Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Fiddle Back Theory

Posts

Fiddle Back Theory

#1

Fiddle Back Theory

charlie belden

My arborist friend brought me by three pieces of a Died Standing Dried Standing sugar maple (I think). The pieces started at the ground and up the bottom 6 feet of the tree. The bottom of the bottom piece had four piths, probably the tops of roots. When I saw that I called our turning club's Wood Whisperer (the guy is really good at visualizing what's inside chunks of wood by what he sees on the ends). This piece was about 26" tall, 27" in one dimension, 22" in the other, and there were some bumps and points on the outside indicating buds that began developing and stopped before becoming a branch. These indicate possible Birds Eye in the wood. There were also very subtle horizontal ripples going around it as well - indicating possible Fiddle Back inside.

Having halved this logette I poured water on the fresh cut faces to "pop" whatever figure was in the wood. Sure enough - Fiddle Back, with evidence of medullary rays that had begun spalting - lighter than the surrounding wood.

The Wood Whisperer explained his theory of what causes Fiddle Back figure in wood. Imagine elastic donuts with small "holes" (pith) in the center - filled with water. Stack them on top of each other. As the stack grows taller, the downward force of the weight above them on the lower donuts cause them to get flatter and bulge out - kind of like a herniated disk in a spine. The grain in each donut that was originally running up and down now has curved due to compression So when you cut "with the grain" though these areas, you cut grain paralling the cut AND acrossed the grain where the grain bulges out.

The attachement may illustrate the idea better than just words


Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#2

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

Mike Foster

Interesting ideas. Sort of what I have imagined as to the origin of fiddleback. I often see that figre more often at the base of trees. You can actually see the curl in a lot of trees around here, especially maples. Definitely seem to see it more in the old large trees. I have to think that compression forces are part of the origin. I recently took down an ash tree that wound up having some gorgeous curl, but only in the first 2 ft of the trunk. Rest was just plain. i have seen logs of maple with curl through the whole log which makes me wonder if it the same forces that cause the curl or if it is a result of the way the tree grows.

BTW- the ground doesn't push up (just had to throw that in) :D

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#3

Steven Antonucci

Ground has to push up

steven antonucci

Or the tree would accelerate into the center of the Earth! Newtonian Law #3 (equal and opposite)

If you've ever fallen on your butt, you know that the ground pushes back ;)

Steve

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#4

Semantics


Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#5

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

charlie belden

Mike:

It's a Statics thing. Dynamics is a bit trickier to deal with - which is why you've got to be more careful around rotating things and moving things ; )

In a force vectors diagram, if there's a force vector in one direction and none in the opposite direction of equal magnitude the object must be moving. Since few trees move much vertically . . .

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#6

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

robo hippy

Well, an old timer told me it was in part that the fibers do an accordion type thing so under wind stress, the tree can move without the fiber breaking. He told a story about harvesting some hill side maple that were all leaning, and under stress, but had no ripple. They were on the lee side of the hill. He harvested others that were on the windy side of the hill, and they all had ripple. It is another explanation of why there is always ripple under where the branch comes into a tree. Sounds logical to me. On the other hand, some trees have ripple just because......

robo hippy

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#7

compression curl compared to curly

Dick Coers

My opinion, at least ttwo kinds of figure with about the same look. Compression curl that forms under big branches and in the buttress flare of the tree, and the genetic version that involves all the tree at the same density.

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#8

Steven Antonucci

not only moving, but accelerating

steven antonucci

but you are dead on ;)

If you fall out of a tree, you don't die from the force of gravity, but the sudden stop (which is how you know the ground pushes back!)

S

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#9

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

waltben

I was told pretty much the same by an arborist in North Carolina about ten years back. He said in his experience, almost all fiddle-back, curly, tiger or whatever name you'd like to use came from trees exposed to wind stress.

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

Keith Tompkins

Charlie, I have cut maples that had fiddleback figure throughout....even the twigs on the tips of each branch! I have been told it's comparable to some people having straight hair, while others have curly hair...Rob Wallace...where are you?

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#11

Re: not only moving, but accelerating

Mike Foster

Yeah, but if the ground pushes up (with acceleration) then why doesn't the ground just fly up and away when the tree is taken down? :D

And it really is just the curvature of space-time, not gravity at all.

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#12

Steven Antonucci

There is no such thing as time

steven antonucci

All depends upon whether you are Newtonian or Einstein in belief...

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#13

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

Doug Turner

Charlie,

In Japan they tie rope around small trees and as they grow they produce "fiddleback" grain. This causes compression from the sides as opposed to your theory of compression from the top and bottom. They can vary the width of the fiddleback by the width of the rope. The rope has to be loosened periodically to avoid killing the tree.

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#14

Youse guys is all nuts! The figure..

JamieDonaldson

...is there cause it is, and if it ain't there then it ain't! :D

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: not only moving, but accelerating

Keith Tompkins

Mike....sounds like the inspiration for a new turning :D

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#16

Malcolm Ray

Re: Youse guys is all nuts! The figure..

Malcolm Ray

I'm with you on that Jamie.......................

Re: Fiddle Back Theory

#17

Re: Youse guys is all nuts! The figure..

John Jordan

A really figured tree will have curl the entire length of the tree, including even the small branches. That's not compression etc.

Pretty much all maples have compression figure at the base and buttresses as already pointed out.

John