got a couple of tompson tools at swatt and i need to make some handles for them...
i like to do big, so i want some length for leverage.. is there a magic formula for length or what do you like for a handle for a big gouge... 14, 16, 20, 26 inches for the handle itself?
I like bigger diameter for fitting my big paws, in the 1 3/4 to 2 inch range. Any handle longer than about 16 is over kill. You only need that much if you are hanging off the tool rest a long way. I have some 3/8 inch diameter tools in 1 inch diameter handles, maybe 12 inches long.
I made my 16" handles out of aluminum 1 1/14" rod and ten rapped them with the stuff they use to rap golf club handles. It would depend on the size of you hands though.
Then I drilled two holes and taped them so I could change the tool when needed.
.....regarding handle length is that the minimum length of the handle should be at least 5 times (5 X) the length of the expected overhang of the tool's cutting end beyond the tool rest. Hopefully your over-reach will not be that long (keep the tool rest close to the work), but for "leverage" and tool control, this 5X "rule" would be a minimum - e.g. for a 4" overhang beyond the tool rest, the handle should be at least 20".
The diameter of the handle should be a comfortable fit within your hand when it is gripped that some say should just barely allow the tip of your thumb to touch (or nearly so) the tip of the closest finger when wrapped around the tool handle. Handles that are too thin or too thick can create added strain on muscles of the hand and forearm, causing unnecessary or "early" fatigue in use. Turning your own wooden handles allows the customization of the handle thickness, which is a benefit for adjusting dimensions of ergonomically compatible tools. Some have taken the step further by designing handles with 'triangle" sections (like Hannestool), following basic ergonomic design principles.
....larger gouges on my hip while roughing, so those are longer handles than most other tools. For finesse cutting with other tools I want the handles to be short enough to swing in front of me while working. It is absolutely counter-productive to fine sand and finish handles, which makes them too slippery to hold securely. I learned with mostly Sorby tools long ago, and have replaced many of those original steels many times in the old familiar handles that stay at home.
The diameter of the handle is an important factor. Despite having relatively small hands (actually short fingers), I like to have a good diameter, and wooden. I generally think that the handles on most tools I have bought are too skinny. I now usually buy tools without handles and make my own.
Most of my tools are 16". That's a comfortable reach for me since my right hand is usually near the end. For roughing I use a 5/8" gouge and the handle is longer and weighted. Mostly for the weight and dampening, my hand is still around the 14" area.
I remember in the early days of big bowls my friend Joe Looper had 7 and 8 foot long handles that were 3" in diameter. When your roughing a 50" platter like Joe did it took that much to counter the leverage. Now everyone is using captured bar systems for larger work although I just met James Johnson and he uses 8 foot long bars made from 3" square tubing. He had a piece on the wall at SWAT that was probably 5 foot around. I'll try to post a photo later.