HOLLOW FORM
KEN HAINES
EXACTLY WHAT CONSTITUTES A HOLLOW FORM?
IS IT THE DIAMETER OF THE OPENING IN RELATION TO THE MAX. WIDTH?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
HOLLOW FORM
KEN HAINES
EXACTLY WHAT CONSTITUTES A HOLLOW FORM?
IS IT THE DIAMETER OF THE OPENING IN RELATION TO THE MAX. WIDTH?
Re: HOLLOW FORM
Joe Fleming
Ken,
I don't think I've ever seen a formal definition. Mostly, I know it when I see it. Although this is very subjective, let me suggest that a hollow form requires making with a hollowing tool rather than a bowl gouge. Of course this definition is based upon the skill of the operator.
Years ago, I took a class with Jimmy Clewes and he challenged me to make a closed bowl with only gouges. The vessel was about 9" in diameter and the opening was about 4". The height was between 5" and 6". That took a lot of different bowl grinds to make all the inside curves.
Maybe a better definition would be how the vessel is related to a bowl. We all know what a bowl is and how it functions. When a closed bowl quits serving the function of a bowl and starts just being a container, then that is a hollow form.
Joe
Re: HOLLOW FORM
Brad Vietje
I like to start with classic bowl proportions, with the foot being close to 1/3 the diameter of the piece. If opening is at the widest part, it is an open bowl; if the opening is narrower than the widest part, its a closed form bowl. If the opening is smaller than the foot (roughly 1/3 diameter), its probably a hollow form.
So, what' a vase? A bottle?
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
If
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
it looks like a jar, it might be a "hollowform".
If it looks like a bottle, is hollow, but has holes and voids so it can't hold anything but air, it's definitely a "hollowform", but remember, that's pronounced with clenched teeth and one slightly raised eyebrow. 
Re: We need a committee.............
Joe Fleming
We need an AAW committee to develop a formal definition. Then, they need to circulate USA definition around the world to other woodturning bodies to gain international recognition.
OK - maybe not. 
Re: HOLLOW FORM
barry rockwell
Hi Ken,
The best description I have ever seen said that if the inside of the form cannot be cut with a gouge while riding the bevel. it is a hollow form. Can't remember who said it but it makes sense to me.
Re: How about.........
Jesper, Denmark
If you can see what you are doing inside, then it's a bowl. If not, it's a hollow form 
Re: We need a committee.............
Don in Central Illinois
Joe, remember that a camel is nothing but a horse builtbr committee.
Re: We need a committee.............
Don in Central Illinois
Joe, remember that a camel is nothing but a horse built by a committee.
Agree, I have said it a million times
Re: We need a committee.............
RCH
I can guarantee that it will fail. I have spent 40 years working on archaeological pottery in the Near East. I have worked closely with one colleague for more than 25 years -- we still differ on things as fundamental as definitions of "bowl" vs "pot" vs "jar". Some pieces are clearly one or another, but on some we still disagree.
Don . .
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
That was supposedly a committee of lawyers 
Re: Don . .
Don in Central Illinois
That's worse than I thought.
Re: Worse
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
1 hump or 2?