Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

Posts

If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

#1

If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

charlie belden

You've probably mounted a chunk of wood on your lathe and started turning with only a vague idea of what you wanted to turn, or maybe even no idea at all of where you were going with it. Sometimes the end results surprise you - in a good way. But more often than not it goes the other way.

You've probably mounted a chunk of wood on your lathe, and with a pretty good idea of what you want to turn, start making the chips fly. Then, on the way to the piece you had in mind, you see something in the wood or about the shape you're seeing or both that changes your mind. The original design gets modified or completely changed and sometimes you end up with a nicer piece than you had in mind - or not.

Then there's the type of piece that pretty much requires that you have a very clear idea of what it should look like and how it must be turned - a winged vessel, a lidded box with a "pop fit" maybe a christmas ornament with finial and icicle.

Wingin' It can be a lot of fun and can sometimes serendipitously result in surprisingly nice pieces. But when you have worked out a design really well before selecting the wood for it or getting to the lathe - you're more apt to end up with a nice piece.

Do YOU have a vague idea for a piece, but don't have the tools to work it out and visualize it in sufficient detail to be able to refine it enough to actually turn it?

The key to success seems to be a Vision Thing, having a pretty clear idea for a piece and being able to visualize the end result you're after.

With single axis turning, it's fairly easy to visualize the design for a plate, bowl, vase or hollow form. You can draw half of the profile on a piece of paper and visualize the other half or actually draw it as well. With a mental image of what you want to turn, you can recognize what the turned piece should look like as you turn it. And you can make templates of the inside and outside profiles to make checking how close your turning is to what you'd designed - as you turn it. Of course, most of us make adjustments on the fly, seeing opportunities for changes as the piece is being turned. Once you have turned a piece you like, the piece can be the model for doing another one, or a dozen more - because you can see the original piece as you're turning a copy or a variation of the original piece.

If you then choose to pierce or pyro or carve the turned piece you usually pencil the pattern directly on the piece so you can SEE the idea on the actual piece and make adjustments to the layout. When you can see what you're after you can start carving, piercing, texturing, or pyroing. Of course you could just jump right in and fly by the seat of your pants - but that's risky. That can lead to accidental discoveries - but . . .

The key to the whole thing is to be able to VISUALIZE ideas, choose the one you like and work out, mentally /visually, how to get there. Then all that's left is the turning, piercing or carving or texturing or pyroing ; )

Now some folks are able to visualize an idea soley in their head - no need to do a drawing, no need for templates - they just see it - very clearly. Fewer can use that mental image of the idea and work out how to make it. Fewer still can actually make it - as the idea was originally visualized.

But when you get into ideas for pieces that require turning on multiple axes (axes being the plural of axis - as in on more than one axis), or pieces that require cutting up a piece or pieces and re-assembling their parts (think Walking Bowl) - things get a bit trickier to visualize, let alone work out how to turn them. And if you can't visualize where you want to go and how you're going to get there - it's hard to get there. 2D design tools just aren't adequate for designing and working out how to actually turn these types of pieces - at least not for me.

The lathe is a sculpting tool with a single axis constraint. The wood, on the other hand has no constraints on how it can be sculpted. It can be sequentially turned on any number of axes - as Escoulen, Weidman and Dill repeatedly show us. WE KNOW it's possible to go way beyond the "round" of Round & Brown. It's the limitations of the design tools that has been limiting what's "turnable" on the lathe - for most of us.

Now Barbara Dill's articles and demonstrations of a structured approach to multi-axis / multiple axes turning has gone a long ways to the understanding of What Does What - axes and outcomes possible using them. With Parallel Axes You Can Do THIS, with Crossing Axes You Can Do THAT, with Intersecting Axes You Can Do These. But even if you understand the fundamental concepts, it's still difficult to apply them because it's difficult to visualize the outcome of a piece turned on multiple axes. And if you can't visualize the outcome - it's very hard to get the outcome you think you want.

But now we're starting to get visualization tools that go way beyond pencil and paper, or even clay models.

There ARE 3D design tools available now (Google's FREE SketchUp, Wolfram's Mathematica being two I'm aware of and familiar with) that can be used to create virtual 3D models of objects - to scale. And there are now "affordable" (if you can spend $2K on one) 3D printers that will "print" ACTUAL 3D objects from a Virtual 3D object's data. Both the 3D design tools and 3D printers do have learning curves that must be climbed before they can be used well, but there are YouTube and other sources for video tutorials that can flatten the learning curve considerably. Easier to learn and use 3D apps are coming and 3D printers with more capabilities at lower prices are coming as well. Won't be too long before we'll be able to visualize things we can't now, and hold them in our hand(s).

The Visualization Dam is leaking and when the dam breaks there'll be a floor of new types of turnings. We have hints of what's coming, but only a few are turning them - now.

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

#2

Leo Cuellar

And some will print in wood... sort of.

Leo Cuellar

Yes, Charlie, visualizing is the key. Especially if you are trying to create something that has not been done before. I've decided to pull the trigger on a small 3D printer, called the Bukito. http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/deezmaker/bukito-portable-3d-printer-take-it-everywhere This is a Kickstarter project(no affiliation), I opted for the fully assembled version which won't ship until next February. So, I have some time to start familiarizing myself with the software before it arrives. Why did I choose this one? Not too expensive, will print in multiple material types, free open-source software, and the way it is designed, it could be reworked to print far larger than its current 5" x 6" x 5" capacity.

Will this make me a better turner? Unknown. Some uses that I imagine... printing up new designs for soft jaws for holding delicate or oddball work. Making liners for vases or boxes. http://richrap.blogspot.co.uk/2013/04/3d-printing-with-nylon-618-filament-in.html Printing out details for casting metal parts or coating with conductive paint and electroplating them. This printer will even print in a substance called Laywood, http://www.geek.com/news/laywood-filaments-lets-you-3d-print-with-wood-1517745/ Not to mention repairing plastic items that I cannot buy parts for. Got plastic containers with missing clips?

The hard part of course will be translating what is designed into something that is doable on the lathe. So it seems to me that what we need is a virtual lathe program that lets us simulate what we actually do on the lathe on the computer before we touch tool to wood. Then we could work out the necessary steps to a finished piece, or discover that it is technically impractical. Now, I am certainly not smart enough to accomplish this, but someone out there is.

This is a technologically exciting era in which we find ourselves. The major patents on the laser sintering process are expiring soon. Expect to be able to print in metal at home at an "affordable" cost within the next two years.

Cheers & keep it coming with the thought provoking topics!!!

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

#3

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

barbara dill

For me, multi axis turning is like music. The relationships that I found between different elements of the spindle and the axes allow me to forge ahead without getting stuck. There is, however quite a bit of play and sketching on the lathe to find other forms. Many of the forms I find really suck; some are delightful. But I learn from them all, just like playing music....there is a theory that allows us to understand harmonies and timing and notes, and then there is the jazz that is free and fun. For me, turning must be fun and an adventure. And it is.

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

#4

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

steve worcester

If you can't visualize it, there is nothing to make.

Not that is wrong, but use that opportunity to create something and refine from that. Sometimes there is a turners block, not unlike a writers block.

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

Keith Tompkins

Hi Charlie, good topic. I stress in my classes the importance of visualization; having a goal beforehand increases the odds dramatically of creating a successful work, but it seems few have the ability (at least at first) to visualize the results. Most of my stuff requires planning right from the start; I occasionally begin a project without a formal plan, but I know exactly what I want to make. I like the concept of making what's in my imagination rather than using a program.

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

#6

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

charlie belden

Barbara:

If you use the music analogy, to play jazz well you need to understand quite a bit about music - Learn The Rules Before You Start Breaking Them - if you want to make music and not just noises. When you began your exploration of turning on more than one axis you were pressing keys on a keyboard and hearing the resulting sounds - some pleasing, some not. You found chords - some that were pleasing - some not. As you developed an understaning of the fundamental concepts behind how to make pleasing sounds you could then hear pleasing sounds in your head and then play them so others could hear them. But you had to be able to hear the sounds in your head first

Now you have an understanding of some of what is possible with Parallel, Crossing and Twisten Axes you you can improvise using that understanding. Consciously or unconsciously - you can visualize the outcome you're after - and know how many and what type(s)of axes are needed and what steps must be taken, in what order, to get the outcome you envision. The idea for your piece Harmony did not come about spontaneously. You'd found the basics of it earlier on when doing bottle stoppers. At that time you didn't see the potentional for the idea - but had a primitive of the idea amongst your reference material for ideas. But the turning of Harmony took some planning and being able to visualize how it could be turned.

To use the music analogy again, even if you can play every note in a piece of sheet music, if you want to compose and play your own music - you have to be able to "hear" it in your mind first.

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

#7

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

Terry Scott

Its one thing visualizing it its another getting my head to tell the hands what to do

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

#8

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

charlie belden

Keith:

Regardless how you do it, drawings, clay models, chicken wire, for trickier pieces like Clewe's Chinese Hat lidded box, Mike Foster's Minimal Surface series, Weidman's animals and even Barbara's improvised MA pieces, there was at least a mental model of the piece. Without at least that, the steps to turn the piece, it would very likely lead to either a dead end before completion - either because there was no way to hold the piece to turn the last step, wood would be removed where it shouldn't be removed (think handcutting dovetails), or the piece wouldn't look as conceived.

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

#9

Re: If you can't visualize IT, can you make IT?

charlie belden

I seldom find myself with no ideas to turn. So it's not a mental block that's the problem - it's being able to visualize an idea in sufficient detail to work out how to turn it. This is particularly true for turnings on multiple axes because of the interaction between what's turned on each axis. Cut and reassemble pieces - walking bowls for example can be a challenge to visualize the turning sequence and the cutting rejoining process. Inside Out turnings can also be difficult to visualize the turning sequence.

There's another need for visualizing - to look at the outside of a logette and "see" what's probably inside - then orient the piece of wood on the lathe to exploit as much as possible what's inside

Yes, on single axis turning, one can Wing It. Mount a chunk of wood between centers and start making the chips fly until you see something that looks good - at least to you. This approach can lead to some interesting pieces. But with a little pre-turning visualization they could probably be better or a lot better.