Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

fading dyes?

Posts

fading dyes?

#1

fading dyes?

GaryG in MD

The "Artisan" dyes from Craft Supplies say they are "highly fade resistant".

I understand modern labeling very well... like in wines, where "dry" means "sweet". I suspect that "highly fade resistant" means they fade, in comparison with something like Trans Tint.

I'd like to hear from anyone who has first-hand knowledge about the real longevity of the "Artisan" brand of dyes. Thanks, GG

Re: fading dyes?

#2

Re: fading dyes?

Mike Foster

Gary, if you discuss this with folks who do archival work I think all would agree that dyes will eventually fade no matter who makes them. Some are more stable than others, but all will eventually fade. I have taken to using more archival coloring methods in preference to dyes. Gary Sanders has been on top of this for a long time, and I took a coloring class from him at JC Campbell a few years ago. His solution is to use inks. This is mostly what I have turned to lately if I want a more transparent color like dyes. Even the inks vary and the art supply companies, like Dick Blick, will give you information on archival quality. Some of the inks are dye based, and they do not give them as good a rating for archival quality as the acrylic based inks. The acrylic based inks are water based and can be diuted with water to get less intense color. The inks I use are FW and Higgins and some Bombay colors.

My other method for a similar effect is airbrushing with transparent acrylic paints. These do tend to hide the wood more than the inks, and the more color you apply, the more opaque it gets.

Re: fading dyes?

#3

Joe Fleming

Re: fading dyes? - long answer

Joe Fleming

I'll add a little to what Mike said. Transparent paints are really stain. Paint and stain are essentially the same except that paint has more solids. If you apply enough coats of stain or transparent paint, the effect is opaque. Both paint an stain suspend solids in the liquid that are deposited on the surface when you use them. Dyes, on the other hand, are completely liquified. The dye penetrates into the fibers and imparts color that way.

Aniline dyes are not very light fast, as a general rule. Their color comes from earth pigments, so I am told, and these will fade. Metal-acid dyes are very light fast. Some inks are aniline and will fade. Others are better. Ink does come in a variety of colors so you can mix. Metal-acid dyes are more difficult to obtain due to their toxicity. I have a set from Liberon, but I do not think they make them anymore.

Trans Tint are metal-complex. They come in a liquid concentrate. I have used them a little with no noticeable fading, but I do not consider my observation conclusive. Trans Fast are aniline. They come in a powder. I have used these powders to color epoxy and to make custom wood colors. I used these on a church lectern over 20 years ago and the color is still true. Again, not a conclusive observation. Both come from Homestead finishing products.

BTW - Some "stains" are really dyes. Solar-Lux brand calls their mixture stain, but they are dyes.

The Chestnut Stains are also really aniline dyes. They will fade. I have a beautiful Don Derry piece at home which was colored with Chestnut, I think. The color they call "royal blue" has faded a lot. If not Chestnut, it is still aniline. Don does not use aniline any longer.

Jimmy Clewes popularized the Chestnut colors about 10 years ago in the US and Craft Supplies carried them for a short while. They are difficult to import, so CSUSA found a state-side maker for the Artisan Brand dyes. I only have one "test" of those colors. When CSUSA introduced them, they had a catalog cover with three pieces dyed with these colors. When I was in Provo the next year for the symposium, those pieces were in their offices and they looked somewhat faded to me.

As a rule, I keep colored pieces out of direct sunlight. The Derry piece mentioned above has always been away from windows and, often, in a glass-enclosed cabinet. After about 10 years, the purple is faded. The blue is not faded to my eye. I acquired another Don piece around the same time. Metal-acid colors. All of the colors in it are still vibrant.

Joe Fleming - San Diego

Re: fading dyes?

#4

Joe Fleming

Re: fading dyes? - long answer

Joe Fleming

Adding one more thought. I just heard that Jimmy Clewes is now importing Chestnut into the US. He lives in Las Vegas now, so they are more easily obtainable. I use Chestnut in my coloring classes especially for airbrush work. They are alcohol based but not particularly toxic as compared to some of the others. I will be buying more for class now that I can.

Do use all of these materials in a well ventilated area and wear protective clothing and gear. Lay out the rags to dry before discarding. Don't do the Jimmy technique of lighting the dyed surface to flash dry it. It is great showmanship, but very dangerous. Trust me on that one. Let's just say that I have three fully charged extinguishers in my shop and I check them annually.

Joe

Re: fading dyes?

#5

Thanks Mike and Joe...

GaryG in MD

...for your excellent, detailed answers.

That's exactly the kind of good info I was looking for.

And it will be a big help for all others reading, too.

Well done! ...GG

Re: fading dyes?

#6

Aniline dyes are mostly derived........

JamieDonaldson

....from organic petroleum processes, and vary greatly in generally poor lightfast characteristics. With the more dependable permanent pigmenting products such as metallic acid TransTints now available, I don't know why anyone would knowingly continue using anilines? >(

Re: fading dyes?

#7

Does anyone know???

GaryG in MD

What chemical type of dye is the Craft Supplies "Artisan" dye.

There is no information available from the packaging or from Craft Supplies literature, and a Google search for the MSDS turned up nada.

Has anyone done the necessary research to get the info out of them? ...GG

Re: fading dyes?

#8

Re: Does anyone know???

Don Orr

I believe-but could easily be wrong-that the Artisan dyes are manufactured by Mohawk finishing products and are made here in the USA. They used to be made near here in Amsterdam,NY. This info I believe came to me from Andy DiPietro who uses Mohawk dyes on many of his large hollow vessels and is very concerned about fading. Maybe a note to him could get you more details. Please feel free to share any more you learn about this subject.

Re: fading dyes?

#9

Thanks, Don...

GaryG in MD

That sounds encouraging.

I just sent Andy an email.

Either I or he will post the results.

...GG

Re: fading dyes?

#10

Andy DiPietro

Re: Does anyone know???

Andy DiPietro

To be absolutely sure I would recommend sticking with the Mohawk Finishing Ultra penetrating Dye stains. I color matched the red to the Artisan dyes from Craft Supply many years ago and I suspect they are the same but I do not know that. If you do not want to buy the large quantities from Mohawk like I do, then call Craft Supply and ask them were the buy their dyes from. Doug Fisher also uses the Mohawk stains.

I have never had an issue with fading colors in the 4 years that I have been dying my vessels.

http://www.mohawk-finishing.com/catalog_browse.asp?ictNbr=178

Product Overview

A truly new dye stain that promises superior transparent qualities found only in dye stains and excellent lightfastness. Will not bleed into top coat finishes. May be brushed, wiped or sprayed directly on wood or mixed in lacquer for toning. Colors may be intermixed to acquire additional shades. Mohawk's Ultra™ Penetrating Stain offers the user the best combined characteristics of water, alcohol, or lacquer type dyes.

Re: fading dyes?

#11

Thanks, Andy...

GaryG in MD

Good to hear from you.

I'll call them and see if they have an answer.

If you have the time, we'd love for you to post a few pix here as well as on WoW.

Your work is extraordinary and uplifting (both figuratively and literally!).

Cheers, Gary

Re: fading dyes?

#12

Andy DiPietro

Re: Thanks, Andy...

Andy DiPietro

Your welcome, will do.