Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

Posts

OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

#1

Steven Antonucci

OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

steven antonucci

Just got back from an oil change appointment for my 2005 Nissan Frontier. As I pulled out to leave, the tire pressure light came on with a loud, audible alarm. I was hoping that I hadn't picked up a nail, but since I was headed to the dealership and it didn't feel flat, I just drove there without too much concern.

As I started to think about it, I recalled about a year ago, I had the same thing happen. For those of you that do not know how tire pressure systems work, there is an RFID chip in the valve stem that sends a wireless signal (Bluetooth, I think?) to an onboard computer to report the pressure in each tire. The first time that the issue came about, I gave in and had them replace the RFID assembly in the tire @$250.

So the guy comes over and says..."Uh, it looks like the valve...blah blah. $250."

I think to myself, "OK, this is tire #2 to have this issue..." so I have $750 in future repairs coming...and the thing that tells me when the pressure is too low is the actual cause of the pressure being so low? And I have to pay for that?

No.

"How much to replace it with a regular valve stem?"

(I think I floored him with this question?)

$10, but the light will always be on...

Me: Done. I will tape over it with electrical tape so I don't have to look at it.

....

Which brings me to my lathe analogy. What percentage of lathe issues are due to applying superfluous technology? I had a bad bearing once, but almost ever other issue I have ever heard of was due to the electronics frying? Do we really need digital speed readouts? Do we really care if the lathe has a spinddown cycle? Or is that just something we see to create a service market for lathe repair/parts?

No doubt in my mind that the automakers are making these things fragile to feed the need for repair parts. Most cars are carrying 2 dozen computers (why not just 1?) for the various systems.

Discuss amongst yourselves.

Steve

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

#2

Similar situation and question? I was......

JamieDonaldson

...on the Interstate, driving my old Toyota Highlander, caught in a back-up and severe thunderstorm. The check engine light came on, so now what? I cancelled my trip to a club meeting and returned home. Took the vehicle to the dealer for troubleshooting the next day, and they charged me $78 to inform me that my gas cap was loose! My wife had filled up the car the day before, and not done the mandatory 3 clicks when screwing down the cap!

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

#3

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

robo hippy

To err is human, but it takes a computer to really screw things up!

robo hippy

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

#4

Steven Antonucci

another common issue

steven antonucci

Wife had the same issue in the van. before you know it, there will be an RFID tag in the gas cap that detects three click...

S

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

#5

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

waltben

Technology and how it's become used continues to amaze me. I was taught how to maintain vacuum tube computers back in the early sixty's, continuing in IT until retiring ten years back. Not too far back, it was touted as able to improve productivity, eliminate paper, make lives easier and give us more leisure time. Software & hardware maker's needs for profit means continual updates and changes in user interfaces (means having to learn and relearn how to do the same thing). Failures, crashes and privacy needs means having to print out everything important. Finally, my life certainly isn't easier, nor do I have more leisure time when (just one example) I've got to spend days trying to figure out how to use the new 'smart' disposable phone I had to get as my two year old one died. What about trying to hook up that new 'smart' Blu-Ray player & home theater system with it's eighty five function remote?

Tire pressure monitors are just another little thing that was supposed to make us imperfect humans safer, but they never thought about making them reliable or long lasting - just like any other piece of electronics, we're supposed to keep buying them over and over.

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

#6

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

John Veerkamp

When I retired as a computer systems analyst 15 years ago I vowed to never try to keep up with technology to that degree again. If my comp has a problem, if it is more complicated than re-booting or changing minor configurations I have a tech I trust. Best decision I ever made.

I am knowledgeable enough to sort thru the rhetoric and sales pitches, but I don't want to fix the things.

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

#7

Leo Cuellar

semi-applicable to turning...

Leo Cuellar

Is the defective valve stem interesting enough to be used as a finial? Or save it as technological whatnot for an aspiring young steampunk or maker. :)

My old Nissan pickup has an annoying malfunctioning seatbelt buzzer... I'll turn the stereo up when I get around to installing it. :D

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

#8

Re: semi-applicable to turning...

Barry L Elder

Just part of our modern permissive society's bent toward instant gratification. Doesn't make anything better, just allows the LOYL to screw it up too! :D

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

#9

Re: OT: technology rant semi-applicable to turning

charlie belden

Computers do what they're progammed to do.

It is nearly impossible to write a computer program that others will use - and make it idiot proof.

As for why so many computers in today's autos

- small micro computers are cheap (under $25)

- small micro computers require very little power and generate very little heat so don't need

a heat sink or fan

- small micro computers can be placed closer to the source of what they're monitoring

and require fewer wires to their display (idiot light)

- it's esier to find space for several micro computers than one larger computer

- by having several micro computers, each with its own function, you limit the replacement cost

to the unit that failed rather than one larger far more expensive computer

- the more complex a system the more things can go wrong

- a micro computer running a single program is far simpler than one large multi-tasking computer running multiple tasks

the list goes on and on.

Why replacements are so damn expensive - THAT is the mystery? (repairs, replacements = PROFIT!)