Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Turning Speed Safety

Posts

Turning Speed Safety

#1

Turning Speed Safety

Jim Breeden

I read a number of responses about turning speed, and how fast the speed is a lesson in safety. I can agree with this reasoning - but - how is one to get a clean cut at slower speeds ? I usually turn at 1800 then finish off the bottom at 500, with lots of sanding to remove the marks. I keep my tools sharp, rub the bevel, but can't seem to get the same results at a slower speed. I watch the demos at our meetings (NMWT.org . . . . . gotta get our plug in here) to see what I am missing about the cutting sequence, but it seems I am doing the correct procedure. At least I have lots >( of sandpaper.

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#2

Re: Turning Speed Safety

Dale Miner

There isn't a safe speed for failed crotches or wood with shakes and checks. It seems that almost without fail when an accident is discussed on the web, high speed AND defects in the wood are both involved. We see photos of pieces that have bark inclusions that virtually cut the wood in to two pieces, and have to wonder how many more times before the turner uses up his luck.

Our ole' (old?) buddy JJ said it best, "Life is to short to turn crappy wood".

As to getting a better finish at higher speed, that is probably a result of the feed rate per revolution. If the tool was advanced the same distance per revolution at a slower rpm with all other factors remaining the same, the surface would be the same. In metal working where a plastic flow of the material occurs, a higher surface speed can sometimes be beneficial, but in wood, plastic flow does not occur.

The 'all other factors remaining the same' is the part that is tough to control, especially with hand held tooling. Cutting air, heart beats, breathing, steadiness of hand, all play into the surface off the tool, so the faster the tool moves, the less those factors influence the surface.

1800 rpm sounds awfully fast to me if the bowl has any size to it.

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#3

Re: Turning Speed Safety

John Lucas

Jim You may be pushing the gouge too much. Relax your grip and let it do the cutting. Smooth cuts are not my problem at slow speeds. The reason I like faster speeds is it helps to get the arc of the bowl smoother. When your tool is moving very slowly across the surface you have to "steer" the gouge handle much more slowly and it can lead to a rippled (although clean) surface. Holding the tool handle against your body helps and steering by moving your hips can produce a smoother arc. However I find it easier to do a fluid movement with my body when the gouge is moving faster across the piece.

There seems to be a middle ground where I take a much lighter cut on the final cuts to smooth out the arc. The lighter cut lets me move the tool faster across the surface and in a smoother arc without having to resort to "Warp" speeds.

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#4

Re: Turning Speed Safety

clay foster

I would be turning at half that speed. Speed is irrelevant to a clean cut. A sharp, well tuned plane will take microscopically thin shavings at speeds of about one foot per second. High rpm on a lathe makes it easier to produce a faired curve, but it's still not essential. A clean surface comes from a sharp tool and thin cuts.

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#5

Re: Turning Speed Safety

John Jordan

I'm with Clay-I doubt that I've ever turned a bowl or vessel at 1800 rpm-usually 8-900 rpm. It doesn't take me long to turn something, not because of speed or furious and aggressive movements, but because each deliberate, controlled movement and cut accomplishes what it should. I don't work hard at all. Ever. :)

John

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#6

Lathe Speed Article  *LINK*

Doc Green

Here are links to two articles that contain the "basic information" relating to selecting an RPM for turning a piece.

The first gives a graphical presentation of the 6,000--9,000 rule, which I believe was first put forth by Dale Nish to give a range of lathe speeds for turning pieces of different diameters. The article also gives a way to visualize the energy content of a spinning disk and explains how changes in RPM affect both the kinetic energy and the centrifugal force. Also, a comparison is made between a spinning disk (a bowl blank) and a spindle; the energy content of the spinning spindle is a small fraction of that of the bowl blank.

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/lathespeed.html

The second article is actually concerned with turning spalted and/or degraded wood, but photos are given of severely punky wood, a piece with a ring shake that goes all the way through the piece, and a chunk of dogwood that had to be rejected because of a bark inclusion.

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/spalted1.html

~Doc


Doc's website

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#7

Steven Antonucci

lathes shouldnt have rpm readouts.

Steven Antonucci

I have 8 (I think?) Belt positions on my Nova 3000. I usually turn between the 3-5 position, which is 700ish to 1400ish rpm. For 90% of the stuff I turn, I can be in any of these and I will be safe...but I always check anyway. Faster is not better above 1500... it is just faster.

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Lathe Speed Article

Lyle Jamieson

Even at slow speeds the missile launched at you will hurt you. Its all about the speed of the wood not the speed of the lathe. Slow speeds can hurt you too. I turn faster then most. Like John Lucas I get better results...but I know what I,m doing and don't turn crappy wood...fast. It is not the speed that can hurt you it is the error in judgment that will hurt you. If you EVER have a piece of wood come off the lathe, get some help and find out what you did wrong. Even if it was a little piece of wood and at slow speeds!! Many of us that teach have had students that have been turning for many years that are still doing dangerous things. We have to learn safe procedures, trial and error is the hard way to learn.

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#9

Re: Lathe Speed Article

sergiov

A bullet at 3 ft a second does'n penetrate a thing, it may bruise you and that's it. A bulet at 3,000 ft a second goes into into a skull whithout esitation.

Accidents happen, that is why car races have deadly accidents in spite of the supposed skills of the drivers.

Speed can kill: E=1/2Iw(square). This is what give a rotating piece of wood is energy.

E = energy (what can kill you)

I = moment of inertia

w= angular velocity

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#10

Re: Turning Speed Safety

Jim Breeden

I thank all for your inputs. I don't turn fast if I see the wood is not stable, there is bark inclusion, off center, etc. It just seems I can't get a good cut with slow rpm after I've got it to a round condition. I have noticed lately I do "push" the tool, and take to big a bite. My conclusion . . . with all your inputs . . . go slow and let the tool do the work. I am in the process of making a three piece candle set out of "fence post cedar". I just finished the first piece, with my usual push method, and lots of sandpaper - man is that stuff soft ! Tomorrow I will try the under 1800 rpm go slow method as recommended, and will let you know what happens.

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#11

Re: Turning Speed Safety

Fred Holder

I seldom turn bowls, of any size, at speed above 800 to 1000 rpm. In 25 years of turning I've only lost one bowl off of the lathe and that one came out of the chuck and went across the room, but didn't hit anyone. I agree that slower speeds and sharp tools are the way to go, always!!!

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#12

Harry Robinette

Re: Turning Speed Safety

Harry Robinette

I was wondering when the, I can't get it smooth at low speed was going to start.

If the lathe is slowed down you have to slow the cut down. I very rarely turn over 1200 rpm unless it's a pen.If you have sharp tools then you can turn on a foot powered lathe.

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#13

Re: Turning Speed Safety

Jim Breeden

Harry - I've never turned a pen, so what does faster speeds have to do with turning a pen ?

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#14

Re: Lathe Speed Article

Jim Breeden

I read your links, especially the part about "turning air", of which I have turned numerous pieces, using high RPM - typically my 1800. I have found if I turn down to less than 1500 I get lots of bumps with uneven cuts and tool marks. I very careful attention not to change the rub angle while doing this, but still get a crummy surface.

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#15

Alan Zenreich

Re: Turning Speed Safety

Alan Zenreich

Jim,

The typical diameter of a pen (especially near the ends of the blank) is often less than 1/2". So to get a reasonable feed rate, raising the speed is useful.

Re: Turning Speed Safety

#16

Re: Lathe Speed Article

robo hippy

Jim,

Relax your grip a little. I had the same problem, and it got a lot better when I wasn't using the white knuckle grip.

Faster speeds just leave a cleaner surface. I don't suggest them for beginners because mistakes are greatly amplified. I will turn smaller bowls (10 inch) that are balanced at 2,000 plus.

robo hippy