Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

New turnings

Posts

New turnings

#1

New turnings

John Lucas

Since I will be John Jordan's assistant at Marc Adams school the first of September I thought I should work on my hand hollowing since I haven't done that in a while. This was magnolia and fairly hard. The neck started cracking as soon as I started hollowing. Haven't had that happen before. I put some CA on it and wrapped the lip with string and soaked that in CA. This isn't going to be a show piece but I didn't want to lose it. After I got it hollowed I turned away the string. The cracks still show of course and since CA isn't permanent it will probably open up some day. Maybe I could make a metal ring for the top to hold it together. :)




Re: New turnings

#2

Re: New turnings

bill Crommett

John: You are creative with the router, could you use the cracks as design starter for a group of star burst contrasting strips ? It would still look like Magnolia, but some colorful strips would be a good contrast.

Re: New turnings

#3

Re: New turnings

John Lucas

Bill I've been thinking about cutting the cracks back open and adding some more. This would sort of accentuate what really wanted to happen to this piece anyway.

I thought about routing or wood burning a texture down the lip but it might open up anyway and cause problems in the future. Might still add the burning after I open up the cracks with my saw. I'll have some time to work on it maybe Thursday. Going to look at a BMW motorcycle today. Hope it fits me. It's about 2 hours away. If I buy it I'm taking the long way home. :)

Re: New turnings

#4

Re: New turnings

Dale Miner

John,

Put the cord back on, the reinforcement adds an appeal of it's own.

Re: New turnings

#5

Don Leydens

Re: New turnings

Don Leydens

I was thinking the same thing. The cord that is.

Re: New turnings

#6

Re: New turnings

Joe Herrmann

I agree John--put the cord back on. It will both hide and reinforce the cracks and add interest.

Re: New turnings

#7

Re: New turnings

Mike Foster

nice vessel John. I know you hate to wait for glue to dry, but you probaly could have made it more permanent by using epoxy. I like the trick of using string soaked in CA though. Never thought of something like that. Certainly seems it would be stronger than using something like duct tape, plus you just turn it away once the hollowing is done. Cool idea.

Re: New turnings

#8

Re: New turnings

John lucas

I think the string wins. I have made string ferrules for some tools and get about 10 years out of them before the ca glue breaks down

Re: New turnings

#9

Ellis Walentine

Why did it crack?

Ellis Walentine

Seems like a likely point for discussion. I've ruined a lot of pieces this way and I'll bet a lot of others have, too.

Could you have avoided this cracking if you had hollowed most of the vase first before thinning out the lip? Cracks like this occur because of the rapid drying of thin sections while there is solid, wetter wood adjacent to it that is preventing it from contracting. If you remove the bulk of the wood so the whole piece can contract at the same rate, it might help.

I've also had cracking like this occur because of the heat of the tool without adequate cooling of the wood. Maybe it would help to keep a spray bottle of H2O handy to cool off the wood?

Thanks for the tip on the string.

Ellis

Re: New turnings

#10

Re: Why did it crack?

John Lucas

You are right Ellis. I haven't done hollow vessels in a while and used keep a spray bottle handy. In this case the log had been sitting in my garage for a year so even though I know it wasn't dry it didn't occur to me that it would be so wet as to crack like that.

I hollow in sort of a stair step way. I hollow a little down the neck and then back to the middle. Next step will be to hollow the neck some more, the next step down some more and then another step in the middle. Repeat until it's hollow stopping when you reach the thickness you want on the side. This does leave the upper neck and shoulder area thin and drying and as I found out, cracking really bad.

I'm glad you pointed that out. I knew better but just haven't hollowed any green wood in so long I forgot.

Re: New turnings

#11

pith??

Jamieson

It is hard to see from the photos but is the pith in the piece?? This can be problematic with the shrinking trying to squeeze into the center of the tree and even with the mouth opening the stresses are severe. My guess is the cracks were in the wood before you started.

Re: New turnings

#12

Re: pith??

John Lucas

The pith is still in the bottom but hasn't caused any problems. I think part of the problem may have been that I didn't cut away all of the cracks in the lip end. I thought I did. It had quite a few. I'm wondering if they simply went deeper than I thought and didn't show until I relieved the stress by hollowing the lip area.

Re: New turnings

#13

Re: New turnings

Dick Coers

Doesn't John make the comment that those cracks were probably already there when you started to turn? At least I thought I've heard him say that during his discussion about turning without cracks forming.

Re: New turnings

#14

Bob Moffett

Re: New turnings

Bob Moffett

John, that is a great idea about using the string and ca glue. I have never heard that one before. Maybe you could do some carving on the rim to eliminate the cracks.