Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

chuck comparison

Posts

chuck comparison

#1

chuck comparison

John Lucas

Chuck comparisons

I am now the proud owner of another chuck. I know do I really need another one. If you have to ask then you aren't really a serious woodturner. :) I have a Vicmarc 100, The Mit-E Bulldog chuck from ChucksPlus, and the Grizzly H6267. I thought you might enjoy a comparison. Granted I have only turned one thing on the Mit-e but my experience with the other chucks tell me a lot about the pros and cons of this one.

All 3 chucks are approximately the same with the Mit-E and Grizzly being copies of the Vicmarc. The jaws and inserts can be swapped between them and the chuck bodies are the same size. The differences are interesting.

All 3 have back dust covers that have index marks. The Mit-e has really small holes on the edge marks which would make them hard to engage, but then I don't of anybody who uses these. I use my index wheel instead of the chuck index holes. The Grizzly dust cover doesn't keep out dust as well as the Vicmarc. Only time will tell on the Mit-e but all the tolerances seem to be as good as the Vicmarc so my bet would be that it will do a pretty good job.

Vicmarc has a setscrew to lock the insert onto the chuck body. The Mit-e does not but has large flats to tighten it up instead of the holes drilled in the Vicmarc and Grizzly. I have deformed the holes in both inserts over the years. This will never happen with the Mit-e. The Mit-e insert screws in cleaner than the others which is just another indication of the care that went into machining this chuck.

The Vicmar and Grizzly use screw that have a 3mm allen which can be stripped fairly easily. The Mit-e used 4mm. Only time will tell if they strip out but the larger size should help prevent this.

The Mit-e has gold jaws that are said to be corrosion resistant. I have owned the other chucks long enough to tell you that the Vicmarc does not rust as easily as the Grizzly.

The Mit-e has jaw numbers stamped on the body of the chuck as well as the ends of the scroll jaws. That makes it quick and easy to place the jaws back in the same slot. The Jaws on the Mit-e have the same “slop” as the Vicmarc jaws. The Grizzly is much looser. This hasn't seemed to affect the actual holding power of the chuck but it gives me an indication of the quality control that goes intop the chucks.

The pin that keeps you from over extending the jaws is a Roll pin on the vicmarc. Very hard to remove if you want to dissassemble the chuck for cleaning. The Grizzly pin was so cheap I bent it sideways somehow over the years so it's completely useless for stopping the jaws and you can't get it out either. The Mit-e uses a set screw. Easy to remove for cleaning and they are usually hardened and hard to break.

I also ordered some 4” jaws for the Mit-e. They are dovetails but came with tiny bead or raised rings on the outside. Don't know if this holds better than smooth jaws or not. It would only be useful in expansion mode of course.

All 3 chucks use 8 mm hex wrenches as the key and all tighten with a clockwise turn.

I guess I might as well put down cost but that is only accurate today 7/19/13. Obviously prices change. Currently the Vicmarc with 1 ¼ insert is $239, The Mit-e $179 and the Grizzly $119.

In the photos the Vicmarc is left, Mit-e middle and Griz on the right.




Re: chuck comparison

#2

Re: chuck comparison

robo hippy

John,

I am trying to figure out the 'raised ring/bead' on the Mit-e chuck. Is that like the tiny detail dove tail on the Nova jaws? '

On a side note, I see that Dave has a new CBN wheel that has radius edges. Made me think about you and your clip on sharpening a hollowing bit where you push it around the edge of the standard grinding wheel, which would not be possible on the other CBN wheels.

robo hippy

Re: chuck comparison

#3

Re: chuck comparison

John Lucas

Reed I'll take a photo later this morning. It's a little raised bead that I guess is designed to help grip the wood better. I assume it would crush the fibers and make the wood take the shape of the beads and grab better. I can't remember exactly how they look but doesn't Oneway have something similar on the inside of their jaws.

Re: chuck comparison

#4

4" jaws

John Lucas

I was incorrect when I said these were dove tail jaws. The 2" jaws are. the 4 inch jaws just have the raised rings on the inside and outside. I must have been tired last night. Here is a photo showing the jaws.

Re: chuck comparison

#5

Re: 4" jaws

robo hippy

I know the Oneway has serrated type jaws on some of their sets. The jaws here are not true dovetail. One turner commented once that most likely if there are going to be that type of bead and detail, it should not be > shaped, but more 7 shaped so that when you tighten it will suck the wood down/jaws up into the wood. That does make a certain amount of sense. I like the plain dove tail like the Vickmark has because it leaves no impressions that need to be turned out later. With my recess, I take a pass to center and one to the inside rim with a Thompson fluteless gouge, and a pass on the dove tail part with a detail gouge, which leaves a 220 grit surface. It is my finished bottom.

robo hippy

Re: chuck comparison

#6

Radius Edge CBN

David Propst

I took Ellsworth's Arrowmont Class in June and bought a D-Way radiused 180 wheel from him. He said he asked Dave for a radiused wheel for sharpening hollowing bits. The increased cost of the radius edge wheel is because it is an entirely separate coating process. David is a big proponent of the CBN wheel, says it produces a better burr and longer life with his gouges. High praise for a true tool minimalist.

David

Re: chuck comparison

#7

Re: Radius Edge CBN

Jeff Smith

You can order the radiused versions either from David Ellsworth or from D-way direct. They're the same 1-1/2" width, but with a 1/4" radius on both edges. 8" only, 80 or 108 grit. Full disclosure - I put Dave's ads together for him - just finished a new for for the radiused wheels for Woodturning Design last week. He's got a new video on his website showing them in use.