Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

mcnaughton question

Posts

mcnaughton question

#1

mcnaughton question

GaryG in MD

I'm considering buying the center saver, but I don't know if they make one to fit my Jet 1236 lathe. I think it's kind of in the crack. Their small one has a 5/8" post which is no good. The middle-size one has a 1" post, but I think it's really for larger lathes. I can't find the height of the gate post in their literature. Most 1" tool rests for larger lathes are too tall for the 1236, so I expect this is too. The centerline of my lathe is at 4-7/8" above the horizontal rod that defines the location of the bottom of the tool rest in the banjo.

Does anyone use the McNaughton center saver with a Jet 1236, and, if so, what did you have to do to get the right height for the gate/post?

TIA, GG

Re: mcnaughton question

#2

Make spacers

Jorge

Gary,

All you need is some hardwood, set the gate so the cutter is dead center, measure the distance from the bottom of it to the bed and make the spacer, a cylinder of the proper height with a hole to go around the post; just a few minutes, and you are in business.

Re: mcnaughton question

#3

Re: mcnaughton question

Greg Haugen

Gary, Measure your factory tool rest from the bottom of the post to the top of the rest. (Now for those other people reading this, this is for the Jets only and the way they make the banjo and the camshaft in line with the hole for the rest.) If that measurement is 6" or under, the McNaughton will be a little too long. Two options are available. One order it and have a metal shop trim the post so it's just a touch short, you don't want it bottomed out at the right height, the vibration can damage your banjo. Or two, Call Craft Supplies and ask what lengths of posts do they have in stock? The standard post, measuring from the bottom of the post to the first step where the turret and restraints rest, is 4". Have Craft Supplies "tech support" measure their extra posts for something shorter. That measurement that you took earlier is the total measurement that the WHOLE assembly can be, fully assembled with cutter in place, from the bottom of the post to the tip of the cutter.

Re: mcnaughton question

#4

Re: mcnaughton question

robert bilevich

I have a add selling a mcnaughton set in classifieds

Re: mcnaughton question

#5

thanks Greg

GaryG in MD

This is what I was concerned about -- it's my expectation that the "standard" post is too long. I don't want one bad enough to go to the effort of finding somebody to cut it off. Tech Support is a good idea, but it won't work for me because the only thing that tempted me is a Woodcraft sale 15% off -- today only. I don't want/need one that badly -- it was just kind of an "impulse" buy. I have a nice crabapple blank that was all I could salvage from our "bird" tree in the front yard. It died and had to come down -- pretty much rotten through and through -- I got only one decent side-grain blank out of the ground cut. I thought it would be nice to be able to core it, but it's not worth a lot of time, money, and grief. Looks like I'll just hollow it. Thanks for your thoughts, GG

Re: mcnaughton question

#6

Steven Antonucci

You could cut the post with a hacksaw/file edges

steven antonucci

Might take all of 20 minutes?

Learning to use it? More than 20 minutes. :)

S

Re: mcnaughton question

#7

it was going to be an impulse buy...

GaryG in MD

and I'm just as well off without it.

Wood grows on trees, and we have a LOT of it around here.

I have more in my basement than I'll ever be able to turn before I die (per a recent post). I'm not up for trouble and grief in order to spend, or after spending, a lot of money. And I don't have a saw that would touch a metal post like that.

I was just being sentimental about the loss of our "bird" tree, plus the fact that the only piece I was able to salvage has some nice color and grain, so it's a shame to turn it into shavings. This coincided with the two-day Woodcraft 15%-off sale. But even if they had what I need, which they probably don't, I'd have to wait for 10 days for them to get it to me. I'm not going to leave the wood in a plastic bag for that long -- I don't want it turning black. It was not meant to be. I'm moving on... ...GG

Re: mcnaughton question

#8

Steven Antonucci

core it at a friend's house?

Steven Antonucci

Save the wood, save the money? Someone owns a coring rig near you.

S

Re: mcnaughton question

#9

right on...

GaryG in MD

Just got the offer!

A fellow WCer.

Great minds... ...GG

Re: mcnaughton question

#10

Re: it was going to be an impulse buy...

Ralph Lindberg

A few weeks ago I was visiting a Myrtle wood bowl factory/store on the Oregon coast. The owner related the following. When he bought the shop the previous owner had him order x hundred board feet of 4 inch (think) wood. From which he got several hundred bowls.

Before the next run he bought coring tool (Oneway) and lathe (Oneway).

By coring, he was able to pay for the cost of the tool and lathe in the next run of bowls.

The point is, unless your wood is free (including your labor), at some point the coring system pays for itself.

Re: mcnaughton question

#11

Steven Antonucci

even just in the clean up!


Re: mcnaughton question

#12

true, Ralph, but...

GaryG in MD

Here in MD, we have easy and constant access to literally tons of about 20 different species of wood. I'm frankly irritated by the degree to which people are taking down big, healthy trees for no good reason. It detracts from the character of the neighborhood. And then there's the power company and their butchers. Don't even get me started there. Our County Council just passed two "tree" bills to begin limiting the wanton destruction. I know that, for example, in Atlanta, they have strong laws that save trees in the old neighborhoods. We have not had such a thing here, but it looks like we're finally moving in the right direction. But, I digress...

Freshly downed wood is plentiful here, but, partly as a result, not much of it is "special". If I were a professional, I agree that it would make sense to do it, but I don't sell, and as a low-volume hobbiest, it's a toss up. I can hollow a bowl in not much longer than the time it would take me to get out and install the coring rig. Plus, I kind of enjoy the act of hollowing a bowl because I get to see what's in there after each cut. Sometimes I see something I like and stop and leave it that way and maybe adjust the outside shape to conform to the unexpected inside shape. I certainly agree that if you have a burl or other "nice" piece of wood (or a sentimental piece such as I have now), coring is a good thing to do. That's why I was tempted. I'll look into the availability of a post that will fit my lathe so I'll know for the future, and maybe reconsider when the next sale comes around. ...GG

Re: mcnaughton question

#13

Re: true, Ralph, but...

Ralph Lindberg

Well....

I'm no pro with a coring system, not like Mike M or Robo, but I can setup and core a bowl blank in less time then it takes me to turn the inside to chips. But then the stop-collar lives on the gate (rest) and I have a couple coring knives sitting in a handle at all times. So I have little setup time.

Even if I (or the DW) don't use the core, I can toss it in the firewood pile and help heat the house with it. So my " wastage " is reduced.

As for wood availability.... well, I live west of Seattle and, well... you might say trees grow well out here. But it still takes effort to cut the tree down and the more wood I don't waste the happier I am.

Re: mcnaughton question

#14

Steven Antonucci

coring is faster by far

Steven Antonucci

When you get proficient at it, it is way faster to core. Add in the reduced clean up time, and you are way ahead...until it comes to finishing, when you give it all back ;)

I use the inner most cores for demos and I give them away at club meetings to the guys with mini lathes. I have a whole bin of them.

Steve