Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Help with cracking bowl?

Posts

Help with cracking bowl?

#1

Help with cracking bowl?

Barry Irby

I cut some limbs from a red oak in my yard. As a sort of keepsake and practice piece I turned a tree wing bowl out of a branch union. Got the whole thing down to about a 1/4". This was a green as could be, turned it within an hour of cutting it off the tree. After several days it has cracked in one of the wings. The top is now sort of crescent shaped where it used to be flat. (Exactly what I expected.)

I am wondering about the crack. The bowl is basically hemispherical. I suspect the problem is I left too much wood under the wings where I swept out to horizontal from the bowl to the under side of the wing. Right in the cove or fillet, the wood is probably a 1/2" thick. Is this the problem? Should I have made the transition more abrupt and tried harder to maintain the 1/4" thickness? Or does this just happen? (The bowl is about 8" in diameter and the whole thing will turn just inside a 16" circle.)

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

#2

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

Dick Coers

1/2" green oak with the pith will always crack. 1/8" may do the same thing. Uneven wall thickness is even worse. What did you do to slow the drying?

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

#3

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

John lucas

Typing on phone so excuse typos. Its probably because its limb stock which is pretty reactive. May have already had a crack or weak spot that you could t see. Could have been dried too fast. May not be the uneven thickness unless the wood tried to move a lot near the thicker area and couldnt.

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

#4

I'd Recommend John Jordan's DVD on Aesthetics.

Greg Haugen

I'd highly recommend John's Aesthetics DVD.

First off, what did you do with the bowl after you turned it? Let's give you the benefit of the the doubt and say the walls were perfectly even and a 1/4" thick. Best option would be to place it in a cardboard box or brown paper bag. IF it was soaking wet, I'd have the box/bag closed for a week or so and then opened. If it wasn't slinging water too bad, I'd start with it open. For the best results, in a cool, calm place-like the basement floor. Any green wood, even finish turned, left open to moving air on the shelf in a hot shop will usually be a cracked piece. Heat and air movement dries wood, usually too fast. Also how was the grain balanced? Was the piece centered and balanced in line with the pith and growth rings? Limb wood or trunk wood doesn't matter to me as long as the grain is balanced. The common error with limb wood is the pith is off centered. Water in the limb is effected by gravity so the bottom of the limbs has wider growth rings than the top. The correct way to cut these pieces is to center the piece on the pith. So you'd have narrow blank and one deep blank. IF you cut it to have two equal pieces, not have the pith centered, you'll have more issues. Personally, I like limb wood. I can usually get deeper blanks off of the first few limbs than I can the trunk often times. The narrow blank...usually is firewood.

Wood Cracks for three reasons:

1)It was cracked already and you couldn't see it before.

2)Being dried too fast and not controlled

3)Unbalanced stresses; either from wall thickness or grain balance

Also Barry, where in the wing did it crack; edge, middle, or at the bowl? Even though it took several days for it to crack, that doesn't necessarily point to one issue or the other. That was just the "free" water drying before the "bound" water. Free water is mostly what gets you wet and your lathe rusty. Bound water is the cellular water that causes the warping and some times cracks.

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

Lyle Jamieson

Red oak it hard to work with. It has a large shrink rate and is not forgiving in the drying process. The drying must be slowed down and even then you can loose some just because it is red oak.

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

#6

Harry Robinette

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

Harry Robinette

One thing I do with limb wood is always make sure I cut it down the pith and split the compression and reaction wood. The reaction wood will always crack allot worst then the compression wood. If you talk to most pro's they only turn trunk wood for this reason.

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

#7

Thanks and a little more info.....

Barry Irby

I split the blank right through the three piths. This is from the larger half. The split is in the wing that would have been the continuation of the main branch away from the tree. The split is centered on that wing. The wing is only about an inch long at that point. The split is running down into the fillet under neath the wing. I sanded it to about 220 and sprayed it with about four coats of rattle can Deft Lacquer. Its sitting on my friends desk in his office. Not so much as a gift, but because people kept asking to see it and take it home to show there wife (wives?). (My "plan" if such existed, was to let the lacquer retard drying and then hand sand and apply more as necessary.)

I was mostly wondering about the fillet or cove under the wings. the closest thing I have to a time machine is the other half of the blank. I could turn another out of it and see what happens. But because it is not precisely identical and has not been treated in an identical fashion, I am not sure what I would learn. The other blank is thinner and has been sitting in my basement shop for about a week.

Re: Help with cracking bowl?

#8

Re: Thanks and a little more info.....

Dick Coers

After you turn it, it has to go into a paper bag, a tub of denatured alcohol, boiled in water, or soak in a water/soap mixture. It just can't see air for at least a week if you have any chance of preventing cracks. Google will be your friend in all those alternative drying techniques I mentioned. A couple coats of lacquer and sitting on a desk is not a good plan for drying.