Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

Posts

More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#1

More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

charlie belden

Playing in The Visual Arts, probably since I was three or four years old, I've finally gotten around to learning about how our Visual System actually works. If you think about it at all you may think in terms of rays of light reflected off a surface, passing through the lens of our eye and somehow sort of projected on some kind of mental screen with our brain watching what's on the screen.

Turns out that HOW we "see" is pretty complicated and folks are still trying to fill in the details of how it actually seems to work. Seems what we're looking at and what we actually perceive can be quite different, and the pereception is not limitied solely to visual input.

The visual system basically provides WHAT and WHERE. But it also makes associations between what the visual data provides and anything similar to that data, pulling in alll kinds of data, not just visual data, stored in our long term memory. Seeing a particular tree may trigger memories of a similar tree - on the bank of a river - that had a rope swing on a branch overhanging the river - that you use to swing on as a kid of ten or twelve on warm summer days. And seeing that tree may cause you to smile - for no apparent reason.

I think I've also stumbled on one explanation of why a piece on the lathe that looks just right - doesn't look quite right when standing vertically as it will later be viewed. Has to do with our Horizontal stereoscopic field of view vs our Vertical stereoscoplc field of view and the difference between their "aspect ratios".

I've put together a web page with lots of illustrations about how our visual system works, and how it can cause us to PERCEIVE things differently than they actually are.

It's surprising that there's so much information about wood, lathes, tools, turning techniques, sharpening methods, profilesa and proportions, finishes, etc. - and so little about HOW we "see". I've filled in a tiny bit of that gap that you may find useful.

Questions and suggestions for improvements to this stuff or other things to lool into or things you've learned that I missed are all welcomed.


HOW we see - and may or may not perceive

Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#2

Visual Acuity Example

charlie belden

Stare at the RED DOT and, without moving your eyes, notice how little of the shapes, lines and numbers you can actually perceive with any detail. The closer you get, the narrower the area of details you can see. The farther away you get the larger the area in which you can see details - to a point. Farther from that point and details become less crisp. Somewhere between five and ten feet away you're back into not being able to distinguish details much, if at all.

Somewhere between having your nose touching your display screen and 10 feet away there's a Maximum Visual Acuity Distance - where you can see both the Forest AND the Trees - at the same time - metaphorically speaking. That's the viewers vantage point distance that I'm trying to design for - see essentially the form, its profile and proportions AND most of the surface details of the piece.


Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#3

Ellis Walentine

You're amazing, Charlie

Ellis Walentine

Your intellectual curiosity never ceases to amaze me. Apropos of your excellent discussion, and in line with the illustration of plumb vs. out-of-plumb ellipses, I think the eye is somehow tuned to detect the differences between true geometric curves vs. more arbitrary ones. My favorite example of this is the ellipse itself, which is described precisely by a mathematical formula. There is only one true ellipse pollible within any given rectangle, and the eye is extremely discerning in detecting variances from this true elliptical shape. Yet, quasi-ellipses abound in the art world. Same goes for parabolas and hyperbolas and other curves that are described by geometric formulas.

I'm not sure what the upshot for turning is, though, unless you're using a CNC machine. I guess the trick is to be conscious of what true curves are supposed to look like, and concentrate on discerning between those and the rest.

Ellis

Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#4

Re: More on The Vision Thing

Don Orr

Always interesting Charlie! There is a TV show on called "Brain Games" I think, that delves into just this type of subject. Perception-are we seeing what is actually there or is it deception? Cool topic.

Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#5

Working Back To The Starting Point

charlie belden

Ellis wrote:

"I'm not sure what the upshot for turning is, though, unless you're using a CNC machine. I guess the trick is to be conscious of what true curves are supposed to look like, and concentrate on discerning between those and the rest."


Actually it's a more universal thing, not just specific to turning, that I'm looking into.

We all like to show off our finished pieces - well those that we're satisfied or even quite pleased with. And there are plenty of discussions on woods, forms, designs, proportions, tools sharpening and use, turning techniques, finishing methods, "enhancement" methods and techniques - and only rarely - how to present a piece. Because the end result's goal is a "visual arts" object - and the object will be experienced / perceived by a "viewer" - i.e. "Seen" - some understanding of the human Visual System, beyond just "light comes from there, into our eyes and we see it", would seem to be a fundamental piece of information for "visual artists".

The two articles in the AAW's June 2013 American Woodturner issue "Line: An Element of Art and Design" by Tanjia Radda, and "What's My Line" by Jerry Bennett get into some of the fundamental "principles" of good design - det into the the importance of one of the "elements" of good design -"Line". While an awarness of these "principles" and "elements" of good design are refreshing to find in the magazine - what underlies them - the human visual system, how it works and how it influences what we perceive - doesn't seem to have been gotten to and understood, even at a rudimentary level, YET.

I suspect that underlying the visual system and how our brains process visual data, there's an instinctual, primitive, brain stem part of the brain that, to some greater or lesser extent, dictates human universal preferences for forms, shapes, proportions and colors - going back to our Hunter Gatherer ancestors.

Perhaps it was Jesuit teachers I've had that cause me to ask WHY so often. Why are these lines and patterns more attractive than those lines and patterns? Why is this combination of curves more appealing than those combinations of curves? Why are these forms and shapes more interesting than those forms and shapes?

Yes, there are visual arts Principles and Elements that have been discovered and codified. Apply them in your work and you increase the likelyhood that your work will appeal to others. Having an awareness of this information is valuable - if applied well.

But I think there are even more fundamental things to be found, cornerstones for the edifice of knowledge built upon it. And I think these cornerstones are built into our brains - the place where perception occurs. As neuroscience continues to make discoveries of how our brains work, we will have a better understanding of how humans perceive the world around them - including wood turnings.

Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#6

Ellis Walentine

Re: Working Back To The Starting Point

Ellis Walentine

I suspect that underlying the visual system and how our brains process visual data, there's an instinctual, primitive, brain stem part of the brain that, to some greater or lesser extent, dictates human universal preferences for forms, shapes, proportions and colors - going back to our Hunter Gatherer ancestors.

Somewhere I read an article about our visual preferences that said that Western man learned his preference system by some sort of osmosis based on several thousand years of exposure to the Greek system of proportions (Golden Mean, etc.). Aboriginal people from other parts of the world, however, didn't grow up with this consciousness, so their preferences evolved from different roots and remain totally different from ours. That was the gist of article; sorry if I have oversimplified it. Wish I could recall more of the details.

One possible conclusion here is that everyone has a personal visual system, based on nature and nurture, that informs their own work and their appreciation of others' work. In other words, there are no absolutes when it comes to line and form.

Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#7

There must be somthing wrong with my vision system

Scott Crumpton

There must be something wrong with my vision system because for as long as I can remember most of those "optical illusion" graphics haven't work for me. The lines look the same length, the boxes the same size, etc. If not immediately, within a couple seconds of looking at the picture. Even with the trickier ones where you can perceive one or the other of two imbedded images, I can usually switch at will between which image I see. There's even this rotating one that appears to rotate in different directions for different people. Most times I only need to blink and it will be rotating in the other direction. Maybe it's because I know that they're illusions and my mind forces my visual system to overcome it.

Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#8

Re: Working Back To The Starting Point

charlie belden

Our visual system does a lot of visual data processing, and in that processing, makes comparisons with data potentially related that has been stored in our long term memory - to help identify what the incoming visual data means. With that data recall comes associations with that data we'd stored away earlier in our lives.

If we see a cat, a lot of visual, as well as other sensoral data related to the category CAT, may be brought into the process for identification - and reaction. Is THIS cat injured, aggressive, cute, old or young, big or little, healthy or ill? But there also may be emotional reactions - to a fond memory of a cat we knew as a child, a scary memory of being scratched or bit by a cat as a kid. The associations can go beyond this particular cat, or cats in general - a connection made between CAT and a grandmother who loved cats - and grandkids - pampering and spoiling both ; )

I believe, like you, that we have cultural biases built into how we perceive not just visual information - and those cultural biases probably go back, as you noted, centuries or even millenniums. Western culture approaches the world in a very Aristotilian and Euclidian way - logic and rational thinking, seeing the world from Euclidian (Plane) Geometry structure of 3D - length, width, height to fix points in 3D space - and straight lines to describe distance from one point in space to another, surfaces to define volumes in 3D space. We inherit The Golden Ratio bias along with other Greek and Roman civilizations biases. The mindset "If it can't be measured, it doesn't exist" precludes many experiences other cultures have held on to.

Let's take a simple example of cultural bias - and just compare "Western" vs "Eastern", though comparisons of African vs Mid Eastern or Polynesian vs Scandanavian would probably also show significant differences in preferences for shapes, forms and maybe even color.

Close your eyes and visualize what a CASTLE looks like.

If you're of Western Descent it'll likely be of a medievil castle, with tall thick stone walls, towers and ramparts - windows being slits through which to fire arrows - maybe a moat around it - located on a hill top, no trees or many bushes anywhere near it. OR - thanks to the impact of Walt Disney - you might think of the castle in The Magic Kingdom

If you are Japanese, the default image of CASTLE may also be a medievil castle - but with a very different appearance.

Think of an example of Western Art and Oriental Art.

Until quite recent times, Western Art was a representation of a piece of the surroundings - usually with a human being as the center of attention. Oriental Art representing a piece of the surroundings may or may not have a human being in the scene. And if a human being is present, they are a small part of the scene rather than the center of attention. Western Civilization puts the individual at the top of the Importantce List (OK, earlier is was GOD or GODS at the top of the list, then CHRIST, then Saints and eventually mere mortals). Oriental Art tends to put the individual as being only part of something larger, the family, clan, and nation - all part of The Land / Natural Environment.

Western paintings were Provacative - provoking a response - THIS is what I WANT you to SEE. Oriental paintings are more Evocative - providing a minimal amount of visual information - requiring more visual data processing - and more opportunities to bring in a wider range of associations and thus a broader potential range of reactions.

Think of a Western Cultural iconic poem. Now think of a Japanese Haiku.

Think of SWORD. You're likely to think of King Arthur's sword, or a cavalry sword - NOT a samurai sword.

In general, I think the aesthetics of Western Culture is far less refined than that of most Oriental Cultures.

Think about how ideas are conveyed in "writing" - Western Culture uses just 26 letters, even fewer if you're Greek - or Hawaiian. Chinese and Japanese writing are more pictographic, with thousands of individual "characters".

Do Westerner Cultures THINK in WORDS and Oriental Cultures THINK in IMAGES?

What about how we're taught to read? Does that effect how we look at objects? If you're used to reading left to right/top to bottom, will you view something differently than a person who is used to reading right to left/top to bottom, or top left to bottom left THEN acrossed? Read by rows - or read by columns?

So lets say you have three pieces to be displayed together - a small, medium and large piece. Do you display them S, M, L or L, M, S or L, S, M or M, S, L - or . . .?

Will clustering a small group of pieces close together be better than spreading them out quite a bit?

What about putting pieces on different heights? By creating multiple visual horizon lines will that force the visual system to "see" each piece with its own visual horizon line?

Yes, there are cultural biases that effect what we perceive. But underlying those biases, there is probably a universal commonality of how we see/perceive the world around us and objects within it - that is based on how our visual system processes incoming visual data. And with an understanding of that process, it may be possible to create visual art pieces that require most or all of that process - and trigger fuller experiences in the viewer of that piece.

Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#9

Re: There must be somthing wrong with my vision sy

charlie belden

Scott:

There are some types of optical illusions that can be mentally resolved fairly quickly and you probably can do that quicker than the average person, perhaps due to training you've had. Or your visual system may pick up on certain line orientations and ignore of downplay lines in other orientations. As a result the Which One's Longer and Which One's Squarer type illusions are resolved quicker.

Same reason why you can switch back and forth at will when presented with a You Can See A - OR _B, but not both illusions (Inside or Outside The Box, Spinning CW or CCW)

The PacMen & White Triangle illusion is an "A" - AND - "B" illusion that's almost impossible to get around. You can't see just "A" (the PacMen) and not see The White Triangle, even though there is not actual White Triangle. Our visual sytem is hardwired to fill in gaps and make connections. We can recognize that there really is no White Triangle between the PacMen - but we'll still see it anyway.

And that's something anyone working in the visual arts can exploit in order to make a piece hold a viewer's attention longer.

Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#10

Suggestion

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Charlie, I'll bet you'd be interested in a Science Channel show currently running called "To See or Not To See." Check your local listings.

Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#11

Alas my experience with CABLE . . .

charlie belden

and satellite TV has not been very good - and I've tried several providers. Pay for 300 "channels" and only 4 or 5 are of any interest to me - and the providers seem to move them around to get you to go searching through Chinese News, 50 Informercial channels, 25 or 30 "religous channels" that mainly are on to solicit money, 25 channels in spanish, 4 or 5 in Thai, same in Viet Namese, . . . And the $100 a month wasn't anything to sneeze at either. And when I wanted to downgrade service I was told that i had to pay an "upgrade fee" in order to downgrade my service and reduce my monthly cost. It was like falling down the rabbit hole. It was like Wall Street babble "mortgage - backed - securities" - where "securities" had no connection to the word secure other than sounding similar Gambling is risky - "investing" in The Market is not gambling - it's Investing!?

Already having NetFlix I've found that my viewing habit has changed from passive to active. Now I choose what interests me and when that show is over I either choose to watch something related, or do something else that doesn't involve sitting and just watching. AND - there are no commercials to sit thorugh, and turn the volume down when they come on. YouTube is also carrying shows I'd been watching on cable and satellite. Lost some shows I used to watch regularly but have found others I didn't have access to on cable or satellite.

Viewing now is quite different.

Re: More on The Vision Thing *LINK*

#12

Steven Antonucci

look at hulu for the shows