Food for thought
Ellis Walentine
Charlie's recent post about filtering and creativity got me to thinking about my own creativity, such as it may be, and, in the larger scheme of things, what motivates me to turn at all. In the past, I've turned both functional and non-functional objects, and in my mind, creativity was at least a factor in all of them, depending on your definition of "creativity."
I think that everything we make or do that is defined by our conscious will, is creative to an extent, in that we have created a solution to the design problem or motivation that prompted this response in the first place. Further, I think that creativity has several different dimensions, not least of which are aesthetics and engineering. Every time we mount a piece of wood on the lathe, we are acting out a design intention -- to turn a beautiful shape, to make a functional object or part, to create raw material for further decoration or refinement off-lathe, etc. -- and I view that intention, and the manner in which we carry it out, as the creative process. Everything from posing the problem to solving it is part of the creative process. Its success is the measure of how well it performs and/or how aesthetically appealing it is.
Of course, aesthetics and engineering success is always relative to the needs of "the customer." This begs the question of who that customer is. If the customer is us -- in other words, we're making the thing for oursleves -- the standard is our own satisfaction, which, in turn, is dependent on how well the piece functions or how pleased we are with its shape, finish, and/or whatever other design intent we have imposed on it. In this case, we are the judges of our own creativity. If the customer is someone else, an actual or anticipated client (i.e., commissioned vs speculative work), we need to adjust our creative output level to that of the client, whose needs and standards may be quite specific, or not.
There has been a long, back-and-forth debate among turners about decorative work, round-and-brown work, functional work, etc., as though these forms were mutually exclusive. I've always taken a step back and viewed them all as forms of expression, which is the right of the individual. Definitions aren't as important if you view it this way. The measure of a person's creativity is how well the piece works for the audience it is designed to please.
I could go on and on here, but I think I'll see if any of you would like to join this discussion. I think it is the underlying issue, spoken or unspoken, of everything we do as creators of things.
Ellis




