Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

vaccum pump choice

Posts

vaccum pump choice

#1

vaccum pump choice

Jimmy Edwards

For those of you that have a vaccum pump and use them I need to ask for your opinion for my application. It is not for the lathe but will be used to stabilize wood. I've made a Presto 16 qt. pressure cooker into a vaccum chamber and use a old car AC compressor. On test runs the AC compressor will only pull down 22" of vaccum. Altitude here is 2950'.

I have been researching better pumps like the JB Eliminator, Robinaire, and Gast. This isn't for my 3520b, only to stabilize punky wood.

If any of you have a vaccum pump, I would appreciate your input and opinions. My focus so far is on the DV-6E JB Eliminator. Thanks

Re: vaccum pump choice

#2

Re: vaccum pump choice

Jeff Smith

I've got a gast pump for the lathe, but use a rebuilt Thomas wob-l piston pump for my carving stand. This thing seems bulletproof, is relatively quiet and compact, and pulls maximum vacuum for me (we're pretty close to sea level here in the Seattle area. The only drawback is that it is only 1.6 cfm. If you can live with that, and it sounds like your application would pretty easily, it may be a good option. I only paid $35.00 for it online (EBay, I think) and it is in good condition. I think they're used a lot for pond aeration...

Re: vaccum pump choice

#3

Re: vaccum pump choice

Nick Todd

Judging by this chart:

http://www.anver.com/document/vacuum%20lifters/atmospheric%20pressure.htm

The most vacuum you should expect to create at your elevation is 26" of mercury. So for an second hand pump, you are doing pretty good. If you need more, you should look at a new pump.

I have a 25 year old gast that has never been rebuild & pulls 28+ " of mercury. I average 30+ bowls a year.

Re: vaccum pump choice

#4

Re: vaccum pump choice

Keith Newton

Jimmy, I would think that 22" ought to do what you are wanting it to do. I suppose you have the wood submerged in a fluid, expecting it to totally permeate the wood when the vacuum is released. Is that correct?

I have had a quart jar in-line on one of my pumps which I some experiments with a long time ago. Being able to see into the jar, gave me insights that I would have missed otherwise. While drawing the vacuum, I could see the wood fizz as the air escaped. But when I released it, you can't really see the fluid being drawn in, and maybe I didn't wait long enough for it to draw it in being a lot heavier viscosity, and I couldn't apply pressure above, as I suppose you could, but I found drawing and releasing multiple times seemed to help pump the fluid deeper.

I'd like to hear what product you are using. I wouldn't think that the cell cavities need to be totally filled, rather than just having the cell walls saturated.

Re: vaccum pump choice

#5

Re: vaccum pump choice

kkruizen

There is a fairly good article on turntexwoodworks website that you might want to look at.

http://www.turntex.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=61%3Avacuum-pumps&catid=35&Itemid=61

Re: vaccum pump choice

#6

Re: vaccum pump choice

Jorge

Jimmy.

I have a 6 cf Robinaire pump, here at sea level pulls 30+ but all I need is around 20 for big bowls or platters and as little as 10 for small pieces. The higher the vacuum, the hotter the pump gets.

This pump was not meant for continuous use like the Gast pumps, it was meant for retrieving freon from refrigeration units, and on the lathe in about 15 minutes, overheats and stops working so your piece can fly away, I had that happen to me, a beautiful honey locust bowl fell from the vacuum chuck, hit the bed and got a couple nasty gashes, while I was changing sandpaper...

Go with the Gast if you need continuous duty.

Re: vaccum pump choice

#7

Rob Wallace

Re: vaccum pump choice

Rob Wallace

Jorge - Jimmy wants a better pump for pulling down pressure in a vacuum chamber (made from a pressure-cooker pot), not for holding turnings on his lathe. I agree with you that Gast pumps are good quality and built to last.

Jimmy, at your altitude, you could do better than 22 in. Hg vacuum with a better pump, and I don't know how much better infiltration you will achieve with a higher level vacuum, but it is worth trying. I have purchased two Gast Model 0523 pumps for use with vacuum chucks on eBay for less than $100 each, plus shipping; eBay is a good source of vacuum pumps, as is Surplus Sales in Nebraska. Even more common on eBay are Gast pumps in the "22" series, which would be able to pull down your chamber well enough for your infiltration requirements; you don't need high cfm ratings since you probably won't be having to make up for leaks in the system (or through the wood) if you install a good valve at the chamber. Higher cfm ratings are needed with a vacuum chucking application in order to overcome leaks to maintain adequate vacuum at the required level.

In any case, I suggest you look for "dry" rotary vane pumps instead of diaphragm or piston pumps, or pumps that require the use of oil, which can be a messy and/or noisy solution for obtaining vacuum.

You should be able to find something that works for this application for a fairly small investment - smaller pumps are quite common.

I would caution anyone using a vacuum system to be careful about including a "jar" or other glass item not designed or rated to be used with vacuum systems. In graduate school I imploded a 2 liter thick-walled vacuum flask (designed to be used with negative pressures) when put under a moderate vacuum (the glass shattered due to a defect in the glass), and the results weren't pretty - glass shards everywhere - I was happy I was wearing jeans and not shorts or my legs would have been full of glass shrapnel! Do not include any item in the vacuum system that could break or implode - if you must, at least place it behind a plexiglas screen or wrap it in tape to prevent fragments from flying in case of an implosion.

Good hunting!

Rob

Re: vaccum pump choice

#8

Re: vaccum pump choice

walta

If you want a perfect vacuum you need a oil bath pump.

I have seen Gast pumps that are oil lubed but never oil bath.

I have never a Gast specification sheet that listed a vacuum over 27 inches.

I own a Gast pump and it is great for vacuum chuck but they will never pull a hard vacuum.

If you are looking for a used pump you want to look for one from a HVAC shop or a Lab.

If new is in your budget I like Robinair equipment.

http://www.testequipmentdepot.com/robinair/vacuum/15150-15300-15500.htm?ref=gbase&gclid=CIqr26vf0LgCFQ1gMgodBjQA1w

Be aware high vacuum pumps are high maintenance equipment and will put oil in the air that can contaminate wood finishes.

Walta

Re: vaccum pump choice

#9

Pulling 81% max theoretical vacuum

Jimmy Edwards

with my rig at current barometric pressure of 30.09 (22/27.05=81%) Turntex.com has a handy calculator. The 27.05 is the max theoretical vacuum at 2950 altitude and current barometric pressure. 81% may not be too bad to go ahead and experiment with this expensive resin. It was $110 a gal. delivered.

Thanks to each of you for your knowledge and opinions. If or when I learn to post pics I will of this rig.