Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

the origin of lichen

Posts

the origin of lichen

#1

the origin of lichen

GaryG in MD

So, a guy goes into a bar...

But I digress...

This is a completely subjective question.

I just turned and sanded a side-grain NE white-oak bowl from a piece of a historic tree over 200 years old. It's one of the usual deals -- get the wood, turn the bowl, give it back for their fund-raising efforts, or whatever. A nice little project.

The bowl is 8" long diameter, and the rim is just under 1/4" wide. All of the inner bark and some of the outer bark is still on. I like the look -- kind of jagged and rustic. But here's the deal -- there are some small patches of lichen interspersed on the rim. (BTW, lichen is a cross between a fungus and algae -- it grows like a fungus but is green and can photosynthesize.)

My question is: do I leave the lichen there, as befits a "natural" edge, or do I remove it, as a visual distraction.

I do have a current personal preference, but I'm flexible, and I'm interested in hearing how YOU have dealt with this problem in the past, and if you were happy with your decision later.

So, a guy goes into the bar.

He's a fun guy, so he sets up a round for everyone.

A pretty girl snuggles up to him and says:

"I'm all gal, and I'm a-liken you."

The rest is history.

...GG

Re: the origin of lichen

#2

My usual practice is to leave lichens......

JamieDonaldson

...on the bark if well attached. They will lose the green or whatever color after finishing, but some customers recognize them as a naturally occurring decoration.

Re: the origin of lichen

#3

Thanks, Jamie...  and another question

GaryG in MD

I was hoping someone would say that -- it's my current propensity if somebody doesn't come up with a good reason for not doing it.

Another question while I have your attention --

I'm going to finish it with Watco Danish.

I normally use Bush Oil, but that builds quickly (which is why I normally use it), but this time I don't want too much of a shine -- I purposely stopped sanding at 320, which is far below my norm, because I want a no-shine "rustic" look. I figure one coat of Watco will do it.

I almost put the Watco on now before the bowl is completely dry -- in part, to slow the drying in hopes of getting no cracks. I wasn't completely sure if putting Watco on slightly wet wood is a good idea or not, so I put it in three brown paper bags and plan to wait for a few days before I oil it. What's your experience, if any, with oiling not-completely-dry woods?

Other readers please chime in too!

...GG

Re: the origin of lichen

#4

Re: Thanks, Jamie...  and another question

Jim Breeden

Gary - I turned a piece of Mountain Mahogany and left all the lichen and bark on in between what I had turned away. Used Deft sealant and Staples wax, didn't put anything on the lichen or the bark, as I wanted it to be the natural color.

Re: the origin of lichen

#5

Re: Thanks, Jamie...  and another question

Mike Brazeau

Gary, in the past few weeks I have made two apple NE bowls with bark and a pencil pot that I turned to completion, sanded to 400 and applied Watco Danish Oil generously and immediately so they would not crack. They were about 1/4" to 3/8" walls. Takes the Watco a long time to dry and they dry to a stable weight in 8-10 days. I buffed one with Tripoli after a week and the oil was coming out from the heat generated. Final Finish Is rougher (capitals are iPad's, not mine) than if turned dry, but can be rubbed with 0000 and buffed and waxed. Have thought of applying some Bush Oil or Waterlox to one for more shine but have not got there yet. The bark I dry brush with a very small amount of oil. This tree did not have lichens, but I have left them in the past on other pieces.

Re: the origin of lichen

#6

aha!

GaryG in MD

Good info, Mike.

What you have reminded me about, among other things, is that when the wood dries, the surface (wet sanded) will not be as smooth as if it were dry sanded.

Since the piece has a very uniform thickness, and I have it triple bagged, I'm going to hope that it dries without cracking, without an early Watco treatment. Even though you meant it otherwise, I'm going to use your info as a recommendation to not oil it till it's reasonably dry AND, importantly, to sand it again after it's dry before oiling it. Since I only took it to 320, this could be an important step.

OK, I'm a-liken lichen. It stays on -- and not too much oil on the bark.

Thanks very much for your thoughtful reply. ...GG

Re: the origin of lichen

#7

Thanks, Jim

GaryG in MD

OK, good thoughts -- the lichen stays on, and don't get the oil on it! ...GG

Re: the origin of lichen

#8

Re: aha!

Mike Brazeau

Thanks Gary. I haven't taken the time to get back to these and try rubbing with the steel wool. I have some seven zero steel wool I picked up at one of the symposiums but have never put it to the test. Maybe this is the time. At worst they will have a real nice satin finish. Have to get around to photographing and posting. The contrast in the apple with heartwood and sapwood is fantastic. One rough out I did the conventional way cracked but will likely heal enough to fill and use.

Re: the origin of lichen

#9

Joe Fleming

Re: aha!

Joe Fleming

Isn't seven-zero steel wool the same as a cotton ball? :-)

Re: the origin of lichen

#10

Re: aha!

Bernie Rose

Would 7 zs steel wool even be strong enough to hold together? It seems that such a fine strand would turn to a handfull of grinder filings.

Re: the origin of lichen

#11

Re: aha!

Doug Trembath

Gary, I have taken a similar approach on some problematic timbers, in order to save that one that just HAS to be finished...

My best recourse is to let it dry 3 bagged (but check it occasionally and replace the bags if it's still wet to discourage any microscopic pests and staining.)

When dry, I will wet sand it by hand or if it will rest comfortably in a vacuum chuck, at low speed, with whatever grit the piece needs using the final finish as a lubricant(Oil, in my case), and then go through my normal finishing routine. I have saved some that you would wonder if it could be done, and reaped the rewards.

On the other hand, I have had those that simply refused to dry without a check. In that case, it becomes character, and I accentuate the failure in some manner, and it almost always sells, don't ask me why. If a piece strikes your heart, I believe you owe it to yourself to complete it, no matter what.

I am often asked when showing my work "How long does it take you to make these?"

My pat answer is to say each one takes it's own time, and I give it whatever it needs..."

Doug Trembath

Re: the origin of lichen

#12

Thanks for your thoughts, Doug...


Re: the origin of lichen

#13

Re: aha!

Mike Brazeau

It is actually bonded to a backing in a sheet about 1/4" thick overall. I think I got it at the Sanding Glove booth at Hartford symposium, might have even been Louisville.