Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Food for thought

Posts

Food for thought

#1

Ellis Walentine

Food for thought

Ellis Walentine

Charlie's recent post about filtering and creativity got me to thinking about my own creativity, such as it may be, and, in the larger scheme of things, what motivates me to turn at all. In the past, I've turned both functional and non-functional objects, and in my mind, creativity was at least a factor in all of them, depending on your definition of "creativity."

I think that everything we make or do that is defined by our conscious will, is creative to an extent, in that we have created a solution to the design problem or motivation that prompted this response in the first place. Further, I think that creativity has several different dimensions, not least of which are aesthetics and engineering. Every time we mount a piece of wood on the lathe, we are acting out a design intention -- to turn a beautiful shape, to make a functional object or part, to create raw material for further decoration or refinement off-lathe, etc. -- and I view that intention, and the manner in which we carry it out, as the creative process. Everything from posing the problem to solving it is part of the creative process. Its success is the measure of how well it performs and/or how aesthetically appealing it is.

Of course, aesthetics and engineering success is always relative to the needs of "the customer." This begs the question of who that customer is. If the customer is us -- in other words, we're making the thing for oursleves -- the standard is our own satisfaction, which, in turn, is dependent on how well the piece functions or how pleased we are with its shape, finish, and/or whatever other design intent we have imposed on it. In this case, we are the judges of our own creativity. If the customer is someone else, an actual or anticipated client (i.e., commissioned vs speculative work), we need to adjust our creative output level to that of the client, whose needs and standards may be quite specific, or not.

There has been a long, back-and-forth debate among turners about decorative work, round-and-brown work, functional work, etc., as though these forms were mutually exclusive. I've always taken a step back and viewed them all as forms of expression, which is the right of the individual. Definitions aren't as important if you view it this way. The measure of a person's creativity is how well the piece works for the audience it is designed to please.

I could go on and on here, but I think I'll see if any of you would like to join this discussion. I think it is the underlying issue, spoken or unspoken, of everything we do as creators of things.

Ellis

Re: Food for thought

#2

A Counterpoint (sort of)

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

That Chaos and/or mental illness may be the Mothers of Creativity I will leave to another day as there's that whole branch of medical research with its focus on most everything we do, feel, or think being able to be explained (and hence manipulated) by the right combination of chemicals.

My point, however, is that while an abstract idea which we may identify as the product of "creativity" may be the result of mental chaos, or even Monsters from the Id (or some other pocket of subconciousness), there must come a point when chaos, instability, and/or the lack of "filtering" are pushed aside, giving way to the intense focus and analytical decision-making that is required to bring that abstract into actual existence. I've heard the assertion more than once that Edvard Munch was actually painting his reality; that what we see on his canvases is what he saw every day. A scary thought actually.

As makers doing a piece, we must clamp on serious filters and must concentrate on the hundreds of decisions we make in the course of doing that piece and only that piece. How well the idea is carried out into a concrete expression of the idea such that others can see and understand it is in direct proportion to the clarity of vision and dedication of the maker to the idea. When I was teaching (art, ceramics, sculpture) I had a sign in my classroom that every student was directed to, most more than once. The sign read "IT'S BETTER TO BE CLEARLY WRONG THAN UNCLEARLY MAYBE"

Chaos and sensory overload can only result in obfuscated ideas and "maybes" as products.

Re: Food for thought

#3

Re: A Counterpoint (sort of)

Sergio

Where the brush...maybe....

Re: Food for thought

#4

Re: A Counterpoint (sort of)

Sergio

previous post...posted in the wrong place!

Re: Food for thought

#5

Notta Too Late

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You hitta da "delete" key, I'ma do likawise :D :D :D

Re: Food for thought

#6

Steven Antonucci

Is it capability or creativity?

steven antonucci

I'm not sure that there aren't really two things being discussed?

Creativity (in my mind) is the ability to take things that you've learned and create new things with them. While turning a bowl CREATES a bowl from nothing, I don't know that I would describe it as overwhelmingly creative? People have been making bowls for 10000 years. We are merely continuing a very human trait of making things.

Truly creative people find something new to do with "a bowl". It might be using the bowl as a canvas, or cutting it and reassembling it into some unforeseen way that makes it transform. There are many fewer of these types of people in the world. I suspect that they are wired a little bit different from your average person...and that it is either in you, or not. I am not certain that you can "learn this?"

Neither one is better than the other, but I do think that they are different. The first person to realize that they could spin a piece of wood on a bow lathe and then figured out that cutting it would give a round object started with nothing. The second person that saw it started with the first person's divine inspiration...

S

Re: Food for thought

#7

Somewhere There Is A Balance

charlie belden

Mark:

You note that there are two phases to creating - conceiving of a piece and the process of designing then creating it. And I agree that the design and execution process requires more and more focus, more and more filtering out of unworkable possibilities, as it proceeds.

I was interested in the initial filtering out of possibilities as arguably the biggest impediment to our being creative. It's the old "If you only have a hammer, everything looks like a nail" thing. If you only think in terms of bowls you unnecessarily narrow down considerably the possibilities of what can be done on a lathe.

As Ellis said, it's the Design and Execution phase of creating where the real fun comes in - where the challenges of working out HOW an idea might be executed and then deciding on the one that best fits your skills, abilities with tools and machines available to you. I think your position is quite similar to Ellis's.

Turners are quite good at figuring out ways to do things. It's the coming up with new ideas of what to DO that many have problems with - a Creativity Mental Block. And, I believe that Creativity Mental Block can be attributed to too much filtering out of possibilities - ruling out wild hare ideas merely because they're wild hare ideas.

I really enjoy pursuing wild hare ideas. And I know how well I've done when I finish my pursuit and think "I'm still not sure how I did THAT." - and THAT is something really nice and not like anything I've seen before. Do all the wild hare ideas end up that way? Admittedly not. But even when that happens, I've learned all sorts of things along the way that may be useful for some future wild hare idea for a piece.

Re: Food for thought

#8

Re: Somewhere There Is A Balance

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The "inspiration" "tickle at the back of your mind" "full-blown dream image" may come from the ether of chaos, but the cognitive realization and the analysis absolutely needed to work out the details to make the object, come from intense focus. Whether you're aware (conscious) of the process or not, it's there. What you call "wild hair" ideas are usually the end result of a process that may have taken 6 minutes or 6 years to complete. Where you take the image in your brain is up to your analytical conscious mind which must have the ability to focus. To "create" the finished object requires cohesive thought. The balance you seek is all in your conscious mind, your millisecond-to-millisecond awareness of being and doing.

Your success will be determined by your ability to tune in, turn on, but not drop out. :D

Re: Food for thought

#9

Be very selective about the "turn on" ....

JamieDonaldson

...process in that equation! ;)

Re: Food for thought

#10

Invitation for all on creativity

Ray - Middletown, IN

There is a MOOC starting Sept. 1 on this very subject. There are a lot of folks here that could add much to the discussion of innovation and creativity. Stop by and take a look at the course syllabus and if you have time join in. I signed up some time ago and the recent posts have really kick started the thought process.

Ray

MOOC - Massive Open Online Course

Re: Food for thought

#11

Ellis Walentine

I understand and agree with you, Steve

Ellis Walentine

There are a lot of semantics at play here, which is part of the ongoing problem with the creativity dialogue. Creativity in the design and execution sense that I was talking about above is more of a catch-phrase for the process of making anything. The flip side, and maybe the more intriguing question is, where do we get our inspiration, our innovation, our out-of-the-box thinking that informs the design and execution of our work? Some of it is probably innate, having to do with the way our brains are wired, our accumulated experiences, our learned paradigms for viewing challenges...

You also touched on the idea of novelty and origination vs derivation. The old adage is that there is nothing new under the sun, that every design has been designed or derived before. We have grown up seeing these designs and internalizing them, so even if they are not consciously articulated in our design process, they are in the background informing it. This opens a whole new can of worms regarding originality. In essence, we can't help designing with the tools we've got, the ones that are pre-wired in our heads, yet, at some level -- perhaps at many levels -- we are incorporating something that has gone before.

To me, the measure of success is whether the finish product satisfies the need or idea that motivated it. If it is clearly derived from some identifiable prior art, or some other maker's style, it needs to acknowledge that and not attempt to capitalize on it. I think this is the crux of the ongoing debate about plagiarism in art. On the other hand, I don't think that we, as striving makers of things, can possibly eliminate all the historical and cultural influences that have been ingrained in us over our lifetimes. We can't help but imitate, consciously or unconsciously -- it would make it impossible for us to turn at all -- but we need to be careful about claiming these creations as our own. This is a controversy that will rage on, I'm sure, but we learn by imitating pieces and techniques we admire, and it's satisfying and motivating to do so, so we'll continue to do it.

Ellis

Re: Food for thought

#12

Ellis Walentine

To your point... *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Here's a TED talk that may amuse.


The Art of the Imperfect

Re: Food for thought

#13

Let's Define Some Terms

charlie belden

The discussion seems to be about being creative, innovative and imaginative. They are often used interchangeably but no one is defining their terms. Maybe this quote from Linda Naiman may help in this discussion.

"Creativity is the act of turning new and imaginative ideas into reality. Creativity involves two processes: thinking, then producing. Innovation is the production or implementation of a creative idea. If you have ideas, but don’t act on them, you are imaginative but not creative."

Re: Food for thought

#14

MOOC Creativity Class Link Please


Re: Food for thought

#16

I Tend to Disagree

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

On one aspect, anyway...

In my view, it is the idea that is creative. The "making" is the hand-maiden of the idea.

The 70's fad of "conceptual art" that involved nothing more than writing up the idea, some in excruciating detail, is an example. Others are the intense fields of higher math and cosmology, which "produce" nothing but chalkboards of calculations.

To limit a definition of "creativity" to the making of something concrete can become somewhat self-serving.

"Innovation", on the other hand, I view as intimately tied to making, or at least the producing, of something, and most often, I think, relates to modification of or an alternative to a preexisting item, method, or improved solution to a task or problem.

Innovation requires a base reference; creativity does not, although it can be helped by a foundation.

The two may, however, function together when the desire to make the creative idea into a concrete object requires innovations in methods and/or materials.

Re: Food for thought

#17

Only "Organic" and "All Natural"