently knock a person to the ground! They will cause injury - the extent of which is determined by what actions the individual has implemented. It may just be a nasty bruise because your actions and the PPE mitigated the impact levels experienced. You may get away with risky practices for a while, however high speed + high mass + taking high risks + no (or inadequate) PPE generally results in a life threatening injury eventually! Accident research and injury statistics prove that.

Occupational mandatory standards for hazard identification and risk assessment may or may not apply to "recreational" users so it becomes the individual’s responsibility to determine their level of exposure to a hazard, the risk of injury and the potential outcome. Bodies like AAW and AWGB etc can and do offer guidance, but it becomes a legal minefield.

Large platter and bowl projects involving questionable blanks can and do generate flying objects with both high mass and high velocity that well exceed the current impact testing standards.

The whole object of implementing safety protocols is to avoid injury, or to at minimum mitigate the level of injury. There is no questioning the facts that high order hazard controls do work. Controls like – DON’T DO IT! - or if you choose to proceed you must use – suitable work holding methods, stabilize blanks, low turning speeds, frequently stop & inspect, minimise time in the line of fire, turning techniques and tools that present a lower risk etc.

Wearing appropriately rated PPE is also proven to mitigate the extent and severity of an injury if all other hazard controls fail. Appropriate selection of PPE (i.e. “impact” rated face shield and safety spectacles) is also considered a high order control for some hazard types such as protection from very commonly encountered nuisance particles that cause typical eye injuries. PPE is a high order control in that scenario because it intervenes between the path of the object and the eye or face. PPE is both a first and a last line of defence hazard control!

A HF, bowl or platter blank with voids / inclusions creates an entirely foreseeable set of hazards that turners should be aware of. In the end it is the individual’s choice – but the whole community often picks up the tab for their stupidity, ignorance or their deliberate and considered choice. I personally do not believe events are “accidents” they may be unintended, unplanned or exceptionally rare but they are possible and we should take reasonable precautions to avoid or mitigate the consequences of them.

One very reasonable control is arround $50 worth of PPE – impact rated face shield and spectacles – less than the cost of a decent gouge! I can never understand why anyone would accept a higher risk of injury when such affordable PPE provides a significant additional level of protection – it is very cheap additional “medical insurance.”

Re: ...but you already knew this..(faceshields)

#25

Manufacturers are obliged to supply

Geoff Whaling

Under ANSI Z87.1 - The protector manufacturer must provide test results to the purchaser upon request.