Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Eccentric threads? (PIC)

Posts

Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#1

Eccentric threads? (PIC)

Doug Wolf

I build a threading jig out of a cross vise from Harbor I had laying around after seeing the threading jigs made by John Lucas and Mike Peace. Thanks guys!

Now the question is why does the workpiece travel in an eccentric circle around the cutter? The cutter touches deeper on one side of the workpiece than the other which produces threads that have sharp peaks on one side and flat peaks on the other.

The chuck is mounted on a 1 1/4" by 8 tpi all-thread that is threaded into a piece of maple that has been tapped. The insert on the chuck is screwed on until it bottoms out on the end of the all-thread and then I insert the set screw in the side of the insert to lock it on the all-thread.

To cut the threads I just unscrew the all-thread out of the maple block and cut the threads.

All I can figure is the chuck/insert is not centering on the all-thread. I turned the lid on the chuck and haven't removed it from the chuck. The all-thread is straight and not bent.

Any ideas will be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#2

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Doug, I see two possibilities: One, the all-thread rod may not be quite round so that the thread depth varies around the circumference; Two, the all-thread may be slightly undersize compared to the chuck and the slack allows the rod to be pulled off center by the set screw or by uneven pressure of the the end of the rod against the chuck.

Dennis

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#3

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

Dick Coers

I'd suspect the thread in the maple block. How much clearance between the all thread and the wood? All thread is almost always undersized. Grain in the maple block will effect the quality of thread. Some of the thread is in end grain, and then long grain. It's just not going to be accurate. You're working with non precision hardware, it will give you non precision results. There is a reason threading jigs are expensive.

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#4

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

Doug Wolf

There is no side play at all in the all-thread and maple. In fact there is no "side" play at the chuck. It just revolves in an eccentric circle around the cutter.

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#5

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

walta

When the chuck is on a lathe it is not the threads that make the chuck run true to the lathe.

The threads only pull the flat part of the chuck (see photo A item 1) firmly against the flat shoulder machined into the spindle (see photo A item 2). Photo B shows the flats seated together.

You need something for the chuck to seat against.

Walta


Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#6

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Doug, try loosening the set screw and backing out the all-thread just a tad so that it does not hit the chuck and see if the all-thread can be moved in any direction. As an experiment, you might try wrapping the all-thread with several layers of plumber's teflon tape to take up any slack and see if that changes things.

Dennis

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#7

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

galen Vetterick

A jam nut behind the chuck would do a better job of holding the chuck more concentric with the all thread then a set screw forcing it off center. Better yet to put the jam nut on your lathe first and face it off as most nuts faces are not that true to thread.

Not sure what holds your cross slide solid either. The acme threads are usually loose fit and the pin fit of the rod to jaw is too.

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#8

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

John Lucas

It's all of the above. I have that problem to a much lesser extent using my Baxter threader and my Powermatic lathe. It's less on my new Delta Midi. I took the threader over to Vic at Bestwoodtools and had him measure it thinking that was the problem. I mean I have a powermatic and Vicmarc chucks which thought were accurate. He measured the threader and it was accurate to about 20 or 30 millionths of an inch. I did not misquote that figure.

so he and I have been trying to trace down the problem. Mine varies from about 7 to 12" from the cutter just scratching the wood to the cutter making one complete scratch all the way around. We have decided that it is a combination of the chuck, the lathe spindle, the wood and just plain dirt getting on the mating surfaces.

First of all out lathes as good as they are, are not metal lathes and don't have the accuracy. Same with the chucks. Sure they are pretty darn close but even tool and die guys will tell you a 3 jaw chuck on a metal lathe will not run perfectly true. If they want dead on the go to 4 jaw independant chucks and dial indicate the piece in. I know our lathes aren't that accurate.

Then couple that with even the tiniest piece of grit between the mating surfaces of the chuck and spindle and you've added another degree of inaccuracy.

Now another area for inaccuracy (and it will always be worse on homemade threaders) is the block that holds the lead screw that determines the thread. If it is not dead on as you screw it out it exagerates the inaccuracies. Then you add in just the tiniest bit of wood movement and now the compounding of all these minor things starts to show up.

I have played will all the threaders on the market except Soren Bergers and they all have this same problem. Sometimes the problems doesn't exist and sometimes it's really bad. My homemade threaders both have (for lack of a better description lets call it runout) of about .018". Well on a 16TPI thread that's half the depth of the thread which means you get a flat top thread on one side and pointed on the other. You can of course cut deeper and get a pointed top thread all the way around. It will throw off the fit of the outside of the box by .018" but this isn't a problem if you clean up the outside once the lid is in place.

What does all this mean. Don't worry about it. I've probably made 100 or more threaded boxes in the last 8 or 9 years (actually maybe a lot more) I've had my threader and not one customer has noticed the difference in the threads. I do and it bugs the hell out me. If you get a good fitting lid and turn the outside after you've made the box and screwed the lid on, no one will notice.

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#9

Eccentric Thread Problem Solved

Doug Wolf

First of all, thanks for all of the good suggestions. Like John said "It's all of the above."

I checked the "runout" of the NOVA G3 chuck, which I was using for the lid, on the all-thread with the set screw and it was .003". Then I measured with it seated against a nut and it was .004". Then screwed on the all-thread until it bottomed out against the end and it was .009". So using the set screw ended up with the least "runout".

Then I mounted it back on the headstock and it was .009".

I checked my SuperNOVA 2, that I was using for the box base, and it was .002" on the headstock and .005 with the setscrew on the threading jig.

After reading John's comments and realizing I would probably be the only one to notice the threads (unless I take it to the wood club meeting and the "critics" start poking around it) I went ahead and cut the threads. Luckily I made the tenon 1/8" larger than the lid so I had plenty of material to cut and the threads ended up with sharp peaks all the way around. When I screwed the lid on the base and turned the outside of the box, the tenon I had used for chucking the lid was over 1/16" off center.

Now that the box is finished, you would never know it was that far off center when the threads were cut. It is still on the lathe with a coat of 50/50 sanding sealer on the inside and threads and Watco oil on the outside.

Thanks for all of the ideas, that's why I'm on this forum.


Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#10

Re: Eccentric Thread Problem Solved

John Lucas

Doug a few more tips. I will sometimes clean the threads with a brass brush. Touch it lightly. This works on softer woods, not needed on hard woods. Then I hit the sharp peak with 600 grit paper. Then I apply wax to the threads with a tooth brush. Makes the threads feel good to the hands and the lid will just spin on.

I also sneak up on a good fit. On 16TPI threads I will often gut the second set of threads at .020" instead of the full depth of .032. Test fit the lid and then add another .005" if needed. Usually a good fit is less than the .032".

Re: Eccentric threads? (PIC)

#11

Re: Eccentric Thread Problem Solved

Marshall Gorrow

Doug, I agree with John on cleaning the threads with a nylon brush (similar to a tooth brush). I use beeswax softened with a little mineral oil for the only finish on threads. The male thread should have a little flat at the top of the thread to prevent chipping.

I don't use a threading jig. I hand chase threads but the results are the same.